Review of Methane Seepages in the Okinawa Trough: Progress and Outlook

It has been two decades since the cold seeps were firstly found in the Okinawa Trough (OT). The scientific cruises and the geological surveys since then have unveiled the currently active submarine methane seeps and significantly improved the understanding of methane seeps in the back-arc basin of the OT. In this paper, we review the up-to-date progress of the research of methane seepages then put forward the promising, yet challenging, outlook by listing the unsolved questions of the cold seeps in the OT. Multiple approaches and techniques, including seismic and echo-sounder recording, dredging, gravity-piston and ROV coring, seafloor drilling, and isotopic and microarray-based genomic analysis, have been used to reveal the geological processes responsible for the seeping activities and the biogeochemical processes related to them. The geophysical signature associated with gas seeps mainly includes the acoustic turbidity in the subsurface, the anomaly of the backscattering intensity at the seabed, and the gas plumes observed in the water column. Pore water and methane-derived authigenic carbonate archive the intensification of methane seepage and the paleoenvironment changes at different time scales. The methane feeding of the seeps in the OT was generated mostly via the microbially mediated process and has an origin mixed by thermogenic hydrocarbon gas in the middle OT. Sulfate-driven and Fe-driven anaerobic oxidations of methane are suggested to be the key biogeochemical processes, which would shape the material cycling in the seeping environment. The future research on the cold seeps in the OT is worth looking forward to due to its geographic and potential geologic links with the nearby hydrothermal activities. Multidisciplinary studies are expected to concentrate on their link with the undiscovered gas hydrates, the amount of methane transferring into the oceans and its impact on the climatic change, and the evolution of the seeping activities accompanied by the biogeochemical processes.

A Geophysical Review of the Seabed Methane Seepage Features and Their Relationship with Gas Hydrate Systems

Seabed methane seepage has gained attention from all over the world in recent years as an important source of greenhouse gas emission, and gas hydrates are also regarded as a key factor affecting climate change or even global warming due to their shallow burial and poor stability. However, the relationship between seabed methane seepage and gas hydrate systems is not clear although they often coexist in continental margins. It is of significance to clarify their relationship and better understand the contribution of gas hydrate systems or the deeper hydrocarbon reservoirs for methane flux leaking to the seawater or even the atmosphere by natural seepages at the seabed. In this paper, a geophysical examination of the global seabed methane seepage events has been conducted, and nearby gas hydrate stability zone and relevant fluid migration pathways have been interpreted or modelled using seismic data, multibeam data, or underwater photos. Results show that seabed methane seepage sites are often manifested as methane flares, pockmarks, deep-water corals, authigenic carbonates, and gas hydrate pingoes at the seabed, most of which are closely related to vertical fluid migration structures like faults, gas chimneys, mud volcanoes, and unconformity surfaces or are located in the landward limit of gas hydrate stability zone (LLGHSZ) where hydrate dissociation may have released a great volume of methane. Based on a comprehensive analysis of these features, three major types of seabed methane seepage are classified according to their spatial relationship with the location of LLGHSZ, deeper than the LLGHSZ (A), around the LLGHSZ (B), and shallower than LLGHSZ (C). These three seabed methane seepage types can be further divided into five subtypes considering whether the gas source of seabed methane seepage is from the gas hydrate systems or not. We propose subtype B2 represents the most important seabed methane seepage type due to the high density of seepage sites and large volume of released methane from massive focused vigorous methane seepage sites around the LLGHSZ. Based on the classification result of this research, more measures should be taken for subtype B2 seabed methane seepage to predict or even prevent ocean warming or climate change.

Proposed Methodology to Quantify the Amount of Methane Seepage by Understanding the Correlation Between Methane Plumes and Originating Seeps

In recent years, discoveries of methane plumes (also called methane flares) have been reported in various sea areas around the world. Clusters of naturally seeping methane bubbles rising from the seafloor are visualized as methane plumes on the echograms of quantitative echo sounders and multibeam sonars. In order to determine if seeping methane can be used as energy resources and its environmental impact, it is necessary to estimate the amount of naturally seeping methane. From April, 2020, a 3-year project is being conducted in Japan to evaluate the amount of methane seepage from methane plumes. The authors propose the following steps to quantify the amount of methane seepage accurately. First of all, methane plumes in the Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) of Japan are mapped out using acoustic devices such as quantitative echo sounders and multibeam sonars. Secondly, methane bubbles of a few millimeters in diameter from methane seeps at seafloor are collected and sampled using a cone-shaped collector with 20 cm in diameter, operated by Remotely Operated Vehicle (ROV). If we can identify the number of seep mouths that form into one single plume, we will be able to quantify the methane seepage from one plume. Based on this result, calibration of the mean backscattering strength and the amount of seeping methane from methane plumes becomes possible and will be applied to the mapped plumes in order to estimate the methane seepage in the EEZ of Japan. Once this calibration is established, it can be applied to the methane plumes observed worldwide, and methane seepage can be quantified simply by acoustic observations of methane plumes. In this study, a method to verify the correlation between methane plumes and methane seeps is introduced, as well as a method to locate methane seeps effectively using the Target Position function of a quantitative echo sounder. The authors intend to use this as the basic data for establishing a method to estimate the amount of methane released from a methane plume by observing the methane plume acoustically.

Autonomous methane seep site monitoring offshore Western Svalbard: Hourly to seasonal variability and associated oceanographic parameters

Improved quantification techniques of natural sources is needed to explain variations in atmospheric methane. In polar regions, high uncertainties in current estimates of methane release from the seabed remain. We present two unique 10 and 3 months long time-series of bottom water measurements of physical and chemical parameters from two autonomous ocean observatories deployed at separate intense seabed methane seep sites (91 and 246 m depth) offshore Western Svalbard from 2015 to 2016. Results show high short term (100–1000 nmol L-1 within hours) and seasonal variation, as well as higher (2–7 times) methane concentrations compared to previous measurements. Rapid variability is explained by uneven distribution of seepage and changing ocean current directions. No overt influence of tidal hydrostatic pressure or water temperature variations on methane concentration was observed, but an observed negative correlation with temperature at the 246 site fits with hypothesized seasonal blocking of lateral methane pathways in the sediments. Negative correlation between bottom water methane concentration/variability and wind forcing, concomitant with signs of weaker water column stratification, indicates increased potential for methane release to the atmosphere in fall/winter. We highlight uncertainties in methane inventory estimates based on discrete water sampling and present new information about short- and long-term methane variability which can help constrain future estimates of seabed methane seepage.

Deglacial bottom water warming intensified Arctic methane seepage in the NW Barents Sea

Changes in the Arctic climate-ocean system can rapidly impact carbon cycling and cryosphere. Methane release from the seafloor has been widespread in the Barents Sea since the last deglaciation, being closely linked to changes in pressure and bottom water temperature. Here, we present a post-glacial bottom water temperature record (18,000–0 years before present) based on Mg/Ca in benthic foraminifera from an area where methane seepage occurs and proximal to a former Arctic ice-sheet grounding zone. Coupled ice sheet-hydrate stability modeling shows that phases of extreme bottom water temperature up to 6 °C and associated with inflow of Atlantic Water repeatedly destabilized subsurface hydrates facilitating the release of greenhouse gasses from the seabed. Furthermore, these warming events played an important role in triggering multiple collapses of the marine-based Svalbard-Barents Sea Ice Sheet. Future warming of the Atlantic Water could lead to widespread disappearance of gas hydrates and melting of the remaining marine-terminating glaciers.

Volumetric Mapping of Methane Concentrations at the Bush Hill Hydrocarbon Seep, Gulf of Mexico

The role of methane as a green-house gas is widely recognized and has sparked considerable efforts to quantify the contribution from natural methane sources including submarine seeps. A variety of techniques and approaches have been directed at quantifying methane fluxes from seeps from just below the sediment water interface all the way to the ocean atmosphere interface. However, there have been no systematic efforts to characterize the amount and distribution of dissolved methane around seeps. This is critical to understanding the fate of methane released from seeps and its role in the submarine environment. Here we summarize the findings of two field studies of the Bush Hill mud volcano (540 m water depth) located in the Gulf of Mexico. The studies were carried out using buoyancy driven gliders equipped with methane sensors for near real time in situ detection. One glider was equipped with an Acoustic Doppler Current Profiler (ADCP) for simultaneous measurement of currents and methane concentrations. Elevated methane concentrations in the water column were measured as far away as 2 km from the seep source and to a height of about 100 m above the seep. Maximum observed concentrations were ∼400 nM near the seep source and decreased away steadily in all directions from the source. Weak and variable currents result in nearly radially symmetric dispersal of methane from the source. The persistent presence of significant methane concentrations in the water column points to a persistent methane seepage at the seafloor, that has implications for helping stabilize exposed methane hydrates. Elevated methane concentrations in the water column, at considerable distances away from seeps potentially support a much larger methane-promoted biological system than is widely appreciated.

OpenFOAM solver of the methane behaviour near the coal mine tunnelling face and its application

The methane near a tunnelling face seriously affects production safety in coal mines. A model considering methane seepage, adsorption, desorption and coal damage processes was established in this research. The open field operation and manipulation (OpenFOAM) solver was compiled to numerically solve the established model. The model is validated against data published in a previous theoretical study. The solver was used to investigate the effect of different parameters on methane emission regularity. This solver demonstrates that the effects of the original stress, coal cohesion and coal internal friction angle on the methane emission rate are limited, but their effects on the width of the fractured zone and effective stress are great. The effects of the initial methane pressure and coal adsorption parameters on the methane emission rate are also notable, but their effects on the width of the fractured zone and effective stress are limited.