Abstract
Background: Low dose radiotherapy (LDRT) of whole lungs with photon beams is a novel under evaluation method for treating COVID-19 pneumonia. The purpose of this study was to estimate the cancer risks induced by lung LDRT as the only radiation side effects at low doses for different radiotherapy delivery techniques.Method: Four different radiotherapy techniques including 3D-conformal with anterior and posterior fields (3D-CRT AP-PA), 3D-conformal with 8 coplanar fields (3D-CRT 8 fields), 8 fields intensity modulated radiotherapy (IMRT), and volumetric modulated arc therapy using 2 full arcs (VMAT) were planned on the CT images of 32 COVID-19 patients. Organ average and maximum doses, and PTV dose distribution indexes were calculated and compared between different techniques. The radiation induced cancer and mortality risks were estimated and compared for the assessed techniques.Results: In IMRT and VMAT techniques, heart (mean, and max), breast (mean, and max), and stomach (mean) doses and also maximum dose in the body were significantly lower compared to 3D-CRT techniques. The calculated conformity indexes were similar in all the techniques. However, the homogeneity indexes were lower (i.e. better) in intensity modulated techniques (P<0.03) with no significant differences between IMRT and VMAT plans. Lifetime lung cancer incident risks for all the delivery techniques were statistically similar (P>0.4). Cancer risks for organs located closer to lung like breast, and stomach were significantly higher in 3D-CRT techniques compared to IMRT or VMAT techniques (for a 30 years old man: 2.041±0.237% Vs 1.560±0.210%; and woman: 6.624±0.548% Vs 4.963±0.462%) (P<0.03). However, 8 fields 3D-conformal had significantly lower breast cancer risk compared to the 3D-CRT AP-PA technique (P<0.01).Conclusion: Although all the radiotherapy techniques had low cancer risks, the overall risks induced by IMRT and VMAT radiotherapy techniques were lower than the 3D-CRT techniques and can be used clinically in younger patients or patients having higher concerns about future cancers. Higher cancer risks except the lungs are related to breast, and stomach which must be considered for lung LDRT.