Experimental Study of Damper Position on Instabilities in an Annular Combustor

Author(s):  
Marek Mazur ◽  
Håkon T. Nygård ◽  
James Dawson ◽  
Nicholas Worth

The present study experimentally investigates the effects of different circumferential damper configurations on the instabilities in an annular combustor. The combustor consists of multiple bluff body swirl stabilized flames. It is operated with an ethylene-air premixture at a power of 66 kW. Combinations of Helmholtz resonators are used as dampers circumferentially arranged around the combustion chamber. The tests are performed at operating conditions where the combustor is self-excited and characterized by a strong standing mode and periodic mode switching. For each test, the dynamic pressure is measured at different locations and overhead imaging of OH* of the entire combustor is conducted simultaneously at a high sampling frequency. The measurements are then used to compare the pressure fluctuations of the different cases in order to find the best positioning of the dampers. The azimuthal modes in the chamber are determined and the phase shift between OH* and pressure is analysed. Based on the Rayleigh criterion, these investigations allow us to find out if the dampers only remove energy from the pressure oscillations, or if they also influence the instability margins of the combustor and the flame dynamics. Finally, the results are compared with the theoretical findings in literature and observed discrepancies are discussed.

Author(s):  
Jacqueline O’Connor ◽  
Nicholas A. Worth ◽  
James R. Dawson

Azimuthal instabilities are prevalent in annular gas turbine combustors; these instabilities have been observed in industrial systems and research combustors, and have been predicted in simulations. Recent experiments in a model annular combustor have resulted in self-excited, circumferential instability modes at a variety of operating conditions. The instability mode “drifts” between standing and spinning waves, both clockwise and counter-clockwise rotating, during the course of operation. In this study, we analyze the flame response to standing wave modes by comparing the flame dynamics in a self-excited annular combustor with the flame dynamics in a single nozzle, transverse forcing rig. In the model annular combustor, differences in flame fluctuation have been observed at the node and anti-node of the standing pressure wave. Flames at the pressure anti-node display symmetric fluctuations, while flames at the pressure node execute asymmetric, flapping motions. This flame motion has been measured using both OH* chemiluminescence and planar laser induced fluorescence of OH radicals. To better understand these flame dynamics, the time-resolved velocity fields from a transverse forcing experiment are presented, and show that such a configuration can capture the symmetric and asymmetric disturbance fields at similar frequency ranges. Using high-speed PIV in multiple planes of the flow, it has been found that symmetric ring vortex shedding is driven by pressure fluctuations at the pressure anti-node whereas helical vortex disturbances drive the asymmetric flame disturbances at pressure nodes. By comparing the results of these two experiments, we are able to more fully understand flame dynamics during self-excited combustion instability in annular combustion chambers.


Author(s):  
Matthias Haeringer ◽  
Guillaume J. J. Fournier ◽  
Max Meindl ◽  
Wolfgang Polifke

Abstract Thermoacoustic properties of can-annular combustors are commonly investigated by means of single-can test-rigs. To obtain representative results, it is crucial to mimic can-can coupling present in the full engine. However, current approaches either lack a solid theoretical foundation or are not practicable for high-pressure rigs. In the present study we employ Bloch-wave theory to derive reflection coefficients that correctly represent can-can coupling. We propose a strategy to impose such reflection coefficients at the acoustic terminations of a single-can test-rig by installing passive acoustic elements, namely straight ducts or Helmholtz resonators. In an iterative process, these elements are adapted to match the reflection coefficients for the dominant frequencies of the full engine. The strategy is demonstrated with a network model of a generic can-annular combustor and a 3D model of a realistic can-annular combustor configuration. For the latter we show that can-can coupling via the compressor exit plenum is negligible for frequencies sufficiently far away from plenum eigenfrequencies. Without utilizing previous knowledge of relevant frequencies or flame dynamics, the test-rig models are adapted within a few iterations and match the full engine with good accuracy. Using Helmholtz resonators for test-rig adaption turns out to be more viable than using straight ducts.


Author(s):  
Matthias Haeringer ◽  
Guillaume Jean Jacques Fournier ◽  
Maximilian Meindl ◽  
Wolfgang Polifke

Abstract Thermoacoustic properties of can-annular combustors are commonly investigated by means of single-can test-rigs. To obtain representative results, it is crucial to mimic can-can coupling present in the full engine. However, current approaches either lack a solid theoretical foundation or are not practicable for high-pressure rigs. In the present study we employ Bloch-wave theory to derive reflection coefficients that correctly represent can-can coupling. We propose a strategy to impose such reflection coefficients at the acoustic terminations of a single-can test-rig by installing passive acoustic elements, namely straight ducts or Helmholtz resonators. In an iterative process, these elements are adapted to match the reflection coefficients for the dominant frequencies of the full engine. The strategy is demonstrated with a network model of a generic can-annular combustor and a 3D model of a realistic can-annular combustor configuration. For the latter we show that can-can coupling via the compressor exit plenum is negligible for frequencies sufficiently far away from plenum eigenfrequencies. Without utilizing previous knowledge of relevant frequencies or flame dynamics, the test-rig models are adapted within a few iterations and match the full engine with good accuracy. Using Helmholtz resonators for test-rig adaption turns out to be more viable than using straight ducts.


Author(s):  
Philipp Jenny ◽  
Yves Bidaut

Unshrouded centrifugal compressor impellers typically operate at high rotational speeds and volume flow rates. The resulting high mean stress levels leave little margin for dynamic excitations that can cause high cycle fatigue. In addition to the well-established high frequency impeller blade excitations of centrifugal compressors caused by the stationary parts, such as vaned diffusers or inlet guide vanes, the presented study addresses an unsteady rotating flow feature (rotating stall) which should be taken into account when addressing high cycle fatigue during the design phase. The unsteady fluid-structure interaction between rotating stall and unshrouded impellers was experimentally described and quantified during two different measurement campaigns with two full-size compression units operating under real conditions. In both campaigns dynamic strain gauges and pressure transducers were mounted at various locations on the impeller of the first compression stage. The casing was also equipped with a set of dynamic pressure transducers to complement the study. Rotating pressure fluctuations were found to form an additional impeller excitation at a frequency that is not a multiple of the shaft speed. The measurements show that the excitation amplitude and frequency caused by the rotating pressure fluctuations depend on the operating conditions and are therefore challenging to predict and consider during the design phase. Furthermore, the excitation mechanism presented was found to cause resonant impeller blade response under specific operating conditions. For the experimentally investigated impeller geometries a rotating pressure fluctuation caused approximately 1.5 MPa of additional dynamic stress in the structure per 1 mbar of dynamic pressure amplitude when exciting the first bending mode of the impeller. The induced dynamic mechanical stresses due to rotating stall are in the order of 10% of the endurance limit of the material for the tested impeller geometries, therefore they are not critical and confirm a robust and reliable design.


Author(s):  
Tim Lieuwen

This paper describes a strategy for determining a combustor’s dynamic stability margin. Currently, when turbines are being commissioned or simply going through day to day operation, the operator has no idea how the dynamic stability of the system is affected by changes to fuel splits/operating conditions unless, of course, pressure oscillations are actually present. We have developed a methodology for ascertaining stability margin from passive monitoring of the acoustic pressure. This method consists of signal processing and analysis that determines a real-time measure of combustor damping. When the calculated damping is positive, the combustor is stable. When the damping goes to zero, the combustor approaches its stability boundary. Changes in the stability margin of each of the combustor’s stable modes due to tuning, aging or environmental changes can then be monitored through online analysis of the pressure signal. This paper outlines the basic approach used to quantify acoustic damping and demonstrates the technique on combustor test data.


2016 ◽  
Vol 139 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Philipp Jenny ◽  
Yves Bidaut

Unshrouded centrifugal compressor impellers typically operate at high rotational speeds and volume flow rates. The resulting high mean stress levels leave little margin for dynamic excitations that can cause high-cycle fatigue. In addition to the well-established high-frequency impeller blade excitations of centrifugal compressors caused by the stationary parts, such as vaned diffusers or inlet guide vanes (IGVs), the presented study addresses an unsteady rotating flow feature (rotating stall) which should be taken into account when addressing the high-cycle fatigue during the design phase. The unsteady fluid–structure interaction between rotating stall and unshrouded impellers was experimentally described and quantified during two different measurement campaigns with two full-size compression units operating under real conditions. In both campaigns, dynamic strain gauges and pressure transducers were mounted at various locations on the impeller of the first compression stage. The casing was also equipped with a set of dynamic pressure transducers to complement the study. Rotating pressure fluctuations were found to form an additional impeller excitation at a frequency that is not a multiple of the shaft speed. The measurements show that the excitation amplitude and frequency caused by the rotating pressure fluctuations depend on the operating conditions and are therefore challenging to predict and consider during the design phase. Furthermore, the excitation mechanism presented was found to cause resonant impeller blade response under specific operating conditions. For the experimentally investigated impeller geometries, a rotating pressure fluctuation caused approximately 1.5 MPa of additional dynamic stress in the structure per 1 mbar of dynamic pressure amplitude when exciting the first bending mode of the impeller. The induced dynamic mechanical stresses due to rotating stall are in the order of 10% of the endurance limit of the material for the tested impeller geometries; therefore, they are not critical and confirm a robust and reliable design.


Author(s):  
John E. Barnes

The effect of combustion dynamic pressure oscillations on the structural integrity of the MS 7001F dry low NOX 2 (DLN 2) combustion system has been evaluated using ANSYS [ref. 1] finite element analyses and high cycle fatigue material data. Analytical results were validated with laboratory measurements on the combustion system subjected to combustion dynamic pressure at actual gas turbine temperature and pressure operating conditions. The combustion liner, transition piece, impingement sleeve and supports were proven to have excellent durability when subjected to dynamic loads. No risk of structural failure exists at anticipated dynamic pressures using assumptions shown to be conservative.


Author(s):  
W. Y. Kwong ◽  
A. M. Steinberg

This paper describes the coupled flow and flame dynamics during blowoff and reattachment events in a combustor consisting of a linear array of five interacting nozzles using 10 kHz repetition-rate OH planar laser induced fluorescence and stereoscopic particle image velocimetry. Steady operating conditions were studied at which the three central flames randomly blew-off and subsequently reattached to the bluff-bodies. Transition of the flame from one nozzle was rapidly followed by transition of the other nozzles, indicating cross-nozzle coupling. Blow-off transitions were preferentially initiated in one of the off-center nozzles, with the transition of subsequent nozzles occurring in a random order. Similarly, the center nozzle tended to be the last nozzle to reattach. The blowoff process of any individual nozzle was similar to that for a single bluff-body stabilized flame, though with cross-flame interactions providing additional means of re-stabilizing a partially extinguished flame. Subsequent to blowoff of the first nozzle, the other nozzles underwent similar blowoff processes. Flame reattachment was initiated by entrainment of a burning pocket into a recirculation zone, followed by transport to the bluff-body; the other nozzles subsequently underwent similar reattachment processes. Several forms of cross-nozzle interaction that can promote or prevent transition are identified. Furthermore, the velocity measurements indicated that blowoff or reattachment of the first nozzle during a multi-nozzle transition causes significant changes to the flow fields of the other nozzles. It is proposed that a single nozzle transition redistributes the flow to the other nozzles in a manner that promotes their transition.


1999 ◽  
Vol 121 (4) ◽  
pp. 850-856 ◽  
Author(s):  
T. Tanaka ◽  
H. Tsukamoto

In the 1st report, the dynamic behavior of a cavitating centrifugal pump was related to the transient phenomena at the sudden opening/closure of the discharge valve. In this paper, the experimental study was extended to the transient behavior of the cavitating centrifugal pump at rapid starting/stopping of the pump. Unsteady pressures and flowrate were related to time-dependent cavitation behavior in a similar manner as for the rapid operation of the discharge valve. As a result of the present study, pressure fluctuations were found to occur due to water column separation at the sudden stop of the pump similarly to pressure oscillations associated with the sudden closure of the discharge valve. Moreover, the experimental results on the transient behavior at pump startup indicated that the transient fluctuations of delivery pressure and discharge flowrate are caused by oscillating cavitation similarly to the ones occurring at the opening of the discharge valve.


2005 ◽  
Vol 127 (3) ◽  
pp. 478-482 ◽  
Author(s):  
Tim Lieuwen

This paper describes a strategy for determining a combustor’s dynamic stability margin. Currently, when turbines are being commissioned or simply going through day to day operation, the operator does not know how the stability of the system is affected by changes to fuel splits or operating conditions unless, of course, pressure oscillations are actually present. We have developed a methodology for ascertaining the stability margin from dynamic pressure data that does not require external forcing and that works even when pressure oscillations have very low amplitudes. This method consists of signal processing and analysis that determines a real-time measure of combustor damping. When the calculated damping is positive, the combustor is stable. As the damping goes to zero, the combustor approaches its stability boundary. Changes in the stability margin of each of the combustor’s stable modes due to tuning, aging, or environmental changes can then be monitored through an on-line analysis of the pressure signal. This paper outlines the basic approach used to quantify acoustic damping and demonstrates the technique on combustor test data.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document