Enercon India v. Enercon GmbH: Concluded Contract, Arbitration and Intellectual Property

Author(s):  
Anurag K. Agarwal

The case deals with the issues of technology transfer and protection of intellectual property in an international contract, with the International commercial arbitration as the dispute resolution method. The case highlights the distrust between parties when they do not want to continue doing business together and the use of legal technicalities to delay the matter from settling and utter confusion due to international nature of contract, multiple court proceedings in different countries and even questioning the status of the contract – whether a concluded contract or not.

2021 ◽  
Vol 58 (3) ◽  
pp. 929-941
Author(s):  
Ay Yunus Emre

International arbitration is widely enjoyed in international commercial disputes. Popular arbitral institutions are known for international commercial disputes. Moreover, academic papers generally analyse international commercial arbitration. However, intellectual property disputes are also resolved in arbitration. Therefore, WIPO set up arbitration and mediation institution in its body. Purpose of this paper is to emphasize that arbitration is also suitable alternative dispute resolution for intellectual property disputes.


2020 ◽  
pp. 73-79
Author(s):  
OLGA Golovko ◽  
Vladislava Druz

Problem setting. The active development of international trade in the 21st century requires the unification and consolidation of legislation and the creation of a unified law to enforce practice in areas related to international commercial arbitration and mediation. Economic disputes are an integral part of commercial relations. Arbitration as a mechanism for resolving conflicts is quite common. From French arbitrage translates as resolving a dispute by involving a mediator. At the same time, the parties may choose commercial mediation, consultation or negotiation. The implication is that it is quite difficult to choose only one method or the need to combine several methods to effectively resolve the dispute. Target of research. The purpose of the article is to analyze the main features of international commercial arbitration and mediation, determinate and establish peculiarities of legislative regulation in Ukraine and abroad. Analysis of recent researches and publications. A significant contribution to the study of this problem was made by O.M. Sadikov, N.O. Saniahmetova, M.M. Агарков, С.С. Alekseev, A.S. Vasiliev, O. A. Belyanevich, M. I. Braginsky, I. B. Zaverukha, I.E. Zamoysky, V.V. Kovalenko, G.F. Shershenev and others. Article’s main body. Ukraine has risen in the world rankings for the investment attractiveness «Doing Business 2020» – by 7 points and ranked 64th among 190 countries and significantly increased economic growth. This ensures the attractiveness of the investment market for Ukraine, which significantly affects the economic development of the country. For instance, a large number of agreements and obligations are concluded between the parties, in which the counterparties can be both the Ukrainian citizens and foreigners, which increases the growth rate of the Ukrainian economy. However, in the concluded agreements there are can be discrepancies, violations and improper fulfillment of obligations by contractors, which can turn into disrupts, interrelated contracts and even leads to a decrease in business activity and affects the reputation of such activities. To resolve such disputes, the parties have the opportunity to go to court or use alternative methods of resolving the conflict. At the discretion of the parties, alternative methods such as commercial mediation and international commercial arbitration are possible, which are designed to resolve disputes and disagreements arising from trading agreements. Conclusions and prospects for the development In conclusion, amendments in the legislation can help to precise the main advantages of international commercial arbitration and mediation, including: neutrality, centralized dispute resolution, final decision, confidentiality and time savings. That is why international commercial arbitration with the use of mediation is one of the most effective alternative methods of resolving commercial disputes. What is more, international arbitration and mediation as ways of alternative dispute resolution have been used since ancient times. However, recognition and enforcement at the level of state courts began in the 20th century – the signing of international conventions governing the procedure for enforcing and enforcing decisions, and states – parties to the conventions – ratified and enshrined in national law. In the future, there is an opportunity to improve the legislation by implementation of the new Act “On Mediation” and also by including mediation as a necessary part of arbitration process into the official rules.


LAW REVIEW ◽  
2018 ◽  
Vol 38 (1) ◽  
Author(s):  
Dr. Ashish Kumar Srivastava

International commercial arbitration is one of the most favourite mode of dispute resolution in world for resolving commercial disputes. Speed and cost are two important features what makes arbitrationa sought-after mode for dispute resolution because in conventional dispute resolution by courts ‘Remedy becomes worse than malady’ due to delay and cost. Legalism and authoritative courts in Anglo Saxon societies make the justice dilatory and expensive which is termed analogically as a disease of ‘Adversariasis’. Judicial minimalism is encouraged by entrepreneurs and business class of world which results in enhanced thrust on international commercial arbitration. In any arbitration interim measures are sine quo non. The irreparable loss and balance of convenience demands intervention by authoritative body to order and issue processes which can binds parties and third parties. In such cases unless interim measures are sought by municipal national courts no effective and binding interim remedies can be granted to the parties and third parties. The arbitrator once appointed is competent enough to grant interim measures and it can also decide about its jurisdiction based on doctrine of Kompetenz-Kompetenz. However, if before the appointment of arbitrator, the need of urgent interim measures arises then obviously parties have to go to the municipal national courts but this judicial intervention is not the intent of parties as they are seeking judicial minimalism. In such situations the urgent interim measures can be granted by emergency arbitrator. The Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 is silent about emergency arbitrator but Delhi and Bombay High Courts have given some pragmatic judgments, making the provision of emergency arbitrator, a reality. The real problem in emergency arbitrator is how one can grant interim relief even without being in existence i.e. when arbitrator itself is non est. ICC, SIAC and LCIA provide for emergency arbitrator. In this paper the author has tried to make an analytical and comparative overview of emergency arbitrator in Indian Perspective.


Author(s):  
Baumann Antje

This chapter discusses the arbitration rules of the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC). It begins with a background on the ICC International Court of Arbitration, with emphasis on its role in the development of international commercial arbitration. It then examines the 2017 ICC Arbitration Rules, citing some relevant figures related to ICC arbitration for the year 2017, including the number of parties involved in cases, the arbitral tribunals, and awards rendered by arbitral tribunals. Figures on other ICC dispute resolution rules are also given. The chapter concludes with a commentary of Articles 1–42 of the ICC Arbitration Rules, which cover topics such as definitions; time limits for written notifications or communications; request for arbitration and the respondent’s counterclaims to such a request; effect of the arbitration agreement; constitution of the arbitral tribunal; appointment, confirmation, challenge, and replacement of arbitrators; and rules of law applicable to the arbitral proceedings.


Author(s):  
Yves Dezalay ◽  
Bryant G. Garth

This chapter traces the development of international commercial arbitration, which is often presented as a response to the demand for law and dispute resolution created naturally by an increase in transnational commerce and investment. Indeed, the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) in Paris was relatively marginal from its establishment in 1923 until the increase in global trade and commerce that came in the 1970s and 1980s. The demand naturally created the supply. Based on the recognition that this market was not inevitable, it has been argued that the rise of international commercial arbitration depended on institutional entrepreneurs around the ICC. The chapter then looks at how the relatively marginal group around the ICC that Sgard studies gained credibility and acceptance from both multinational enterprises and developing countries.


This chapter examines the nature of international commercial arbitration and its distinguishing features; the harmonisation of the law of international commercial arbitration; international arbitration and the conflict of laws; the review of arbitral awards; and the recognition and enforcement of arbitral awards. Consideration is given to the contribution made by the UNCITRAL Model law on International Commercial Arbitration and to the rules of various arbitral institutions (such as the ICC) to the harmonisation of arbitral law and practice. Also examined is the relationship between arbitration and national courts and national law, particularly in the context of the debate over delocalisation.


Author(s):  
Nufaris Elisa

If an international trade dispute occurs, so that the ways of resolution can be reached through non-litigation (alternative litigation) or Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR). The facilities classified as ADR other than Arbitration facilities as contained in Article 6 of Law No. 30 of 1999 concerning Arbitration and Alternative Dispute Resolution which includes facilities including Meditation facilities, Negotiation facilities, Consolidation facilities, and other facilities. Based on the Arbitration Law it provides an opportunity to resolve trade disputes through the Arbitration institution and it is very appropriate if this institution has a very important role in resolving disputes that occur in the world of international trade. The scope of disputes which can be tried in a trial of the International Commercial Arbitration institution must be related to the issue of trade, finance and general trading (commerce), while those relating to other matters have nothing to do at all.


Legal Concept ◽  
2020 ◽  
pp. 129-135
Author(s):  
Ekaterina Kupchina

Introduction: in the paper the author considers such a complex and multi-level issue as cybersecurity in the international commercial arbitration, including when considering disputes related to the intellectual property violations. The rapidly developing areas of information technology dictate the need for rapid and adequate measures in this area. Modern approaches based on the risk assessment in each arbitration by the participants of the arbitration, as a result of which the arbitrators have the right to take measures based on the circumstances of each individual case, have become a subject of discussion in the modern scientific community. Although the significance of cybersecurity risks may vary from one case to another, the threat of a cyber attack occurs in almost every international arbitration. The purpose of the research is achieved by solving a number of tasks: to identify the most frequent cases of violation of the rights of legal rights holders; to highlight the problem of confidentiality of arbitration disputes. The methodology is based on a theoretical approach to the study of the arbitration rules, as well as a number of national sources and other normative acts. Based on the analysis of the theoretical data obtained, the author provides examples of the most frequent cases of violation of the confidentiality of arbitration proceedings, as well as highlights some modern approaches to solving this problem. The results of the research can be used in determining the key goals and objectives of the procedural nature, improving the functioning of judicial and non-judicial organizations, law enforcement, research, and teaching activities, in particular, lectures and seminars on private international law, arbitration, copyright and patent law. Conclusions: the increased awareness of participants of the international commercial arbitration about the ways of information storage and information security promotes the development of the institution of arbitration proceedings, increases the degree of confidence of the parties in the procedures for dispute resolution.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document