Extending the Fuel Flexibility From Natural Gas to Low-LHV Fuel: Test Campaign on a Low-NOx Diffusion Flame Combustor

Author(s):  
Nicola Giannini ◽  
Alessandro Zucca ◽  
Christian Romano ◽  
Gianni Ceccherini

Today’s Oil & Gas facility market requires enlarging machines’ fuel flexibility toward two main directions: on the one hand burning fuels with high percentages of Ethane, Butane and Propane, on the other hand burning very lean fuels with a high percentage of inerts. GE has extensive experience in burning a variety of gas fuels and blends in heavy-duty gas turbines. From a technical point of view, the tendency towards leaner fuel gases for feeding gas turbines, introduces potential risks related to combustion instability, on both combustion hardware and machines’ operability. GE Oil&Gas (Nuovo Pignone), has developed a new program aimed to extend the fuel flexibility of its Low-NOx diffusion flame combustor (Lean Head End, or LHE), which currently equips single and dual shaft 30 MW gas turbines, so that it can handle low-LHV fuels. A fuel flexibility test campaign was carried out at full and partial load conditions over an ambient and fuel range, in order to investigate both ignition limits and combustor performances, focusing on hot parts’ temperatures, pollutant emissions and combustion driven pressure oscillations. The pressurized tests were performed on a single combustion chamber, using a dedicated full-scale (full-pressure, full-temperature and full-flow) combustor test cell. Variable composition gaseous fuel mixtures, obtained by mixing natural gas with N2 from 0% up to about 50% vol., were tested. The experienced LHE combustion system up to now had been fed only with natural gas in multi can single gas combustion systems. Combustion system modifications and different burner configurations were considered to enlarge system capabilities, in order to accommodate operation on the previous mentioned range of fuel mixtures, including: nozzle orifice sizing and combustor liner modification. This paper aims to illustrate the upgraded technology and the results obtained. Reported data show combustion system’s performances, mainly in terms of pollutant emissions and operability. The performed test campaign demonstrated the system’s ability to operate at all required loads with diluted natural gases containing up to 50% vol. of N2. Results also indicate that ignition is possible with the same inerts concentration in the fuel, keeping the fuel flow at moderately low levels. As far as load operation, the combustion system proved to be almost insensitive to any tested inerts concentration, while a huge reduction of NOx emissions was observed increasing the molar fraction of N2 in the fuel gas, maintaining good flame stability.

Author(s):  
Stefano Cocchi ◽  
Michele Provenzale ◽  
Gianni Ceccherini

An experimental test campaign, aimed to provide a preliminary assessment of the fuel flexibility of small power gas turbines equipped with Dry Low NOx (DLN) combustion systems, has been carried over a full-scale GE10 prototypical unit, located at the Nuovo-Pignone manufacturing site, in Florence. Such activity is a follow-up of a previous experimental campaign, performed on the same engine, but equipped with a diffusive combustion system. The engine is a single shaft, simple cycle gas turbine designed for power generation applications, rated for 11 MW electrical power and equipped with a DLN silos type combustor. One of the peculiar features of such combustion system is the presence of a device for primary combustion air staging, in order to control flame temperature. A variable composition gaseous fuel mixture has been obtained by mixing natural gas with CO2 up to about 30% vol. inerts concentration. Tests have been carried over without any modification of the default hardware configuration. Tests performed aimed to investigate both ignition limits and combustors’ performances, focusing on hot parts’ temperatures, pollutant emissions and combustion driven pressure oscillations. Results indicate that ignition is possible up to 20% vol. inerts concentration in the fuel, keeping the fuel flow during ignition at moderately low levels. Beyond 20% vol. inerts, ignition is still possible increasing fuel flow and adjusting primary air staging, but more tests are necessary to increase confidence in defining optimal and critical values. Speed ramps and load operation have been successfully tested up to 30% vol. inerts concentration. As far as speed ramps, the only issue evidenced has been risk of flameout, successfully abated by rescheduling combustion air staging. As far as load operation, the combustion system has proven to be almost insensitive to any inerts concentration tested (up to 30% vol.): the only parameter significantly affected by variation in CO2 concentration has been NOx emission. As a complementary activity, a simplified zero-dimensional model for predicting NOx emission has been developed, accounting for fuel dilution with CO2. The model is based on main turbine cycle and DLN combustion system controlling parameters (i.e., compressor pressure ratio, firing temperature, pilot fuel and primary air staging), and has been tuned achieving good agreement with data collected during the test campaign.


Author(s):  
Jeffrey Goldmeer ◽  
William York ◽  
Paul Glaser

The world is currently undergoing a shift in the power industry with an increase in the amount of electrical power being generated from natural gas. This is being driven, in part, by the increase in availability of natural gas derived from shale gas and the reduction in global natural gas prices. In parallel, there is a second trend; a shift of new gas turbines installations to higher efficiency F and HA-class gas turbine combined cycle platforms. Supporting these industry trends, GE’s DLN 2.6+ combustion system, which is available for the 7F, 9F, 7HA, and 9HA gas turbines offers a high degree of operational and fuel flexibility. The latest evolution of this combustion technology for GE’s 7F gas turbines has been commissioned on 25 units, including new units and upgrades to existing turbines. The increased fuel and operational flexibility of this system is aided by GE’s advanced control systems that includes a high fidelity digital twin. This paper details recent developments of the DLN 2.6+ combustion system as well as validation examples for both the DLN 2.6+ and the digital twin controls system.


Author(s):  
Anthony Campbell ◽  
Jeffrey Goldmeer ◽  
Tim Healy ◽  
Roy Washam ◽  
Michel Molie`re ◽  
...  

Gas Turbine fuel flexibility is becoming an increasingly important global issue. The global power sector is being driven by a complex assembly of customer economics, environmental concerns and global political uncertainties to look at cost-effective gas and liquid fuel alternatives without sacrificing plant efficiency and emissions characteristics. In this climate, fuel flexibility includes natural gas, but also expands to non-traditional fuels. GE’s extensive experience with natural gas, industrial and syngas fuels, as well as biofuels segments are surveyed.


Author(s):  
Douglas A. Pennell ◽  
Mirko R. Bothien ◽  
Andrea Ciani ◽  
Victor Granet ◽  
Ghislain Singla ◽  
...  

This paper introduces and presents validation of the Constant Pressure Sequential Combustion system (denoted CPSC), a second generation concept developed for and applied to the new Ansaldo GT36 H-class gas turbine combustors. It has evolved from the well-established sequential burner technology applied to all current GT26 and GT24 gas turbines, and contains all architectural improvements implemented since original inception of this engine frame in 1994, with beneficial effects on the operation turndown, fuel flexibility, on the overall system robustness, and featuring the required aspects to stay competitive in the present day energy market. The applied air and fuel management therefore facilitate emission and dynamics control at both the extremely high and low firing temperature ranges required for existing and future Ansaldo gas turbine engine classes.


Author(s):  
V. G. McDonell ◽  
M. W. Effinger ◽  
J. L. Mauzey

The deployment of small gas turbines at landfills and wastewater treatment plants is attractive due to the availability of waste fuel gases generated at these sites and the need for onsite power and/or heat. The fuel gases produced by these applications typically contain 35 to 75% of the heating value of natural gas and contain methane (CH4) diluted primarily with carbon dioxide (CO2) and sometimes nitrogen (N2). Demonstrations of 30 to 250 kW gas turbines operating on these waste fuels are underway, but little detailed information on the systematic effect of the gas composition on performance is available. Growth in the use of small gas turbines for these applications will likely require that they meet increasingly stringent emission regulations, creating a need to better understand and to further optimize emissions performance for these gases. The current study characterizes a modified commercial natural gas fired 60 kW gas turbine operated on simluated gases of specified composition and establishes a quantitative relationship between fuel composition, engine load, and emissions performance. The results can be used to determine the expected impact of gas composition on emissions performance.


Author(s):  
Kexin Liu ◽  
Varkey Alexander ◽  
Victoria Sanderson ◽  
Ghenadie Bulat

The extension of gas fuel flexibility in the Siemens SGT-300 single shaft (SGT-300-1S) is reported in this paper. A successful development programme has increased the capability of the Siemens Industrial Turbomachinery, Lincoln (SITL) dry low emissions (DLE) burner configuration to a fuel range covering a Wobbe Index (WI) from 15 to 49 MJ/m3. The standard SGT-300-1S SITL DLE combustion hardware allowed for gas and liquid fuels within a specified range typically associated with natural gas and diesel, respectively. Field operation of the standard production SGT-300-1S has confirmed the reliable operation with an extension to the fuels range to include processed land fill gas (PLG) from 32 to 49 MJ/m3. The further extension of the fuel range for the SGT-300-1S SITL DLE combustion system was achieved through high pressure testing of a single combustion system at engine operating conditions. The rig facility allowed for the actual fuel type to be tested using a mixing plant. The variations in fuel heating value were achieved by blending natural gas with diluent CO2 and/or N2. Various diagnostics were used to assess the performance of the combustion system including measurement of combustion dynamics, temperature, fuel supply pressure and emissions of NOx, CO and unburned hydrocarbon (UHC). The results of the testing showed that the standard production burner can operate for a fuel with WI as low as 23 MJ/m3 which corresponds to 35% CO2 (in volume) in the fuel. This range can be extended to 15 MJ/m3 (54.5% CO2 in the fuel) with only minor modification, to control losses through the burner and to maintain similar fuel injection characteristics. The SITL DLE combustion system is able to cover a WI range of 15 to 49 MJ/m3 in two configurations. The results of testing showed a lowering in WI, from diluting with CO2 and/or N2, a benefit in NOx reduction is observed. This decrease in WI may lead to an increased requirement in fuel supply pressure.


Author(s):  
Amin Akbari ◽  
Vincent McDonell ◽  
Scott Samuelsen

Co firing of natural gas with renewable fuels such as hydrogen can reduce greenhouse gas emissions, and meet other sustainability considerations. At the same time, adding hydrogen to natural gas alters combustion properties, such as burning speeds, heating values, flammability limits, and chemical characteristics. It is important to identify how combustion stability relates to fuel mixture composition in industrial gas turbines and burners and correlate such behavior to fuel properties or operating conditions. Ultimately, it is desired to predict and prevent operability issues when designing a fuel flexible gas turbine combustor. Fuel interchangeability is used to describe the ability of a substitute fuel composition to replace a baseline fuel without significantly altering performance and operation. Any substitute fuel, while maintaining the same heating load as the baseline fuel, must also provide stable combustion with low pollutant emissions. Interchangeability indices try to predict the impact of fuel composition on lean blowoff and flashback. Correlations for operability limits have been reported, though results are more consistent for blowoff compared to flashback. Yet, even for blowoff, some disagreement regarding fuel composition effects are evident. In the present work, promising correlations and parameters for lean blow off and flashback in a swirl stabilized lean premixed combustor are evaluated. Measurements are conducted for fuel compositions ranging from pure natural gas to pure hydrogen under different levels of preheat and air flow rates. The results are used to evaluate the ability of existing approaches to predict blowoff and flashback. The results show that, while a Damköhler number approach for blowoff is promising, important considerations are required in applying the method. For flashback, the quench constant parameter suggested for combustion induced vortex breakdown was applied and found to have limited success for predicting flashback in the present configuration.


Author(s):  
Antonio Andreini ◽  
Bruno Facchini ◽  
Luca Mangani ◽  
Stefano Cocchi ◽  
Roberto Modi

Medium- and low-LHV fuels are receiving a continuously growing interest in stationary power applications. Besides that, since in many applications the fuels available at a site can be time by time of significantly different composition, fuel flexibility has become one of the most important requirements to be taken into account in developing power systems. A test campaign, aimed to provide a preliminary assessment of a small power gas turbine’s fuel flexibility, was carried over a full-scale GE10 prototypical unit, located at the Nuovo-Pignone manufacturing site, in Florence. The engine is a single shaft, simple cycle gas turbine designed for power generation applications, rated at 11 MW electrical power and equipped with a silos-type combustor. A variable composition gas fuel was obtained by mixing natural gas with CO2 to about 40% by vol. at engine base-load condition. Tests involved two different diffusive combustion systems: the standard version, designed for operation with natural gas, and a specific system designed for low-LHV fuels. Tests performed aimed to investigate both ignition limits and combustors’ performances, focusing on hot parts’ temperatures and pollutant emissions. Regarding NOx emissions, data collected during standard combustor’s tests were matched a simple scaling law (as a function of cycle parameters and CO2 concentration in the fuel mixture), which can be used in similar applications as a NOx predictive tool. In a following step, a CFD study was performed in order to verify in detail the effects of LHV reduction on flame structure and to compare measured and calculated NOx. STAR-CD™ code was employed as main CFD solver while turbulent combustion and NOx models were specifically developed and implemented using STAR’s user-subroutine features. Both models are based on classical laminar-flamelet approach. Three different operating points were considered at base-load conditions, varying CO2 concentration (0%, 20% and 30% vol. simulated). Numerical simulations point out the flexibility of the GE10 standard combustor to assure flame stabilization even against large variation of fuel characteristics. Calculated NOx emissions are in fairly good agreement with measured data confirming the validity of the adopted models.


Author(s):  
G. J. Kelsall ◽  
M. A. Smith ◽  
H. Todd ◽  
M. J. Burrows

Advanced coal based power generation systems such as the British Coal Topping Cycle offer the potential for high efficiency electricity generation with minimum environmental impact. An important component of the Topping Cycle programme is the development of a gas turbine combustion system to burn low calorific value (3.5–4.0 MJ/m3 wet gross) coal derived fuel gas, at a turbine inlet temperature of 1260°C, with minimum pollutant emissions. The paper gives an overview of the British Coal approach to the provision of a gas turbine combustion system for the British Coal Topping Cycle, which includes both experimental and modelling aspects. The first phase of this programme is described, including the design and operation of a low-NOx turbine combustor, operating at an outlet temperature of 1360°C and burning a synthetic low calorific value (LCV) fuel gas, containing 0 to 1000 ppmv of ammonia. Test results up to a pressure of 8 bar are presented and the requirements for further combustor development outlined.


Author(s):  
Ranjith Malapaty ◽  
Suresh M. V. J. J.

The world is facing complex and mounting environmental challenges. Increased fuel costs and increased market capacity in power generation markets is driving a transformation in power plant operations. Power plants are seeking ways to maximize revenue potential during peak conditions and minimize operational costs during off-peak conditions. Although proven natural gas reserves have increased globally by nearly 50% over the last 20 years, much of this growth has been focused in select regions and countries. In parallel to the discovery of new reserves is the increase in power demand across the globe. However, there are many regions of the globe in which power demand is not being matched by increased local supplies of natural gas, or in infrastructure required to supply natural gas to power generation assets. Given these drivers, there is growing global interest in LNG & alternate fuels. This phenomenon is driving a trend to explore the potential of using LNG fuels which can be easily transported across the globe as an alternative for power generation. In a carbon-constrained environment, the technology trend is for combustion systems capable of burning LNG fuel in combination with delivering the required operability. This paper will focus on developments in GE’s heavy duty gas turbines that enable operation on fuels with varying properties, providing fuel flexibility for sustainable power generation and better emissions compliance. GE’s turbine control system employs physics-based models of gas turbine operability boundaries (e.g., emissions, combustion dynamics, etc.), to continuously estimate current boundary levels and make adjustments as required.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document