Step 3: Critically Appraising Evidence

Critical appraisal of the evidence is the third step in the evidence-based practice process. This column, the first in a multipart series to describe the critical appraisal process, defines and provides examples of the levels of evidence and tools to begin the appraisal process using a rapid critical appraisal technique.

Relative Adrenal Insufficiency: Crisis Averted?

Relative adrenal insufficiency (AI) is a disease process commonly associated with preterm birth and critical illness. Further, the incidence of AI is inversely proportional to gestational age. The incidence of AI is likely underreported; however, it is reported to occur in 150–280/1,000,000 live births worldwide. Functional development of the adrenal gland does not occur until after 30 weeks of gestation; however, advances made in neonatal care increase the survivability of infants born well before this period. Among infants with AI, the adrenal gland is transiently incapable of secreting physiologic levels of cortisol in response to stressors. Common and nonspecific signs include hypotension, poor perfusion, and dysregulation of fluid, electrolytes, and euglycemia. Recognition, diagnosis, and steroid therapy is critical, as inappropriately managed AI can lead to an adrenal crisis, shock, and death. Understanding the presentation and common risk factors for developing relative AI is crucial for quick diagnosis and timely management to prevent morbidity and mortality in this vulnerable population.

Congenital Hypothyroidism

Congenital hypothyroidism (CH) is a disorder of thyroid hormone deficiency which develops secondary to incomplete thyroid development or inadequate thyroid hormone production. State-mandated newborn screening throughout the United States has increased the detection rate of CH, allowing for early intervention. Although the overall mortality rate of CH is low, delayed or omitted treatment can lead to devastating neurocognitive outcomes. As such, CH is regarded as the leading cause of preventable intellectual disability in children. Early identification, facilitated by astute neonatal nursing and medical care, is contingent upon an active working knowledge of the disease process and awareness of the limitations of the newborn screen.

Neonatal Seizures: Core Concepts

Seizures are the abnormal, excessive, synchronous discharge of cortical neurons that results in injury to the brain. Seizures presenting in the neonatal period may be the first and only clue to underlying neurological pathology. Despite advances in care, the mortality rate for infants experiencing neonatal seizures is still as high as 20 percent, with up to 65 percent of infants with seizures demonstrating significant morbidity. Early identification and treatment of the seizure or modifiable underlying etiology greatly reduces the extent of morbidity associated with neonatal seizures. Literature, including journal articles and relevant textbooks, was reviewed and condensed into a practical guide to neonatal seizures which includes the pathophysiology of injury associated with neonatal seizures, clinical manifestations, methods of diagnosis, and various options available for treatment.

Neuroprotective Agents for Neonates with Hypoxic-Ischemic Encephalopathy

Hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE) remains a significant source of long-term neurodevelopmental impairment despite overall improvements in survival without disability in neonates who undergo therapeutic hypothermia. Each phase in the evolution of hypoxic-ischemic injury presents potential pharmacologic targets for neuroprotective agents. Melatonin is a promising emerging therapy for early phases of ischemic injury, but utility is currently limited by the lack of pharmaceutical-grade products. Magnesium has been extensively studied for its neuroprotective effects in the preterm population. Studies in neonates with HIE have produced mixed outcomes. Erythropoietin use in HIE with or without therapeutic hypothermia appears to be safe and may provide additional benefit. Dexmedetomidine, N-acetylcysteine, xenon, and topiramate all have promising animal data, but need additional human trials to elucidate what role they may play in HIE. Frequent review of existing literature is required to ensure provision of evidence-based pharmacologic agents for neuroprotection following HIE.

Simulating Telehealth Experiences in the Neonatal Care Environment: Improving Access to Care

Telehealth in the neonatal environment can improve remote medical care and access to specialized care and training eliminating barriers for effective health care delivery. Clinicians are utilizing telehealth in their practice to provide specialized care and training in areas that have little access. Educating health care clinicians on the basics of telehealth is an essential component of clinical training programs. Use of simulation-based telehealth experiences as part of that training can provide hands-on learning in a safe, realistic environment. Simulation can prepare health care teams in using telehealth technology in managing patient care, postdischarge care, and specialized care programs.