Girdler (1968, pp. 1102-1105) has suggested that transform faults may exist in the Red Sea depression. A possible left-handed transform fault, trending at 050°, and centred on 19°N 39°E was plotted (Girdler 1968, fig. 1). This is supposed to offset the axial trough, and run on to the land, where it is shown displacing the ‘marginal structure lines’ and the Mesozoic and Tertiary sedimentary/Basement Complex contact by about 50 km. Girdler (1968) cites Sykes (in
History of the Earth's crust
, Nasa, Symposium) as providing supporting first motion evidence of transform movement along this proposed fault. However Isaacs, Sykes & Oliver (1968, fig. 5) show a left-handed transform ‘earthquake mechanism’ bearing 020° for a centre associated with the axial trough at 17°N, 40° 30' E. Because of the proximity of these centres, the 30° difference in trend, and the scarcity of Red Sea earthquake data, the question arises are Girdler and Isaacs
et al
. dealing with the same centres ? More data and an explanation are required as there are few places in the world where undisputed transform faults have been described from the land and sea. Girdler’s proposed transform fault is therefore extremely important both from a local Red Sea and a global structural view.