Equally Performing, Unfairly Evaluated The social determinants of grade repetition in Italian high schools
Grade repetition requires students with lower performance in comparison with their peers to repeat the same grade for an additional year. Educators and parents generally favour such policy. The distribution of grade repetition among different levels of education varies across educational systems, but, in general, all European countries rely on grade repetition to improve performance of students. Yet, little attention has been paid to the link between grade repetition and inequality in educational opportunities. By relying on an ad-hoc large panel dataset which collects the population of secondary school students in three northern Italian regions, the present paper asks to which extent disadvantaged students (in terms of parents’ educational title and migration background) incur in grade repetition on top of prior performance differences. The paper also contributes to further the understanding of the interaction between school context (in terms of track and social composition) and family background in determining a grade repetition. Italy is a relevant case study in the European context; as in other southern European countries, grade repetition typically occurs during high school, significantly fluctuates across tracks, and teachers have a high degree of discretion in implementing this remedial policy. This paper suggests to carefully use grade repetition - especially with regard to students with a disadvantaged economic and social background. Among students with comparable (poor) performance, the risk of grade repetition is substantially higher for students with low educated or migrant parents. By contrast, grade repetition for students with highly educated parents is smaller in academic tracks and schools with a large share of students with tertiary-educated parents. The paper critically assesses likely justification for the observed inequalities in grade repetition such as differences in parents’ support and teachers’ expectations.