scholarly journals Intercomparison between Switch 2.0 and GE MAPS Models for Simulation of High-Renewable Power Systems in Hawaii

Author(s):  
Matthias Fripp

Background: New open-source electric-grid planning models have the potential to improve power system planning and bring a wider range of stakeholders into the planning process for next-generation, high-renewable power systems. However, it has not yet been established whether open-source models perform similarly to the more established commercial models for power system analysis. This reduces their credibility and attractiveness to stakeholders, postponing the benefits they could offer. In this paper, we report the first model intercomparison between an open-source power system model and an established commercial production cost model. Results: We compare the open-source Switch 2.0 to GE Energy Consulting’s Multi Area Production Simulation (MAPS), considering 18 scenarios of renewable energy adoption in Hawaii. We find that after configuring Switch with similar inputs to MAPS, the two models agree closely on hourly and annual production from all power sources. Comparing production gave an R2 value of 0.996 across all energy sources and scenarios, with R2 values in the range of 69–100 percent for individual sources. Conclusions: Although some disagreement remains between the two models, this work indicates that Switch is a viable choice for renewable integration modeling, at least for the small power systems considered here.

Author(s):  
Matthias Fripp

Background: New open-source electric-grid planning models have the potential to improve power system planning and bring a wider range of stakeholders into the planning process for next-generation, high-renewable power systems. However, it has not yet been established whether open-source models perform similarly to the more established commercial models for power system analysis. This reduces their credibility and attractiveness to stakeholders, postponing the benefits they could offer. In this paper, we report the first model intercomparison between an open-source power system model and an established commercial production cost model. Results: We compare the open-source Switch 2.0 to GE Energy Consulting’s Multi Area Production Simulation (MAPS) for production-cost modeling, considering hourly operation under 17 scenarios of renewable energy adoption in Hawaii. We find that after configuring Switch with similar inputs to MAPS, the two models agree closely on hourly and annual production from all power sources. Comparing production gave a coefficient of determination of 0.996 across all energy sources and scenarios, indicating that the two models agree on 99.6% of the variation. For individual energy sources, the coefficient of determination was 69–100. Conclusions: Although some disagreement remains between the two models, this work indicates that Switch is a viable choice for renewable integration modeling, at least for the small power systems considered here. Although some disagreement remains between the two models, this work indicates that Switch is a viable choice for renewable integration modeling, at least for the small power systems considered here.


2021 ◽  
Vol 15 ◽  
pp. 73-79
Author(s):  
Jan Veleba ◽  
Tomáš Nestorovič

Nowadays, electric power systems have been often operated close to their limits due to increased electric power consumptions, vast installments of renewable power sources and deliberated power market policies. This poses a serious threat to stable network operation and control. Therefore, voltage stability is currently one of key topics worldwide for preventing related black-out and islanding scenarios. In this paper, modelling and simulations of steady-state voltage stability problems in MATLAB environment are performed using author-developed computational tool implementing both conventional and more advanced numerical approaches. Their performance is compared with Simulink-based library Power System Analysis Toolbox (PSAT) in terms of solution accuracy, CPU time, and possible limitations. Their use for both real-time and off-line monitoring and assessment of system's voltage stability are also discussed.


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Gilles Mpembele ◽  
Jonathan Kimball

<div>The analysis of power system dynamics is usually conducted using traditional models based on the standard nonlinear differential algebraic equations (DAEs). In general, solutions to these equations can be obtained using numerical methods such as the Monte Carlo simulations. The use of methods based on the Stochastic Hybrid System (SHS) framework for power systems subject to stochastic behavior is relatively new. These methods have been successfully applied to power systems subjected to</div><div>stochastic inputs. This study discusses a class of SHSs referred to as Markov Jump Linear Systems (MJLSs), in which the entire dynamic system is jumping between distinct operating points, with different local small-signal dynamics. The numerical application is based on the analysis of the IEEE 37-bus power system switching between grid-tied and standalone operating modes. The Ordinary Differential Equations (ODEs) representing the evolution of the conditional moments are derived and a matrix representation of the system is developed. Results are compared to the averaged Monte Carlo simulation. The MJLS approach was found to have a key advantage of being far less computational expensive.</div>


Energies ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (3) ◽  
pp. 737
Author(s):  
Michał Kosmecki ◽  
Robert Rink ◽  
Anna Wakszyńska ◽  
Roberto Ciavarella ◽  
Marialaura Di Somma ◽  
...  

Along with the increasing share of non-synchronous power sources, the inertia of power systems is being reduced, which can give rise to frequency containment problems should an outage of a generator or a power infeed happen. Low system inertia is eventually unavoidable, thus power system operators need to be prepared for this condition. This paper addresses the problem of low inertia in the power system from two different perspectives. At a system level, it proposes an operation planning methodology, which utilises a combination of power flow and dynamic simulation for calculation of existing inertia and, if need be, synthetic inertia (SI) to fulfil the security criterion of adequate rate of change of frequency (RoCoF). On a device level, it introduces a new concept for active power controller, which can be applied virtually to any power source with sufficient response time to create synthetic inertia. The methodology is demonstrated for a 24 h planning period, for which it proves to be effective. The performance of SI controller activated in a battery energy storage system (BESS) is positively validated using a real-time digital simulator (RTDS). Both proposals can effectively contribute to facilitating the operation of low inertia power systems.


2015 ◽  
Vol 35 (1Sup) ◽  
pp. 42-49 ◽  
Author(s):  
Luis Fernando Rodríguez-García ◽  
Sandra Milena Pérez-Londoño ◽  
Juan José Mora-Flórez

<span>Current electric power systems have an increasing penetration of electric vehicles, and its effect has to be considered in different <span>studies, such as optimal dispatch or voltage stability, among others. Additionally, considering that power system analysis becomes <span>complex when the number of buses increase, this paper presents a methodology for aggregation of load areas that use a measurement-based load modeling approach based on an evolutionary computational technique and a classical reduction method. This aggregate <span>load area model is proposed to reduce areas that consider electric vehicle (EV) load models. The proposed method provides a static <span>equivalent load model and an equivalent network that can be used to reduce the computational effort required by power system<br /><span>studies. In order to validate the application of the proposed methodology, a 30-bus power system considering several disturbances <span>and levels of penetration of the electric vehicles was used. The results show that the equivalent network model allows the reproduction <span>of different events with an acceptable accuracy when it is compared to the original system behavior.</span></span></span></span></span></span></span><br /><br class="Apple-interchange-newline" /></span>


2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Congmei Jiang ◽  
Yongfang Mao ◽  
Yi Chai ◽  
Mingbiao Yu

<p>With the increasing penetration of renewable resources such as wind and solar, the operation and planning of power systems, especially in terms of large-scale integration, are faced with great risks due to the inherent stochasticity of natural resources. Although this uncertainty can be anticipated, the timing, magnitude, and duration of fluctuations cannot be predicted accurately. In addition, the outputs of renewable power sources are correlated in space and time, and this brings further challenges for predicting the characteristics of their future behavior. To address these issues, this paper describes an unsupervised method for renewable scenario forecasts that considers spatiotemporal correlations based on generative adversarial networks (GANs), which have been shown to generate high-quality samples. We first utilized an improved GAN to learn unknown data distributions and model the dynamic processes of renewable resources. We then generated a large number of forecasted scenarios using stochastic constrained optimization. For validation, we used power-generation data from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory wind and solar integration datasets. The experimental results validated the effectiveness of our proposed method and indicated that it has significant potential in renewable scenario analysis.</p>


2020 ◽  
Vol 12 (2) ◽  
pp. 518
Author(s):  
Yue Chen ◽  
Zhizhong Guo ◽  
Hongbo Li ◽  
Yi Yang ◽  
Abebe Tilahun Tadie ◽  
...  

With the increasing proportion of uncertain power sources in the power grid; such as wind and solar power sources; the probabilistic optimal power flow (POPF) is more suitable for the steady state analysis (SSA) of power systems with high proportions of renewable power sources (PSHPRPSs). Moreover; PSHPRPSs have large uncertain power generation prediction error in day-ahead dispatching; which is accommodated by real-time dispatching and automatic generation control (AGC). In summary; this paper proposes a once-iterative probabilistic optimal power flow (OIPOPF) method for the SSA of day-ahead dispatching in PSHPRPSs. To verify the feasibility of the OIPOPF model and its solution algorithm; the OIPOPF was applied to a modified Institute of Electrical and Electronic Engineers (IEEE) 39-bus test system and modified IEEE 300-bus test system. Based on a comparison between the simulation results of the OIPOPF and AC power flow models; the OIPOPF model was found to ensure the accuracy of the power flow results and simplify the power flow model. The OIPOPF was solved using the point estimate method based on Gram–Charlier expansion; and the numerical characteristics of the line power were obtained. Compared with the simulation results of the Monte Carlo method; the point estimation method based on Gram–Charlier expansion can accurately solve the proposed OIPOPF model


Energies ◽  
2019 ◽  
Vol 13 (1) ◽  
pp. 92 ◽  
Author(s):  
Antonio T. Alexandridis

In stability studies, the response of a system enforced by external, known or unknown, inputs is of great importance. Although such an analysis is quite easy for linear systems, it becomes a cumbersome task when nonlinearities exist in the system model. Nevertheless, most of the real-world systems are externally enforced nonlinear systems with nonzero equilibriums. Representative examples in this category include power systems, where studies on stability and convergence to equilibrium constitute crucial objectives. Driven by this need, the aim of the present work is twofold: First, to substantially complete the theoretical infrastructure by establishing globally valid sufficient conditions for externally enforced nonlinear systems that converge to nonzero equilibriums and, second, to deploy an efficient method easily applicable on practical problems as it is analyzed in detail on a typical power system example. To that end, in the theoretical first part of the paper, a rigorous nonlinear analysis is developed. Particularly, starting from the well-established nonlinear systems theory based on Lyapunov techniques and on the input-to-state stability (ISS) notion, it is proven after a systematic and lengthy analysis that ISS can also guarantee convergence to nonzero equilibrium. Two theorems and two corollaries are established to provide the sufficient conditions. As shown in the paper, the main stability and convergence objectives for externally enforced systems are fulfilled if simple exponential or asymptotic converging conditions can be proven for the unforced system. Then, global or local convergence is established, respectively, while for the latter case, a novel method based on a distance-like measure for determining the region of attraction (RoA) is proposed. The theoretical results are examined on classic power system generation nonlinear models. The power system examples are suitably selected in order to effectively demonstrate the proposed method as a stability analysis tool and to validate all the particular steps, especially that of evaluating the RoA. The examined system results clearly verify the theoretical part, indicating a rather wide range of applications in power systems.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document