Evaluation of Satellite-Derived Surface Soil Moisture Products over Agricultural Regions of Canada

Soil moisture is a critical indicator for climate change and agricultural drought, but its measurement is challenging due to large variability with land cover, soil type, time, space and depth. Satellite estimates of soil moisture are highly desirable and have become more widely available over the past decade. This study investigates and compares the performance of four surface soil moisture satellite datasets over Canada, namely, Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity Level 3 (SMOS L3), versions 3.3 and 4.2 of European Space Agency Climate Change Initiative (ESA CCI) soil moisture product and a recent product called SMOS-INRA-CESBIO (SMOS-IC) that contains corrections designed to reduce several known sources of uncertainty in SMOS L3. These datasets were evaluated against in situ networks located in mostly agricultural regions of Canada for the period 2012 to 2014. Two statistical comparison methods were used, namely, metrics for mean soil moisture and median of metrics. The results suggest that, while both methods show similar comparisons for regional networks, over large networks, the median of metrics method is more representative of the overall correlation and variability and is therefore a more appropriate method for evaluating the performance of satellite products. Overall, the SMOS products have higher daily temporal correlations, but larger biases, against in situ soil moisture than the ESA CCI products, with SMOS-IC having higher correlations and smaller variability than SMOS L3. The SMOS products capture daily wetting and drying events better than the ESA CCI products, with the SMOS products capturing at least 75% of observed drying as compared to 55% for the ESA CCI products. Overall, for periods during which there are sufficient observations, both SMOS products are more suitable for agricultural applications over Canada than the ESA CCI products, even though SMOS-IC is able to capture soil moisture variability more accurately than SMOS L3.

Download Full-text

From near-surface to root-zone soil moisture using an exponential filter: an assessment of the method based on in-situ observations and model simulations

Hydrology and Earth System Sciences ◽

10.5194/hess-12-1323-2008 ◽

2008 ◽

Vol 12 (6) ◽

pp. 1323-1337 ◽

Cited By ~ 261

Author(s):

C. Albergel ◽

C. Rüdiger ◽

T. Pellarin ◽

J.-C. Calvet ◽

N. Fritz ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Soil Moisture ◽

Soil Water ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Root Zone ◽

Synthetic Data ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Data Set ◽

Water Index ◽

In Situ Observations

Abstract. A long term data acquisition effort of profile soil moisture is under way in southwestern France at 13 automated weather stations. This ground network was developed in order to validate remote sensing and model soil moisture estimates. In this paper, both those in situ observations and a synthetic data set covering continental France are used to test a simple method to retrieve root zone soil moisture from a time series of surface soil moisture information. A recursive exponential filter equation using a time constant, T, is used to compute a soil water index. The Nash and Sutcliff coefficient is used as a criterion to optimise the T parameter for each ground station and for each model pixel of the synthetic data set. In general, the soil water indices derived from the surface soil moisture observations and simulations agree well with the reference root-zone soil moisture. Overall, the results show the potential of the exponential filter equation and of its recursive formulation to derive a soil water index from surface soil moisture estimates. This paper further investigates the correlation of the time scale parameter T with soil properties and climate conditions. While no significant relationship could be determined between T and the main soil properties (clay and sand fractions, bulk density and organic matter content), the modelled spatial variability and the observed inter-annual variability of T suggest that a weak climate effect may exist.

Download Full-text

Field scale spatiotemporal analysis of surface soil moisture for evaluating point-scale in situ networks

Geoderma ◽

10.1016/j.geoderma.2011.11.004 ◽

2012 ◽

Vol 170 ◽

pp. 195-205 ◽

Cited By ~ 39

Author(s):

Gary C. Heathman ◽

Michael H. Cosh ◽

Eunjin Han ◽

Thomas J. Jackson ◽

Lynn McKee ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Soil Moisture ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Spatiotemporal Analysis ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Field Scale ◽

Point Scale

Download Full-text

Evaluation of the AMSR2 L2 soil moisture product of JAXA on the Mongolian Plateau over seven years (2012–2018)

SN Applied Sciences ◽

10.1007/s42452-019-1488-y ◽

2019 ◽

Vol 1 (11) ◽

Cited By ~ 1

Author(s):

Ichirow Kaihotsu ◽

Jun Asanuma ◽

Kentaro Aida ◽

Dambaravjaa Oyunbaatar

Keyword(s):

Soil Moisture ◽

Vegetation Index ◽

Normalized Difference Vegetation Index ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Mongolian Plateau ◽

Moisture Measurement ◽

Rainfall Condition ◽

Soil Moisture Measurement

Abstract This study evaluated the Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer 2 (AMSR2) L2 soil moisture product (ver. 3) using in situ hydrological observational data, acquired over 7 years (2012–2018), from a 50 × 50 km flat area of the Mongolian Plateau covered with bare soil, pasture and shrubs. Although AMSR2 slightly underestimated soil moisture content at 3-cm depth, satisfactory timing was observed in both the response patterns and the in situ soil moisture data, and the differences between these factors were not large. In terms of the relationship between AMSR2 soil moisture from descending orbits and in situ measured soil moisture at 3-cm depth, the values of the RMSE (m3/m3) and the bias (m3/m3) varied from 0.028 to 0.063 and from 0.011 to − 0.001 m3/m3, respectively. The values of the RMSE and bias depended on rainfall condition. The mean value of the RMSE for the 7-year period was 0.042 m3/m3, i.e., lower than the target accuracy 0.050 m3/m3. The validation results for descending orbits were found slightly better than for ascending orbits. Comparison of the Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity (SMOS) soil moisture product with the AMSR2 L2 soil moisture product showed that AMSR2 could observe surface soil moisture with nearly same accuracy and stability. However, the bias of the AMSR2 soil moisture measurement was slightly negative and poorer than that of SMOS with deeper soil moisture measurement. It means that AMSR2 cannot effectively measure soil moisture at 3-cm depth. In situ soil temperature at 3-cm depth and surface vegetation (normalized difference vegetation index) did not influence the underestimation of AMSR2 soil moisture measurements. These results suggest that a possible cause of the underestimation of AMSR2 soil moisture measurements is the difference between the depth of the AMSR2 observations and in situ soil moisture measurements. Overall, this study proved the AMSR2 L2 soil moisture product has been useful for monitoring daily surface soil moisture over large grassland areas and it clearly demonstrated the high-performance capability of AMSR2 since 2012.

Download Full-text

An Evaluation of the EnKF vs. EnOI and the Assimilation of SMAP, SMOS and ESA CCI Soil Moisture Data over the Contiguous US

Remote Sensing ◽

10.3390/rs11050478 ◽

2019 ◽

Vol 11 (5) ◽

pp. 478 ◽

Cited By ~ 6

Author(s):

Jostein Blyverket ◽

Paul Hamer ◽

Laurent Bertino ◽

Clément Albergel ◽

David Fairbairn ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Soil Moisture ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Open Loop ◽

Surface Zone ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Atmospheric Forcing ◽

Significance Level ◽

Soil Moisture Data ◽

In Situ Observations

A number of studies have shown that assimilation of satellite derived soil moisture using the ensemble Kalman Filter (EnKF) can improve soil moisture estimates, particularly for the surface zone. However, the EnKF is computationally expensive since an ensemble of model integrations have to be propagated forward in time. Here, assimilating satellite soil moisture data from the Soil Moisture Active Passive (SMAP) mission, we compare the EnKF with the computationally cheaper ensemble Optimal Interpolation (EnOI) method over the contiguous United States (CONUS). The background error–covariance in the EnOI is sampled in two ways: (i) by using the stochastic spread from an ensemble open-loop run, and (ii) sampling from the model spinup climatology. Our results indicate that the EnKF is only marginally superior to one version of the EnOI. Furthermore, the assimilation of SMAP data using the EnKF and EnOI is found to improve the surface zone correlation with in situ observations at a 95 % significance level. The EnKF assimilation of SMAP data is also found to improve root-zone correlation with independent in situ data at the same significance level; however this improvement is dependent on which in situ network we are validating against. We evaluate how the quality of the atmospheric forcing affects the analysis results by prescribing the land surface data assimilation system with either observation corrected or model derived precipitation. Surface zone correlation skill increases for the analysis using both the corrected and model derived precipitation, but only the latter shows an improvement at the 95 % significance level. The study also suggests that assimilation of satellite derived surface soil moisture using the EnOI can correct random errors in the atmospheric forcing and give an analysed surface soil moisture close to that of an open-loop run using observation derived precipitation. Importantly, this shows that estimates of soil moisture could be improved using a combination of assimilating SMAP using the computationally cheap EnOI while using model derived precipitation as forcing. Finally, we assimilate three different Level-2 satellite derived soil moisture products from the European Space Agency Climate Change Initiative (ESA CCI), SMAP and SMOS (Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity) using the EnOI, and then compare the relative performance of the three resulting analyses against in situ soil moisture observations. In this comparison, we find that all three analyses offer improvements over an open-loop run when comparing to in situ observations. The assimilation of SMAP data is found to perform marginally better than the assimilation of SMOS data, while assimilation of the ESA CCI data shows the smallest improvement of the three analysis products.

Download Full-text

The impact of near-surface soil moisture assimilation at subseasonal, seasonal, and inter-annual timescales

Hydrology and Earth System Sciences ◽

10.5194/hess-19-4831-2015 ◽

2015 ◽

Vol 19 (12) ◽

pp. 4831-4844 ◽

Cited By ~ 19

Author(s):

C. Draper ◽

R. Reichle

Keyword(s):

Soil Moisture ◽

Data Assimilation ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Root Zone ◽

Surface Model ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Near Surface ◽

In Situ Observations ◽

The Impact

Abstract. A 9 year record of Advanced Microwave Scanning Radiometer – Earth Observing System (AMSR-E) soil moisture retrievals are assimilated into the Catchment land surface model at four locations in the US. The assimilation is evaluated using the unbiased mean square error (ubMSE) relative to watershed-scale in situ observations, with the ubMSE separated into contributions from the subseasonal (SMshort), mean seasonal (SMseas), and inter-annual (SMlong) soil moisture dynamics. For near-surface soil moisture, the average ubMSE for Catchment without assimilation was (1.8 × 10−3 m3 m−3)2, of which 19 % was in SMlong, 26 % in SMseas, and 55 % in SMshort. The AMSR-E assimilation significantly reduced the total ubMSE at every site, with an average reduction of 33 %. Of this ubMSE reduction, 37 % occurred in SMlong, 24 % in SMseas, and 38 % in SMshort. For root-zone soil moisture, in situ observations were available at one site only, and the near-surface and root-zone results were very similar at this site. These results suggest that, in addition to the well-reported improvements in SMshort, assimilating a sufficiently long soil moisture data record can also improve the model representation of important long-term events, such as droughts. The improved agreement between the modeled and in situ SMseas is harder to interpret, given that mean seasonal cycle errors are systematic, and systematic errors are not typically targeted by (bias-blind) data assimilation. Finally, the use of 1-year subsets of the AMSR-E and Catchment soil moisture for estimating the observation-bias correction (rescaling) parameters is investigated. It is concluded that when only 1 year of data are available, the associated uncertainty in the rescaling parameters should not greatly reduce the average benefit gained from data assimilation, although locally and in extreme years there is a risk of increased errors.

Download Full-text

Accuracy and Transferability of Artificial Neural Networks in Predicting in Situ Root-Zone Soil Moisture for Various Regions across the Globe

Water ◽

10.3390/w12113109 ◽

2020 ◽

Vol 12 (11) ◽

pp. 3109

Author(s):

Roïya Souissi ◽

Ahmad Al Bitar ◽

Mehrez Zribi

Keyword(s):

Neural Network ◽

Soil Moisture ◽

Soil Texture ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Root Zone ◽

Data Filtering ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

The Mean ◽

Artificial Neural

This paper explores the accuracy in using an artificial neural network (ANN) to estimate root-zone soil moisture (RZSM) at multiple worldwide locations using only in situ surface soil moisture (SSM) as a training dataset. The paper also addresses the transferability of the trained ANN across climatic and soil texture conditions. Data from the International Soil Moisture Network (ISMN) were collected for several networks with variable soil texture and climate classes. Several scaling, feature extraction, and training approaches were tested. An artificial neural network employing rolling averages (ANNRAV) of SSM over 10, 30, and 90 days was developed. The results show that applying a standard scaling (SSCA) to the ANN input features improves the correlation, Nash–Sutcliffe efficiency (NSE), and root mean square error (RMSE) for 52%, 91%, and 87%, respectively, of the tested stations, compared to MinMax scaling (MMSCA). Different training sets are suggested, namely, training on data from all networks, data from one network, or data of all networks excluding one. Based on these trainings, new transferability (TranI) and contribution (ContI) indices are defined. The results show that one network cannot provide the best prediction accuracy if used alone to train the ANN. They also show that the removal of the less contributing networks enhances performance. For example, elimination of the densest network (SCAN) from the training enhances the mean correlation by 20.5% and the mean NSE by 42.5%. This motivates the implementation of a data filtering technique based on the ANN’s performance. A median, max, and min correlation of 0.77, 0.96, and 0.65, respectively, are obtained by the model after data filtering. The performances are also analyzed with respect to the covered climatic regions and soil texture, providing insights into the robustness and limitations of the approach, namely, the need for complementary information in highly evaporative regions. In fact, the ANN using only SSM to predict RZSM has low performance when decoupling between the surface and root zones is observed. The application of ANN to obtain spatialized RZSM will require integrating remote sensing-based surface soil moisture in the future.

Download Full-text

Exploring the use of machine-learning techniques to integrate ground- and remote sensing-based observations for efficient near-surface soil moisture mapping

10.5194/egusphere-egu2020-9092 ◽

2020 ◽

Author(s):

Sarah Schönbrodt-Stitt ◽

Paolo Nasta ◽

Nima Ahmadian ◽

Markus Kurtenbach ◽

Christopher Conrad ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Machine Learning ◽

Soil Moisture ◽

Spatial Resolution ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Bare Soil ◽

Small Scale ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Near Surface ◽

Campania Region

Mapping near-surface soil moisture (&#952;) is of tremendous relevance for a broad range of environment-related disciplines and meteorological, ecological, hydrological and agricultural applications. Globally available products offer the opportunity to address &#952; in large-scale modelling with coarse spatial resolution such as at the landscape level. However, &#952; estimation at higher spatial resolution is of vital importance for many small-scale applications. Therefore, we focus our study on a small-scale catchment (MFC2) belonging to the &#8220;Alento&#8221; hydrological observatory, located in southern Italy (Campania Region). The goal of this study is to develop new machine-learning approaches to estimate high grid-resolution (about 17 m cell size) &#952; maps from mainly backscatter measurements retrieved from C-band Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) based on Sentinel-1 (S1) images and from gridded terrain attributes. Thus, a workflow comprising a total of 48 SAR-based &#952; patterns estimated for 24 satellite overpass dates (revisit time of 6 days) each with ascendant and descendent orbits will be presented. To enable for the mapping, SAR-based &#952; data was calibrated with in-situ measurements carried out with a portable device during eight measurement campaigns at time of satellite overpasses (four overpass days in total with each ascendant and descendent satellite overpasses per day in November 2018). After the calibration procedure, data validation was executed from November 10, 2018 till March 28, 2019 by using two stationary sensors monitoring &#952; at high-temporal (1-min recording time). The specific sensor locations reflected two contrasting field conditions, one bare soil plot (frequently kept clear, without disturbance of vegetation cover) and one non-bare soil plot (real-world condition). Point-scale ground observations of &#952; were compared to pixel-scale (17 m &#215; 17 m), SAR-based &#952; estimated for those pixels corresponding to the specific positions of the stationary sensors. Mapping performance was estimated through the root mean squared error (RMSE). For a short-term time series of &#952; (Nov 2018) integrating 136 in situ, sensor-based &#952; (&#952;insitu) and 74 gravimetric-based &#952; (&#952;gravimetric) measurements during a total of eight S1 overpasses, mapping performance already proved to be satisfactory with RMSE=0.039 m&#179;m-&#179; and R&#178;=0.92, respectively with RMSE=0.041 m&#179;m-&#179; and R&#178;=0.91. First results further reveal that estimated satellite-based &#952; patterns respond to the evolution of rainfall. With our workflow developed and results, we intend to contribute to improved environmental risk assessment by assimilating the results into hydrological models (e.g., HydroGeoSphere), and to support future studies on combined ground-based and SAR-based &#952; retrieval for forested land (future missions operating at larger wavelengths e.g. NISARL-band, Biomass P-band sensors).

Download Full-text

The spatiotemporal patterns of surface soil moisture in Northeast China based on remote sensing products

Journal of Water and Climate Change ◽

10.2166/wcc.2016.106 ◽

2016 ◽

Vol 7 (4) ◽

pp. 708-720 ◽

Cited By ~ 6

Author(s):

Xingming Zheng ◽

Kai Zhao ◽

Yanling Ding ◽

Tao Jiang ◽

Shiyi Zhang ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Climate Change ◽

Remote Sensing ◽

Soil Moisture ◽

Northeast China ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Temporal Dynamics ◽

Remote Sensing Data ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

The Past ◽

Warming Rate

Northeast China (NEC) has become one of China's most obvious examples of climate change because of its rising warming rate of 0.35 °C/10 years. As the indicator of climate change, the dynamic of surface soil moisture (SSM) has not been assessed yet. We investigated the spatiotemporal dynamics of SSM in NEC using a 32-year SSM product and found the following. (1) SSM displayed the characteristics of being dry in the west and wet in the east and decreased with time. (2) The seasonal difference was found for the temporal dynamics of SSM: it increased in summer and decreased in spring and autumn. (3) For all four regions studied, the temporal dynamics of SSM were similar to those of the whole of NEC, but with different rates of SSM change. Moreover, SSM in regions B and D had a lower spatial variance than the other two regions because of the stable spatial pattern of cropland. (4) The change rates for SSM were consistent with that observed for the warming rates, which indicated that SSM levels derived from remote sensing data will correlate with climate change. In summary, a wetter summer and a drier spring and autumn were observed in NEC over the past 30 years.

Download Full-text

An evaluation of ASCAT surface soil moisture products with in-situ observations in Southwestern France

Hydrology and Earth System Sciences ◽

10.5194/hess-13-115-2009 ◽

2009 ◽

Vol 13 (2) ◽

pp. 115-124 ◽

Cited By ~ 158

Author(s):

C. Albergel ◽

C. Rüdiger ◽

D. Carrer ◽

J.-C. Calvet ◽

N. Fritz ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Soil Moisture ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Mountainous Area ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Water Index ◽

In Situ Observations ◽

Weather Stations ◽

Term Data

Abstract. A long term data acquisition effort of profile soil moisture is currently underway at 13 automatic weather stations located in Southwestern France. In this study, the soil moisture measured in-situ at 5 cm is used to evaluate the normalised surface soil moisture (SSM) estimates derived from coarse-resolution (25 km) active microwave data of the ASCAT scatterometer instrument (onboard METOP), issued by EUMETSAT for a period of 6 months (April–September) in 2007. The seasonal trend is removed from the satellite and in-situ time series by considering scaled anomalies. One station (Mouthoumet) of the ground network, located in a mountainous area, is removed from the analysis as very few ASCAT SSM estimates are available. No correlation is found for the station of Narbonne, which is close to the Mediterranean sea. On the other hand, nine stations present significant correlation levels. For two stations, a significant correlation is obtained when considering only part of the ASCAT data. The soil moisture measured in-situ at those stations, at 30 cm, is used to estimate the characteristic time length (T) of an exponential filter applied to the ASCAT product. The best correlation between a soil water index derived from ASCAT and the in-situ soil moisture observations at 30 cm is obtained with a T-value of 14 days.

Download Full-text

Statistical Exploration of SENTINEL-1 Data, Terrain Parameters, and in-situ Data for Estimating the Near-Surface Soil Moisture in a Mediterranean Agroecosystem

Frontiers in Water ◽

10.3389/frwa.2021.655837 ◽

2021 ◽

Vol 3 ◽

Author(s):

Sarah Schönbrodt-Stitt ◽

Nima Ahmadian ◽

Markus Kurtenbach ◽

Christopher Conrad ◽

Nunzio Romano ◽

...

Keyword(s):

Soil Moisture ◽

Empirical Model ◽

Surface Soil ◽

Surface Soil Moisture ◽

Channel Network ◽

Near Surface ◽

Short Period ◽

Terrain Parameters ◽

Simple Empirical Model

Reliable near-surface soil moisture (θ) information is crucial for supporting risk assessment of future water usage, particularly considering the vulnerability of agroforestry systems of Mediterranean environments to climate change. We propose a simple empirical model by integrating dual-polarimetric Sentinel-1 (S1) Synthetic Aperture Radar (SAR) C-band single-look complex data and topographic information together with in-situ measurements of θ into a random forest (RF) regression approach (10-fold cross-validation). Firstly, we compare two RF models' estimation performances using either 43 SAR parameters (θNovSAR) or the combination of 43 SAR and 10 terrain parameters (θNovSAR+Terrain). Secondly, we analyze the essential parameters in estimating and mapping θ for S1 overpasses twice a day (at 5 a.m. and 5 p.m.) in a high spatiotemporal (17 × 17 m; 6 days) resolution. The developed site-specific calibration-dependent model was tested for a short period in November 2018 in a field-scale agroforestry environment belonging to the “Alento” hydrological observatory in southern Italy. Our results show that the combined SAR + terrain model slightly outperforms the SAR-based model (θNovSAR+Terrain with 0.025 and 0.020 m3 m−3, and 89% compared to θNovSAR with 0.028 and 0.022 m3 m−3, and 86% in terms of RMSE, MAE, and R2). The higher explanatory power for θNovSAR+Terrain is assessed with time-variant SAR phase information-dependent elements of the C2 covariance and Kennaugh matrix (i.e., K1, K6, and K1S) and with local (e.g., altitude above channel network) and compound topographic attributes (e.g., wetness index). Our proposed methodological approach constitutes a simple empirical model aiming at estimating θ for rapid surveys with high accuracy. It emphasizes potentials for further improvement (e.g., higher spatiotemporal coverage of ground-truthing) by identifying differences of SAR measurements between S1 overpasses in the morning and afternoon.

Download Full-text