Evaluation Using Random Assignment Experiments: Demonstrating the Effectiveness of Earnings Supplements

2003 ◽  
Vol 186 ◽  
pp. 73-84
Author(s):  
Doug Tattrie ◽  
Reuben Ford

The UK is preparing to start one of the largest random assignment evaluations of a new social policy that has ever been undertaken in Europe or North America. This juncture is a useful time to examine the merits of random assignment evaluation using new results from one-of the most widely cited experimental evaluations the Self-Sufficiency Project in Canada. Random assignment experiments are the most reliable approach to measure the impacts of changes in social policy. However, they are often expensive and cannot answer all relevant research questions. The Canadian Self-Sufficiency Project demonstrates these qualities. It showed that the provision of earnings supplements to lone parents who leave welfare for full-time work can increase employment and earnings and decrease welfare receipt. The high quality of research provides credible evidence that the large, initial programme expenditure can mostly be recovered through reduced welfare payments and higher taxes.

2003 ◽  
Vol 58 (2) ◽  
pp. 258-286 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kelly Foley ◽  
Saul Schwartz

Summary The Self-Sufficiency Project (SSP) offered a generous but time-limited earnings supplement to a randomly assigned group of lone parents—who were also long-term social assistance recipients—if they found full-time work and left social assistance. Employment data was collected for this group over a three-year period following the offer, and for a randomly-assigned control group. This article analyzes the characteristics of the first job that SSP participants found after they left social assistance. The occupations and industries of the first job held are analyzed as is SSP’s impact on hourly wages, weekly hours and job stability. The article finds that SSP increased employment in jobs that were no worse (and no better) than the jobs that participants might have taken in the absence of the program.


2020 ◽  
Vol 30 (4) ◽  
pp. 509-517
Author(s):  
Kitty Stewart ◽  
Kerris Cooper ◽  
Isabel Shutes

While social policy falls predominantly under national rather than European Union (EU) jurisdiction, there are nonetheless multiple ways in which social policy and social outcomes in EU member states have been affected by EU membership. This paper draws on existing evidence and analysis to review the consequences for UK social policy of the decision to leave the EU. We focus predominantly on the implications of the British government’s pledge to ‘take back control’ of money, borders and laws. Our conclusion is that Brexit is likely to have negative effects on the quality of public services and, for some groups in particular, social rights, and that these effects are likely to be greater the more distant are the future trading and wider relationships between the UK and the EU27.


Blood ◽  
2008 ◽  
Vol 112 (11) ◽  
pp. 4671-4671
Author(s):  
Louise M Arnold ◽  
Jill Stephenson ◽  
Richard Kelly ◽  
David Buchanan ◽  
Gareth Jones ◽  
...  

Abstract Paroxysmal Nocturnal Hemoglobinuria (PNH) is an acquired clonal stem cell disease, characterised by intravascular hemolysis, bone marrow failure and lifethreatening thromboses. The median survival is 10–15 years, with the average age of presentation being in the 30’s. Symptoms include hemoglobinuria, fatigue, anemia, venous and arterial thromboses, recurrent pain, renal impairment, erectile dysfunction and pulmonary hypertension. The care of a patient with PNH is complex and challenging, as many experience chronic symptoms with periods of acute exacerbations. Historically the management of PNH included bone marrow transplant, blood transfusion and administration of additional supportive therapies, all necessitating regular visits to the hospital. Eculizumab, a monoclonal antibody that binds to the C5 complement component inhibiting the activity of terminal complement and thus preventing the destruction of red blood cells has dramatically altered the management of hemolytic PNH. Clinical trials of eculizumab demonstrated the resolution of the majority of symptoms and complications of PNH and resulted in its approval in the UK in June 2007. Eculizumab is administered as a 30 minute intravenous infusion every 14 days, and under the terms of its current EU licence, must be administered by a healthcare professional. In view of the rarity of PNH there are relatively few specialist Centres for the disease resulting in, patients travelling long distances for review and treatment. In view of the dramatic improvement in symptoms on eculizumab many patients are able to return to a near normal lifestyle. In the UK, Leeds Teaching Hospitals with Healthcare at Home have developed a home infusion programme that ensures safe administration of eculizumab in the patient’s home at a time convenient to them, leading to enhanced treatment-associated convenience for patients and their families. Patients then only attend the PNH Centre every 3 months to ensure appropriate monitoring and patient education. A recent survey of patients reports a reduction in treatment-associated burden for PNH patients and their families when receiving infusions at home. 46 patients responded to the survey with just over half receiving eculizumab. Of the 21 patients at the time receiving home infusions 19 found this more convenient than the hospital. Home treatment allows flexibility and for some, the return to full-time employment, with the associated financial benefits and improvement in psychological well-being. Of the 21 patients on home care 7 stated there ability to work was transformed with a further 10 having great improvement. Whilst the purpose of the survey was not to address financial burden, the home infusion programme has anecdotally reduced the financial burden on the patient and their family by eliminating the need for time off work, allowing return to full-time employment, and eliminating the cost of travel to and from the hospital for treatments. No patients reporting negative impact, including effect on social life and family relationships, whilst 15 experienced improvement or complete transformation in both areas. The patients reported confidence in the homecare programme, knowing that a very close working relationship existed between the expert hospital and homecare teams. This innovative programme of medication delivery by a dedicated home nursing team allows patients who have previously struggled to cope with their illness to lead a near normal life with an associated enhancement in quality of life. Patients are able to carry on with activities of daily life, including work, recreational activities and holidays, whilst at the same time ensuring compliance with treatment and therefore allowing maximum therapeutic benefit.


2017 ◽  
Vol 39 (2) ◽  
pp. 48-49
Author(s):  
Gabriele Butkute

In an age where huge amounts of data is collected on everything we do – from our Google searches to our GPS coordinates – we like to be able to count, measure and assess things. This includes measuring the impact and quality of research in the UK, through an assessment method known as the Research Excellence Framework (REF).


F1000Research ◽  
2015 ◽  
Vol 4 ◽  
pp. 66 ◽  
Author(s):  
Catherine Joynson ◽  
Ottoline Leyser

In 2014, the UK-based Nuffield Council on Bioethics carried out a series of engagement activities, including an online survey to which 970 people responded, and 15 discussion events at universities around the UK to explore the culture of research in the UK and its effect on ethical conduct in science and the quality of research. The findings of the project were published in December 2014 and the main points are summarised here. We found that scientists are motivated in their work to find out more about the world and to benefit society, and that they believe collaboration, multidisciplinarity, openness and creativity are important for the production of high quality science. However, in some cases, our findings suggest, the culture of research in higher education institutions does not support or encourage these goals or activities. For example, high levels of competition and perceptions about how scientists are assessed for jobs and funding are reportedly contributing to a loss of creativity in science, less collaboration and poor research practices. The project led to suggestions for action for funding bodies, research institutions, publishers and editors, professional bodies and individual researchers.


Author(s):  
Jorgen Hansen

Abstract This paper analyzes the effects of human capital on welfare dynamics in Canada using data from the Self-Sufficiency Project (SSP). SSP offered a time-limited earnings supplement to a randomly assigned group of new welfare applicants who remained on welfare for one year and, in the subsequent year, left welfare for full-time employment. The results suggest that high school completion has no significant impact on the exit rate from welfare or on the re-entry rate. Moreover, full-time work experience is found to reduce the risk of returning to welfare but not for respondents who were assigned to the treatment group. This finding suggests that the provision of an earnings subsidy encourages welfare recipients to accept low-wage jobs with little gains from work experience. Thus, the rationale for such a policy that work today will raise experience and consequently future wages is not supported by the results in this paper.


2008 ◽  
Vol 5 (1) ◽  
pp. 3-4 ◽  
Author(s):  
Geraldine Holt ◽  
Helen Costello ◽  
Nick Bouras

Services for people with intellectual disabilities, in the UK as elsewhere, have changed dramatically over the last 30 years; deinstitutionalisation has probably been the largest experiment in social policy in our time. The vast majority of people with intellectual disabilities, their families and carers have benefited from having a better quality of life as a result of deinstitutionalisation. However, much still needs to be done to integrate this population more into society and to ensure they are offered the appropriate supports to meet their needs.


2003 ◽  
Vol 5 (2) ◽  
pp. 143-165 ◽  
Author(s):  
Claire Annesley

A number of recent accounts of UK social policy under New Labour have emphasised the continuing Americanisation of the British welfare state. This article does not deny the influence of the US but rather seeks to balance it with an account of the growing Europeanisation of UK social policy. It argues that Americanisation and Europeanisation are distinct in terms of both content and process. Since these are not mutually exclusive, the UK is currently influenced by both. This situation is illustrated by looking at three social policy issues under New Labour: social exclusion, the New Deal and the treatment of lone parents.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document