THE MYTH OF CSR ON THE EXAMPLE OF DOVE CAMPAIGN

Author(s):  
Aneta Duda

"This article discusses the concept of corporate social responsibility (CSR) in the particular case of a controversial Dove campaign for Real Beauty (CFRB) and its role in the production and consumption of contemporary popular meanings of empowerment, social change, and female beauty in global consumer culture. Because in some instances such corporate strategies appear well received, we move beyond cynical dismissal to analyze corporate discourse to identify its transformative possibilities and contradictions. The analysis replaces the oversimplifying approaches to the ethics of CSR with a communicative perspective that highlights the need for a contextual examination of the ethical dilemmas that arisen from CSR practices. In this article, I engage with this CSR campaign, using critical discourse analysis (CDA) to uncover its mechanisms and ideological functioning. CDA of the print, television, and new media texts reveals a certain juxtaposition between liberation and oppression of CFRB. The analysis show how Dove was able to transform an ordinary commodity, skin cleansing products, into a consumer activist brand through which consumers could take part in solving self-esteem and social problems. My analysis of CFRB shows the ways that CSR often operates to co-opte the criticism by embracing it, consolidating brand loyalty and corporate profits, and defuse struggles around consumption. By doing so, CSR forms a complex strategy to legitimize particular brands and commodities, so it can be seen as the ideological force of contemporary consumer capitalism."

2021 ◽  
pp. 095001702199735
Author(s):  
Lucy McCarthy ◽  
Anne Touboulic ◽  
Jane Glover

This article explores representations of food labour at different stages in the supply chain through a labour process theory perspective. Employing multi-modal critical discourse analysis it analyses visual data collected from three television programmes focused on dairy production and consumption. The research sheds light on the power relations inherent to food production and the devaluing of manual food labour in supply chains, which are shaped by the current capitalist socio-political environment. The findings expose ways in which media can reinforce dominant understandings of food supply chains, while making aspects of food labour invisible.


2019 ◽  
Vol 12 (2) ◽  
pp. 25-52 ◽  
Author(s):  
Magdalena Karolak

The goal of this research is to explore the opportunities brought about by the use of new media in urban protests. Specifically, it investigates the use of the Internet in modern protest movements that failed to bring about the changes they sought, using Bahrain as a case study. The focus is put on urban movements that continue revolutionary activism off- and online in the sixth year after the failure of the Bahraini uprising. This research assesses the need to maintain an online presence for these cities and explains the goals of their online presence. The paper also aims to understand what type of variations exist within these urban movements; and analyzes the interplay between such online manifestations and online censorship. This research is based on the critical discourse analysis of web content and graphic representations produced by Bahraini activists on particular online sites pertaining to each city in question.


Author(s):  
Christopher M Bingham

Twitch is an online video distribution platform that allows users to broadcast live video of themselves playing videogames. This distribution infrastructure includes features that allow viewers to financially support their favorite Twitch streamers, creating a new type of media professional: the entrepreneurial Twitch streamer. Like other professionals, Twitch streamers meet regularly to discuss the profession and business of live streaming. This article applies critical discourse analysis to one such venue for insider dialogue on professional Twitch streaming: the weekly talk show, Dropped Frames. On this program, professional broadcasters discuss many aspects of their career, such as Twitch’s corporate presence, production technology, the time and effort required to stream, precarity, their relationship to their community, the data they use to run their channels, the games they play, and their relationship to game developers. Speech within these empirically present categories demonstrates an underlying set of common assumptions about how the streaming industry should function. In other words, professional Twitch broadcasters develop a normative theory of streaming practice that is expressed in their speech. I argue that through their speech, professional Twitch streamers demonstrate a theoretical understanding of professional streaming that is based on their ability to negotiate uncertainty and the responsibility they feel for their communities.


2019 ◽  
Vol 32 (8) ◽  
pp. 2395-2420 ◽  
Author(s):  
Uzoechi Nwagbara ◽  
Ataur Belal

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to investigate how language (choice) in CSR reports of leading oil companies in Nigeria is used to portray an image of “responsible organisation”. Design/methodology/approach This paper draws insights from communication studies (persuasion theory) and critical discourse analysis (CDA) studies to discursively unpack all those subtle and visible, yet equally invisible, linguistic strategies (micro-level elements): wording (single words), phrases and chains of words (clauses/sentences). These linguistic strategies (micro-level elements) proxy organisational discourses (meso-level elements), which are reflective of wider social practices (macro-level elements). The authors base the investigation on CSR reports of six leading oil companies in Nigeria from 2009 to 2012. Findings The findings of this study reveal that (leading) Nigerian oil companies linguistically use CSR reports to persuasively construct and portray the image of “responsible organisation” in the eyes of wider stakeholders (the communities) despite serious criticism of their corporate (ir) responsibility. Originality/value As opposed to the previous content analysis based studies, this paper contributes to the emerging stream of CDA studies on CSR reporting by providing a finer-grained linguistic analytical schema couched in Fairclough’s (2003) approach to CDA (and persuasion theory). This helps to unravel how persuasive language/discourse of responsible organisation is enacted and reproduced. The authors thus respond to the calls for theoretical plurality in CSR reporting research by introducing persuasion theory from communication studies literature which has hitherto been rarely applied.


2019 ◽  
Vol 5 (2) ◽  
pp. 48
Author(s):  
Okta Mediutami Putri ◽  
Lisda Liyanti

<p class="Normal1"><em>Abstrak</em> - <strong>Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk </strong><strong>mengetahui bagaimana </strong><strong>penggambaran </strong><strong>perempuan setelah ditetapkannya Hari Perempuan Internasional </strong><strong>(<em>Weltfrauentag) </em></strong><strong>dalam </strong><strong>dua</strong><strong> ilustrasi online yang dimuat pada dua portal ilustrasi online di Jerman, yaitu <em>toonpool.de </em>dan<em> </em></strong><strong><em>ce-</em></strong><strong><em>comico</em></strong><strong><em>.</em></strong><strong><em>de</em></strong><strong><em>.</em></strong><strong> Metode penelitian yang </strong><strong>di</strong><strong>gunakan berupa metode deskriptif kualitatif dengan pendekatan studi pustaka. </strong><strong>Analisis ini menggunakan teori analisis wacana kritis model Sara Mills dan model teori segitiga semantik Charles Sanders Peirce.</strong><strong> </strong><strong>Hasil penelitian ini menunjukkan bahwa </strong><strong>penggambaran perempuan dalam </strong><strong>media baru berupa ilustrasi online</strong><strong> menghadirkan diskusi terbuka mengenai pelekatan unsur domestik yang kuat pada perempuan. Diskusi ini dihadirkan oleh dua ilustrasi ini dengan cara berbeda. Ilustrasi pertama bernada positif, sedangkan yang kedua bernada pesimis. Ilustrasi pertama menggambarkan pelekatan unsur domestik melalui permainan kata oleh pemuka agama yang kemudian dipatahkan dengan penggunaan warna cerah dan simbol gambar yang mendukung kemajuan perempuan. Sementara itu, ilustrasi kedua menggunakan penggambaran relasi kuasa pada pimpinan laki-laki dan bawahan perempuannya. Kesadaran akan adanya hari perempuan dunia yang diucapkan pimpinan laki laki hanya mengacu pada kemampuan perempuan dalam mengerjakan pekerjaan domestik. Warna gelap dan simbol ada dalam gambar juga menyiratkan rasa pesimis yang diusung ilustrasi tersebut.</strong></p><p class="Normal1"><em>Abstract<strong> </strong>- </em><strong>The purpose of this research was to find out how the portrayal of women (concerning international women's day/Weltfrauentag) depicted in two German online illustrations.  This research methodology is a qualitative method that is written by descriptive analysis with the approach of the study of literature. This research used Sara Mills's critical discourse analysis and semantic triangle theory by Charles Sanders Peirce. The research found that the portrayal of women in the new media (in the form of illustrated online) open the discussion on the domestication of woman. This discussion is presented differently in the two illustrations: while the first shows hope and positive attitude, the latter is seen pessimistic. The first illustration depicts the domestication of a woman using the word-play by two monks that are denied by using bright color and symbol of woman empowerment. The second illustration describes the power-relation between a male director and a woman employee. The male director argues the "International Woman Day" by referring only to woman domestic skills. The dark color and symbols support pessimistic attitude in the illustration.</strong></p><p class="Normal1"><strong><em>Keywords</em></strong> – <em>International Woman’s Day, Domestication of Woman, online illustration, Weltfrauentag.</em></p>


ARISTO ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 8 (1) ◽  
pp. 165
Author(s):  
Nunik Hariyanti ◽  
Senja Yustitia

Reforms bring consequences of freedom in political, contending, and media freedom. In the freedom of media, the presence of new media is dynamic in the process of delivering messages and opinions, especially in the realm of democracy. Black issues, polarisation supporters until identity politics also coloring the Indonesian elections in Indonesia in 2019, until finally, the figure @nurhadi_aldo emerged as the presidential candidate version of the Cyber Society. This research discusses text analysis in a discourse, according to Fairclough, the presence of text is a representation of the understanding of the creator, and this is open to interpretation. The purpose of this study describes the use of sexuality and satire language as a form of political expression in Indonesia, especially those that appear on the Nurhadi - Aldo Instagram account (@nurhadi_aldo). There are three stages to analyzing discourse based on Norman Fairclough's critical discourse analysis theory, namely representation, relation, and identity. The research results show that the language of sexuality and satire used by @nurhadi_aldo is a form of honesty expression to criticize the loss of the essence of an election contestation in Indonesia. Then found bizarre disclosure techniques, hyperbola, contrast, and unexpected techniques of logic use as an attempt to criticize the political phenomenon with @nurhadi_aldo. 


2020 ◽  
Vol 11 (1) ◽  
pp. 57-66
Author(s):  
Francesco Fabbro

The paper presents Critical Discourse Analysis (CDA) as a qualitative research method particularly suitable for the study of media education practices. The contribution highlights how the CDA allows to focus on social functions, identities and power relations mediated by language(s) in educational settings and then it presents an analytical framework widely adopted in social and educational research. Secondly, it exemplifies the application of CDA by presenting a case study on literacy education. Finally, after underlying the convergence between new media literacies and CDA perspectives on the concept of learning, it outlines some possible applications of CDA for the empirical study of media education practices.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document