Numerical Study of the Effect of Honeycomb Tip on Tip Leakage Flow in Turbine Cascade

Author(s):  
Yunfeng Fu ◽  
Fu Chen ◽  
Cong Chen ◽  
Yanping Song

A novel leakage flow control strategy with honeycomb seal applied on the tip of the rotor blades in a highly-loaded turbine cascade is proposed. The numerical method is used to study the tip leakage flow in a highly-loaded turbine cascades with flat tip and with honeycomb seal structure, the mechanism of honeycomb tip on inhibiting leakage flow is analyzed, the influence of various relative gap heights is also been investigated. The discussions of the action of the honeycomb-tip structure in reducing leakage flow and improving the turbine efficiency provide the according for control methods of tip leakage flow. Through the comparative study among three different tip structures of honeycomb tip, honeycomb casing and flat tip, the results show that both honeycomb tip and honeycomb casing inhibit the leakage flow effectively, but honeycomb tip has positive effect on reducing the flow loss in cascade. For the cascade with honeycomb tip, on one hand, the vortices rolled up in the regular hexagon honeycomb cavities dissipate the energy of the tip leakage flow, and the range of influence of the vortices is nearly one third of the tip clearance height. On the other hand, the radial jets caused by the honeycomb obstruct the tip leakage flow like a “pneumatic fence”, resulting in weaker leakage flow and less leakage flow rate. Besides, the honeycomb tip reduces the scale of the leakage vortex, thus the leakage loss also decreases. Compared with the flat tip cascade at the clearance height of 1%H, the honeycomb tip cascade with the same clearance height obtains decrease of the leakage flow rate and leakage flow speed in circumference by 10.16% and 20%. As a result, the leakage vortex in honeycomb tip cascade is undermined, the loss is reduced by nearly 4.43%. Considering the abradable property of the honeycomb seal that can protect the blade tips from damage, the cascade with honeycomb tip structure can obtain a smaller clearance height and achieve better sealing effect. Compared to cascade with the flat tip at the clearance height of 2%H, the amount of leakage flow using inlet flow in the honeycomb tip cascades decreases by 17.33%, 36.63% and 54.79% at the clearance heights of 2%H, 1.5%H and 1%H, the losses related to the leakage flow is reduced by nearly 5.71%, 14.33% and 25.24%, respectively.

2018 ◽  
Vol 140 (6) ◽  
Author(s):  
Yunfeng Fu ◽  
Fu Chen ◽  
Huaping Liu ◽  
Yanping Song

In this paper, the effect of a novel honeycomb tip on suppressing tip leakage flow in turbine cascade has been experimentally and numerically studied. Compared to the flat tip cascade with 1%H blade height, the relative leakage flow in honeycomb tip cascade reduces from 3.05% to 2.73%, and the loss also decreases by 8.24%. For honeycomb tip, a number of small vortices are rolled up in the regular hexagonal honeycomb cavities to dissipate the kinetic energy of the clearance flow, and the fluid flowing into and out the cavities create aerodynamic interceptions to the upper clearance flow. As a result, the flow resistance in the clearance increased and the velocity of leakage flow reduced. As the gap height increases, the tip leakage flow and loss changes proportionally, but the growth rate in the honeycomb tip cascade is smaller. Considering its wear resistance of the honeycomb seal, a smaller gap height is allowed in the cascade with honeycomb tip, and that means honeycomb tip has better effect on suppressing leakage flow. Part honeycomb tip structure also retains the effect of suppressing leakage flow. It shows that locally convex honeycomb tip has better suppressing leakage flow effect than the whole honeycomb tip, but locally concave honeycomb tip is slightly less effective.


Author(s):  
Shaowen Chen ◽  
Weihang Li ◽  
Qinghe Meng ◽  
Zhihua Zhou ◽  
Songtao Wang

Sweeping jet actuator as a fresh attempt has been applied in controlling flow separations and improving aerodynamic performances in a linear turbine cascade with tip clearance. In the present study, the oscillating jet process of sweeping jet actuator in the tip clearance was illustrated and a potential advantage from a system integration perspective was validated by an unsteady numerical study. The excitation frequencies and excitation modes were also investigated for achieving the further understanding of the mechanism of sweeping jet actuator for controlling flow separations. By using sweeping jet actuator, the flow separation near the upper endwall was delayed and the flow loss at the outlet of the cascade was reduced. For the optimal case, the time-averaged total pressure loss decreased by about 11.7% with the jet flow rate of only 0.35% of the inlet flow rate. In addition, it was found that there exists an optimum frequency to achieve the optimum controlling effects on the flow separations. Because of the blockage of tip leakage flow at the local gap by the high-momentum fluid from sweeping jet actuator, the controlling effects on the tip leakage vortex loss were better than that on the passage vortex loss. Through the use of four excitation modes in this study, the total pressure losses at the outlet were all reduced in different degrees. Under the present boundary conditions and working parameters, the unsteady controlling mode of sweeping jet actuator was found to perform much better than the other steady modes.


Author(s):  
Yunfeng Fu ◽  
Fu Chen ◽  
Huaping Liu ◽  
Yanping Song

In this paper, the effect of a novel honeycomb tip on suppressing tip leakage flow in a highly-loaded turbine cascade has been experimentally and numerically studied. The research focuses on the mechanisms of honeycomb tip on suppressing tip leakage flow and affecting the secondary flow in the cascade, as well as the influences of different clearance heights on leakage flow characteristics. In addition, two kinds of local honeycomb tip structures are pro-posed to explore the positive effect on suppressing leakage flow in simpler tip honeycomb structures. Based on the experimental and numerical results, the physical processes of tip leakage flow and its interaction with main flow are analyzed, the following conclusions can be obtained. Honeycomb tip rolls up a number of small vortices and radial jets in regular hexagonal honeycomb cavities, increasing the flow resistance in the clearance and reducing the velocity of leakage flow. As a result, the structure of honeycomb tip not only suppresses the leakage flow effectively, but also has positive effect on reducing the associated losses in cascade by reducing the strength of leakage vortex. Compare to the flat tip cascade at 1%H gap height, the relative leakage flow in honeycomb tip cascade reduces from 3.05% to 2.73%, and the loss at exit section is also decreased by 10.63%. With the increase of the gap height, the tip leakage flow and loss have variations of direct proportion with it, but their growth rates in the honeycomb tip cascade are smaller. Consider the abradable property of the honeycomb seal, a smaller gap height is allowed in the cascade with honeycomb tip, and that means honeycomb tip has better effect on suppressing leakage flow. Two various local honeycomb tip structures has also been discussed. It shows that local raised honeycomb tip has better suppressing leakage flow effect than honeycomb tip, while local concave honeycomb tip has no more effect than honeycomb tip. Compare to flat tip cascade, the leakage flow in honeycomb tip cascade, local concave tip cascade and local raised honeycomb tip cascade decrease by nearly 17.33%, 15.51% and 30.86% respectively, the losses at exit section is reduced by 13.38%, 12% and 28.17% respectively.


Author(s):  
Kai Zhou ◽  
Chao Zhou

In turbines, secondary vortices and tip leakage vortices develop and interact with each other. In order to understand the flow physics of vortices interaction, the effects of incoming vortex on the downstream tip leakage flow are investigated in terms of the aerodynamic performance in a turbine cascade. Experimental, numerical and analytical methods are used. In the experiment, a swirl generator was used upstream near the casing to generate the incoming vortex, which interacted with the tip leakage vortex in the turbine cascade. The swirl generator was located at ten different pitchwise locations to simulate the quasi-steady effects. In the numerical study, a Rankine-like vortex was defined at the inlet of the computational domain to simulate the incoming swirling vortex. Incoming vortices with opposite directions were investigated. The vorticity of the positive incoming swirling vortex has a large vector in the same direction as that of the tip leakage vortex. In the case of the positive incoming swirling vortex, the vortex mixes with the tip leakage vortex to form one vortex near the tip as it transports downstream. The vortices interaction reduces the vorticity of the flow near the tip, as well as the loss by making up for the streamwise momentum within the tip leakage vortex core. In contrast, the negative incoming swirling vortex has little effects on the tip leakage vortex and the loss. As the negative incoming swirling vortex transports downstream, it is separated from the tip leakage vortex and forms two vortices. A triple-vortices-interaction kinetic analytical model and one-dimensional mixing model are proposed to explain the mechanism of vortex interaction on the aerodynamic performance.


Author(s):  
Jingjun Zhong ◽  
Shaobing Han ◽  
Peng Sun

The effect of tip winglet on the aerodynamic performance of compressor cascade are mainly determined by the location of the tip winglet, the tip winglet geometry, the size of tip clearance, and the aerodynamic parameters of the cascade. In this paper, an extensive numerical study which includes three aspects has been carried out to investigate the effects of these influencing factors in a highly-loaded compressor cascade in order to give the guidance for the application of tip winglet to control the tip leakage in modern highly-loaded compressor. Firstly, the numerical method is validated by comparing the numerical results with available measured data. Results show that the numerical procedure is valid and accurate. Then, the cascade flow fields are interrogate to identify the physical mechanism of how suction-side winglet improve the cascade flow behavior. It is found that a significant tip leakage mass flow rate and aerodynamic loss reduction is possible by using proper tip winglet located near the suction side corner of the blade tip. Finally, an optimum width of the suction-side tip winglet is obtained by comparing the compressor performance with different clearances and incidences. The use of the suction-side winglet can reduce the pressure difference between the pressure and the suction sides of the blade and tip leakage velocity ratio. And the winglet also can compact the tip leakage vortex structure, which is benefit to decrease the loss of the tip secondary flow mixing with the primary flow.


Author(s):  
Hark-Jin Eum ◽  
Shin-Hyoung Kang

Effects of tip clearance on through flows and performance of a centrifugal compressor impeller with six different tip clearances were numerically studied using CFX-TASCflow. The flow structures inside the impeller of a centrifugal compressor were visualized observing streamlines starting the leading edge of blade tips. The calculated results at the impeller exit were circumferential averaged for quantitative discussion. Flow, pressure and entropy contours at the impeller exit were largely influenced by the tip leakage flow. Tip clearance effect on the performance was decomposed into inviscid and viscous components using one-dimensional relations expressed in terms of the specific work reduction and the additional entropy generation. Both inviscid and viscous effects affected performance to similar extent, while efficiency drop was mainly influenced by viscous loss of the tip leakage flow. Performance reduction and efficiency drop due to tip clearance was proportional to the ratio of tip clearance to blade height. A simple model suggested in the present study predicts performance and efficiency drop quite successfully.


Author(s):  
Fu Chen ◽  
Yunfeng Fu ◽  
Jianyang Yu ◽  
Yanping Song

In this paper, the control mechanism of the honeycomb tip structure on the tip leakage flow of a turbine cascade is studied experimentally and numerically, and the sensitivity of tip leakage flow characteristics to different clearance heights from 0.5% to 2% based on the blade span are mainly discussed. A flat tip is considered as a comparative case. The results show that a part of the leakage flow enters the tip honeycomb cavity, forming small-scale vortices and mixes with the upper leakage fluid, which increases the flow resistance within the clearance. In the range of clearance height variation investigated, honeycomb tip structure can effectively reduce the leakage flow, and reduce the size and strength of the leakage vortex, so that the loss of the cascade is reduced. At a large tip clearance height, the unstable split of the vortex cores causes the vortex in the honeycomb cavities near pressure side to grow in size, so that the vortex extends further into the upper gap, where the turbulent blocking effect of the vortices on the leakage flow is increased. However, due to the vortex movement and the mixing between honeycomb vortices and the upper clearance flow, there is no obvious advantage in reducing the total loss of the cascade compared to the small tip clearance height.


Author(s):  
Jiahui Jin ◽  
Yanping Song ◽  
Jianyang Yu ◽  
Fu Chen

Tip geometry modification is frequently used to suppress the tip leakage flow in the turbine cascade however a universally beneficial tip geometry modification design has not been fully discovered. In this paper, the two-surface coupling arbitrary blade tip design method in three-dimensional physical space which satisfies the simple trigonometric function law is proposed and the mathematical parametric description is presented. The effects of different arbitrary blade tips on tip leakage flow have been studied numerically in a highly loaded axial turbine cascade. The aerodynamic performance of different tips is assessed by the tip leakage mass flow rate and the total pressure loss coefficient at the exit section. The Kriging model and genetic optimization algorithm are used to optimize the arbitrary blade tips to obtain the optimal arbitrary blade tip. Compared with the flat tip, the tip leakage mass flow rate is decreased by 10.57% and the area-average total pressure loss coefficient at the exit section is reduced by 8.91% in the optimal arbitrary blade tip.


Author(s):  
Yoojun Hwang ◽  
Shin-Hyoung Kang

A low speed axial compressor with casing treatment of axial slots was numerically investigated. Time-accurate numerical calculations were performed to simulate unsteady flow in the rotor tip region and the effects of casing treatment on the flow. Since the compressor rotor had a large tip clearance, it was found that the tip leakage flow had an inherent unsteady feature that was not associated with rotor rotation. The unsteadiness of the tip leakage flow was induced by changes in the blade loading due to the pressure distribution formed by the tip leakage flow. This characteristic is called rotating instability or self-induced unsteadiness. The frequency of the flow oscillation was found to decrease as the flow rate was reduced. On the other hand, as expected, the operating range was improved by casing treatment, as shown by calculations in good agreement with the experimentally measured data. The unsteadiness of the tip leakage flow was alleviated by the casing treatment. The interaction between the flow in the tip region and the re-circulated flow through the axial slots was observed in detail. The removal and injection of flow through the axial slots were responsible not only for the extension of the operating range but also for the alleviation of the unsteadiness. Analyses of instantaneous flow fields explained the mechanism of the interaction between the casing treatment and the unsteady oscillation of the tip leakage flow. Furthermore, the effects of changes in the amount of re-circulation and the location of the removal and injection flow on the unsteadiness of the tip leakage flow were examined.


Author(s):  
Yuping Qian ◽  
Jian Cui ◽  
Chaoqing Chen ◽  
Yifang Gong ◽  
Qiushi Li

The tip leakage flow rate can be directly linked to the loss and stall margin. In this paper, key factors affecting the tip leakage flow rate are explained based on a simple leakage flow model including viscous effect. Based on the numerical results, the flow model is verified in a low speed compressor rotor, and finally a simplified one-dimensional tip blockage model is established based on the Khalid’s model, which may be helpful in the design of compressor.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document