Application of Plastic Region Bolt Tightening to Flange Joint Assembly: Behavior of Large Diameter Flange

Author(s):  
Shinobu Kaneda ◽  
Hirokazu Tsuji

In the past study the plastic region tightening has been applied to the bolted flange joint with smaller nominal diameter and its advantages have been demonstrated, however, behavior of the bolted flange joint with larger diameter is not investigated. Flange rotation of the bolted flange joint with large diameter increases when the internal pressure is applied. Gasket stress is not uniform and it may cause leak accident. So, it is necessary to investigate the behavior of the larger diameter flange. The present paper describes the behavior of bolted flange joint with large diameter under plastic region tightening. Firstly, API 20-inch flange joint tightened to the plastic region by bolt with a smaller diameter and superiority in the uniformity of the axial bolt force is demonstrated. And then the internal pressure is applied to the bolted flange joint and the behavior of the additional axial bolt force is demonstrated. The axial bolt force decreases with increasing the internal pressure, and the load factor is negative due to increasing of the flange rotation. However, the load factor of the bolted flange joint tightened to the plastic region by using the bolt with the smaller diameter approached zero. Using the bolts with smaller diameter is advantageous to the flange joint with the larger diamter, whose load factor is negative, to prevent the leakage. Additionally, the leak rate from the bolted flange joint is measured and the sufficient sealing performance is obtained.

Author(s):  
Shinobu Kaneda ◽  
Yoshiyasu Shimizu ◽  
Satoshi Nagata ◽  
Hirokazu Tsuji

In the past study the plastic region tightening has been applied to the compact flange joint and its advantages have been demonstrated. However, behavior of the compact flange joint subjected to the thermal load is not investigated. There are reduction of the gasket stiffness, the flange rotation, and difference in the thermal expansion among the members making up the flange joint. It is well known that these problems cause the change in axial bolt force. The present paper describes the behavior of the compact flange joint subjected to the thermal load under the plastic region tightening. Since there is a difference in temperature between the compact flange joint and the bolts, the axial bolt force increases as the temperature of the internal fluid increases. The additional axial bolt force is positive when the thermal loads are applied to the compact flange joint. However, the additional axial bolt force was approximately 3% of the bolt yield force at maximum and the bolt had a sufficient margin for the allowable limit. Additionally, the load factor depends on the change in the elastic modulus due to change in temperature of the internal fluid.


Author(s):  
Tsutomu Kikuchi ◽  
Yuya Omiya ◽  
Toshiyuki Sawa

The effects of nut thinning due to corrosion on the strength characteristic and the sealing performance in 3B bolted flange joints under internal pressure are examined from both FEM calculations and experiments. The following results are obtained. When bolts and nuts in a bolted flange joint are tightened with 50% of yield stress, no yield region at the engaged screw thread occurs, however, when they arc tightened with 90% of the yield stress, a small scale yield region occurs at the roots of the engaged three screw threads from the bearing surface of the nut. While verifying this phenomenon using FEM, it was newly discovered that when the height of the nut was reduced to 1/3 (equivalent to approximately two threads) of the original dimensions according to the standards, the sealing performance could no longer be assured.


2019 ◽  
Vol 795 ◽  
pp. 246-253
Author(s):  
Fa Kun Zhuang ◽  
Xiao Peng Li ◽  
Guo Shan Xie ◽  
Jin Shi ◽  
Yian Wang

Leakage accidents often occur at the bolted flange joints, which are widely used in the petro-chemical plant. This is mainly resulted by the reduction of bolt force during operation. Therefore, bolt force is very important for sealing performance of the joints in service. Based on the leakage rate parameter, the relationship between the bolt force and gasket stress was derived. Moreover, the leakage rate model was established on the basis of bolt force. With this model, the leakage rate can be directly calculated through the bolt force, and the sealing performance can be evaluated. In order to verify this model, corresponding experiments have been performed. It shows that with the internal pressure increasing, the bolt force increases and the gasket stress reduces. There exists a monotonic relationship between the bolt force and gasket stress. The theoretical gasket stress value corresponds well with the experimental value. The calculated leakage rates for the joints also agree well with the experimental value. Then, it is feasible to evaluate the sealing performance for the bolted flange joints based on the bolt force.


Author(s):  
Shinobu Kaneda ◽  
Hirokazu Tsuji

Elastic region tightening by means of the torque control method is a conventional method to tighten bolts. The bolt axial force is controlled by a torque wrench; however, it is not easy to achieve constant bolt axial force. When the torque control method is applied to the flange joint assembly, the scatter of the bolt axial force is significant with respect to the joint reliability, such that it may cause leakage of the internal fluid from the flange joint. Recently, plastic region tightening has received considerable attention, which provides good uniformity in the bolt axial force. In a previous study, plastic region tightening was applied to a flange joint assembly, and the superior uniformity of the bolt axial force was demonstrated. The present paper describes the behavior of the plastic region tightening bolt in a flange joint subjected to internal pressure. First, the flange joint is tightened to the plastic region using a downsized bolt. The internal pressure is then applied to the flange joint, and the behavior of the additional bolt axial force is investigated. Application of plastic region tightening to the flange joint assembly is found to be effective for obtaining leak-free joints and for downsizing of the nominal diameter of the bolt. The behavior of the bolt axial force in a flange joint subjected to internal pressure was clarified. The additional bolt axial force has a sufficient margin for the allowable limit.


Author(s):  
Shinobu Kaneda ◽  
Hirokazu Tsuji

The present paper describes the behavior of plastic region tightening of a bolt in a downsized flange joint subjected to internal pressure. An API 4-inch flange joint is downsized for plastic region tightening. The bolt is reduced from M16 to M8, and the bolt pitch circle diameter and the outer diameter of the flange are decreased by 11%. The flange rigidity and the stresses of the compact flange joint are calculated and are superior to the original API flange joint. The bolt spacing is also examined, and the correction factor for bolt spacing is acceptable. Internal pressure is applied to a compact flange joint, and the behavior of additional bolt force is demonstrated. Load factor depends on the type of gasket, such that the load factor is positive for a flexible graphite sheet gasket. The load factor is in agreement with the value calculated by the Load Factor Method (LFM). When the external force is applied to the bolted joint under plastic region tightening, the allowable limit of the additional bolt force is approximately 10% of the bolt yield force. In the present experiment, the additional bolt force is as small as 1% of the bolt yield force. Therefore, the additional bolt force has sufficient margin for the allowable limit.


Author(s):  
Muhammad Abid ◽  
Javed A. Chattha ◽  
Kamran A. Khan

Performance of a bolted flange joint is characterized mainly by its ‘strength’ and ‘sealing capability’. A number of analytical and experimental studies have been conducted to study these characteristics only under internal pressure loading. In the available published work, thermal behavior of the pipe flange joints is discussed under steady state loading with and without internal pressure and under transient loading condition without internal pressure. The present design codes also do not address the effects of steady state and thermal transient loading on the structural integrity and sealing ability. It is realized that due to the ignorance of any applied transient thermal loading, the optimized performance of the bolted flange joint can not be achieved. In this paper, in order to investigate gasketed joint’s performance i.e. joint strength and sealing capability under combined internal pressure and transient thermal loading, an extensive nonlinear finite element analysis is carried out and its behavior is discussed.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document