Retinal Stem Cell ‘Retirement Plans’: Growth, Regulation and Species Adaptations in the Retinal Ciliary Marginal Zone

The vertebrate retina develops from a specified group of precursor cells that adopt distinct identities and generate lineages of either the neural retina, retinal pigmented epithelium, or ciliary body. In some species, including teleost fish and amphibians, proliferative cells with stem-cell-like properties capable of continuously supplying new retinal cells post-embryonically have been characterized and extensively studied. This region, termed the ciliary or circumferential marginal zone (CMZ), possibly represents a conserved retinal stem cell niche. In this review, we highlight the research characterizing similar CMZ-like regions, or stem-like cells located at the peripheral margin, across multiple different species. We discuss the proliferative parameters, multipotency and growth mechanisms of these cells to understand how they behave in vivo and how different molecular factors and signalling networks converge at the CMZ niche to regulate their activity. The evidence suggests that the mature retina may have a conserved propensity for homeostatic growth and plasticity and that dysfunction in the regulation of CMZ activity may partially account for dystrophic eye growth diseases such as myopia and hyperopia. A better understanding of the properties of CMZ cells will enable important insight into how an endogenous generative tissue compartment can adapt to altered retinal physiology and potentially even restore vision loss caused by retinal degenerative conditions.

Vertebrate features revealed in the rudimentary eye of the Pacific hagfish ( Eptatretus stoutii )

Hagfish eyes are markedly basic compared to the eyes of other vertebrates, lacking a pigmented epithelium, a lens and a retinal architecture built of three cell layers: the photoreceptors, interneurons and ganglion cells. Concomitant with hagfish belonging to the earliest-branching vertebrate group (the jawless Agnathans), this lack of derived characters has prompted competing interpretations that hagfish eyes represent either a transitional form in the early evolution of vertebrate vision, or a regression from a previously elaborate organ. Here, we show the hagfish retina is not extensively degenerating during its ontogeny, but instead grows throughout life via a recognizable PAX6 + ciliary marginal zone. The retina has a distinct layer of photoreceptor cells that appear to homogeneously express a single opsin of the RH1 rod opsin class. The epithelium that encompasses these photoreceptors is striking because it lacks the melanin pigment that is universally associated with animal vision; notwithstanding, we suggest this epithelium is a homologue of gnathosome retinal pigment epithelium (RPE) based on its robust expression of RPE65 and its engulfment of photoreceptor outer segments. We infer that the hagfish retina is not entirely rudimentary in its wiring, despite lacking a morphologically distinct layer of interneurons: multiple populations of cells exist in the hagfish inner retina and subsets of these express markers of vertebrate retinal interneurons. Overall, these data clarify Agnathan retinal homologies, reveal characters that now appear to be ubiquitous across the eyes of vertebrates, and refine interpretations of early vertebrate visual system evolution.

Igf signalling uncouples retina growth from body size by modulating progenitor cell division

Balancing the relative growth of body and organs is of key importance for coordinating size and function. This is of particular relevance in post-embryonically growing organisms, facing this challenge life-long. We addressed this question in the neuroretina of medaka fish (Oryzias latipes), where growth and size regulation are crucial for functional homeostasis of the visual system. We find that a central growth regulator, Igf1 receptor, is necessary and sufficient for proliferation control in the postembryonic retinal stem cell niche, the ciliary marginal zone (CMZ). Targeted activation of Igf1r signalling in the CMZ uncouples neuroretina growth from body size control, increasing layer thickness while preserving the structural integrity of the retina. The retinal expansion is driven exclusively by enhanced proliferation of progenitor cells while stem cells do not respond to Igf1r modulation. Our findings position Igf signalling as key module controlling retinal size and structure with far reaching evolutionary implications.

dnmt1 function is required to maintain retinal stem cells within the ciliary marginal zone of the zebrafish eye

The ciliary marginal zone (CMZ) of the zebrafish retina contains a population of actively proliferating resident stem cells, which generate retinal neurons throughout life. The maintenance methyltransferase, dnmt1, is expressed within the CMZ. Loss of dnmt1 function results in gene misregulation and cell death in a variety of developmental contexts, however, its role in retinal stem cell (RSC) maintenance is currently unknown. Here, we demonstrate that zebrafish dnmt1s872 mutants possess severe defects in RSC maintenance within the CMZ. Using a combination of immunohistochemistry, in situ hybridization, and a transgenic reporter assay, our results demonstrate a requirement for dnmt1 activity in the regulation of RSC proliferation, gene expression and in the repression of endogenous retroelements (REs). Ultimately, cell death is elevated in the dnmt1-/- CMZ, but in a p53-independent manner. Using a transgenic reporter for RE transposition activity, we demonstrate increased transposition in the dnmt1-/- CMZ. Taken together our data identify a critical role for dnmt1 function in RSC maintenance in the vertebrate eye.

Developmental delay during eye morphogenesis underlies optic cup and neurogenesis defects in mab21l2u517 zebrafish mutants

Background: Shaping the vertebrate eye requires evagination of the optic vesicles. These vesicles subsequently fold into optic cups prior to undergoing neurogenesis and allocating a population of late progenitors at the margin of the eye. mab21l2 encodes a protein of unknown biological function expressed in the developing optic vesicles, and loss of mab21l2 function results in malformed eyes. The bases of these defects are, however, poorly understood. Methods: To further study mab21l2 we used CRISPR/Cas9 to generate a new zebrafish mutant allele (mab21l2u517). We characterized eye morphogenesis and neurogenesis upon loss of mab21l2 function using tissue/cell-type-specific transgenes and immunostaining, in situ hybridization and bromodeoxyuridine incorporation. Results: mab21l2u517 eyes fail to grow properly and display an excess of progenitors in the ciliary marginal zone. The expression of a transgene reporter for the vsx2 gene –a conserved marker for retinal progenitors– was delayed in mutant eyes and accompanied by disruptions in the epithelial folding that fuels optic cup morphogenesis. Mutants also displayed nasal-temporal malformations suggesting asynchronous development along that axis. Consistently, nasal retinal neurogenesis initiated but did not propagate in a timely fashion to the temporal retina. Later in development, mutant retinas did laminate and differentiate. Thus, mab21l2u517 mutants present a complex eye morphogenesis phenotype characterized by an organ-specific developmental delay. Conclusions: We propose that mab21l2 facilitates optic cup development with consequences both for timely neurogenesis and allocation of progenitors to the zebrafish ciliary marginal zone. These results confirm and extend previous analyses supporting the role of mab21l2 in coordinating morphogenesis and differentiation in developing eyes.

Her9/Hes4 is required for retinal photoreceptor development, maintenance, and survival

The intrinsic and extrinsic factors that regulate vertebrate photoreceptor specification and differentiation are complex, and our understanding of all the players is far from complete. Her9, the zebrafish ortholog of human HES4, is a basic helix-loop-helix-orange (bHLH-O) transcriptional repressor that regulates neurogenesis in several developmental contexts. We have previously shown that her9 is upregulated during chronic rod photoreceptor degeneration and regeneration in adult zebrafish, but little is known about the role of her9 during retinal development. To better understand the function of Her9 in the retina, we generated zebrafish her9 CRISPR mutants. Her9 homozygous mutants displayed striking retinal phenotypes, including decreased numbers of rods and red/green cones, whereas blue and UV cones were relatively unaffected. The reduction in rods and red/green cones correlated with defects in photoreceptor subtype lineage specification. The remaining rods and double cones displayed abnormally truncated outer segments, and elevated levels of apoptosis. In addition to the photoreceptor defects, her9 mutants also possessed a reduced proliferative ciliary marginal zone, and decreased and disorganized Müller glia. Mutation of her9 was larval lethal, with no mutants surviving past 13 days post fertilization. Our results reveal a previously undescribed role for Her9/Hes4 in photoreceptor differentiation, maintenance, and survival.

Retinal stem cells modulate proliferative parameters to coordinate post-embryonic morphogenesis in the eye of fish

Combining clonal analysis with a computational agent based model, we investigate how tissue-specific stem cells for neural retina (NR) and retinal pigmented epithelium (RPE) of the teleost medaka (Oryzias latipes) coordinate their growth rates. NR cell division timing is less variable, consistent with an upstream role as growth inducer. RPE cells divide with greater variability, consistent with a downstream role responding to inductive signals. Strikingly, the arrangement of the retinal ciliary marginal zone niche results in a spatially biased random lineage loss, where stem- and progenitor cell domains emerge spontaneously. Further, our data indicate that NR cells orient division axes to regulate organ shape and retinal topology. We highlight an unappreciated mechanism for growth coordination, where one tissue integrates cues to synchronize growth of nearby tissues. This strategy may enable evolution to modulate cell proliferation parameters in one tissue to adapt whole-organ morphogenesis in a complex vertebrate organ.