Positive and Negative Symptom Course in Chronic Community-Based Patients

1995 ◽  
Vol 166 (5) ◽  
pp. 634-641 ◽  
Author(s):  
Donald M. Quinlan ◽  
David Schuldberg ◽  
Hal Morgenstern ◽  
William Glazer

BackgroundThe long-term symptom profile of chronic out-patients was studied.Method. 242 out-patients receiving neuroleptic medications (109 with schizophrenia and 133 non-schizophrenics), were studied for positive (SAPS) and negative (SANS) symptoms at baseline and at 24 months to investigate whether these symptom groups changed over out-patient maintenance treatment.ResultsOverall and within groups, negative symptoms decreased and positive symptoms increased. While the sums of the SANS scores for the schizophrenic patients were initially higher, their mean SANS score dropped more over time (P< 0.001), to show no difference from non-schizophrenics at follow-up. Positive symptoms increased in both groups, although schizophrenics were higher at both times; sub-scales within the SANS showed different patterns of change.ConclusionSupport is found for a multidimensional view of both positive and negative symptoms and for a reconsideration of the notion of ‘progressive downward course’ in schizophrenia.

1995 ◽  
Vol 166 (1) ◽  
pp. 61-67 ◽  
Author(s):  
Hai-Gwo Hwu ◽  
Happy Tan ◽  
Chu-Chang Chen ◽  
Ling-Ling Yeh

BackgroundThe clinical significance in schizophrenia of positive and negative symptoms at discharge was assessed.MethodOf schizophrenic patients fulfilling DSM–III criteria, 113 were recruited for this study. Personal, social and psychopathological data were collected and all cases were followed up at one and two years after discharge.ResultsThe presence of positive symptoms (64 cases), without concomitant negative symptoms, did not predict the follow-up social function and positive symptom score. Conversely, the presence of negative symptoms (31 cases) predicted worse social functioning (P < 0.05 to P < 0.005) and higher positive symptom scores (P < 0.01) at follow-up using MANOVA. Eighteen cases (15.9%) had neither positive nor negative symptoms and had the best clinical outcome.ConclusionsNegative, but not positive, symptoms assessed at discharge are an important predictor of poor outcome. In addition, negative symptoms may themselves expose a biological vulnerability to the presence of positive symptoms.


2020 ◽  
Vol 46 (Supplement_1) ◽  
pp. S81-S82
Author(s):  
Marie Starzer ◽  
Carsten Hjorthøj ◽  
Nikolai Albert ◽  
Merete Nordentoft ◽  
Helene Lund Sørensen

Abstract Background Since the first OPUS trial 20 years ago, structured clinical assessments have been collected from a cohort of first episode psychosis patients at 2, 5 and 10 years follow-up. They found that the symptomatology of patients clustered in distinct groups, and they were able to determine stable long-term trajectories of positive and negative symptoms. The Suffolk County Medical health project has followed patients after a first episode psychosis for 20 years. They also found a stable course of trajectories but with an overall significant worsening of symptom severity over time. The 20 year OPUS follow-up will give us the first opportunity to assess the long term outcome in a large representative cohort treated within modern mental health services with treatment available for all. Methods From 1998 to 2000 578 participants were randomized to OPUS or TAU. Baseline characteristics of the cohort were as follows: mean age 26.6 years, 59% were males, 66% had a diagnosis of schizophrenia and 27% had a secondary diagnosis of alcohol or substance abuse At the 20 year follow-up the investigators will be blinded to the original treatment allocation. The patients who wish to participate will be assessed using SAPS, SANS, SCAN, PSP and GAF. Socio-demographic factors and suicidal ideation will be register via self report. Cognitive function will be tested using BACS and all participants will be asked to fill out a number of self-rating questioners including WHO quality of life-BREF, self-perceived health, strengths and difficulties, the parenting scale and self-perceived negative symptoms. Using national Danish registers we can collect information on all former participants regarding the use of psychiatric and general healthcare services, medication, supported housing or homelessness, employment status, substance abuse and mortality. Results The OPUS 20 study started collecting data in Jan 2018. We are attempting to contact as many patients as possible from the 578 participants in the original OPUS cohort. At the time of writing we had included data and attempted contact to 322 participants. Overall 104 people (31,7%) have agreed to participate in the interviews. In the follow-up 10 years ago, the participation-rate was 60% so this is a big drop in participation rate. 41 (14%) have died, 31 (9,5%) were lost due to emigration, homelessness or hidden identity and/or disempowerment. 70 (21,3%) didn’t wish to participate and 76 (23,2%) never responded. Discussion Psychotic disorders and schizophrenia in particular are associated with progressive worsening of symptoms and profound social impairment, and as such are still very stigmatized. Results from the 10 year OPUS follow-up found stable trajectories of positive and negative symptoms over time, with a tendency of reduction and stabilization of positive symptoms but less variation of negative symptoms. They found poor but stable social functioning with a mean GAF score of 55 after 10 years. The Suffolk County mental health project also found stable trajectories of psychopathology measured with SAPS and SANS. They however found progressive worsening of GAF scores declining form 49 points at the beginning to 36 after 20 years. So far we have seen stable GAF scores and SAPS and SANS scores compared to OPUS 10. This gives rise to some optimism about the prognosis for schizophrenia compared to the findings of the Suffolk study. In our study the extensive interviews combined with the data collected form Danish registers give us a unique opportunity to look at the long term course of illness after FEP. The ability to test if previous findings are robust over time will be essential to the development of targeted interventions, differentiated to the needs of different patient groups.


1986 ◽  
Vol 148 (5) ◽  
pp. 587-589 ◽  
Author(s):  
Michael R. Trimble

The terms positive and negative symptoms have slipped into the language of contemporary psychiatry with comparative ease. It is not uncommon for these expressions to be used with little explanation, both at meeting and in written communications, with the implicit understanding that their meaning is understood and that somehow they are of value to our knowledge of psychopathology. However, that there are no clear guide-lines at present for our use of these terms is shown from a recent survey of psychiatrists' opinions from a market research company (Martin Hamblin Research-Personal Communication). As part of a series of questions asked to many psychiatrists of differing age, geographical location, and status, they were asked about the meaning of these terms, positive and negative symptoms and the proportion of schizophrenic patients having them. Of the categories quoted by Crow (1980–81) as positive symptoms, 68% considered that delusions were positive symptoms, 63% hallucinations, and only 35% thought disorder. In contrast, 18% thought that behaviour disturbance was a positive symptom, a similar figure (15%) being given for passivity feelings. Considerable variation was noted, however, with hallucinations being considered positive by only 33% of London psychiatrists, thought disorder by only 11% of those qualified 16–25 years, and one-quarter of all registrars and psychiatrists from Midland Health Districts considered passivity feelings to fall into this category. Even greater disagreement was recorded for negative symptoms. Thus, the symptom most often associated with this category was apathy, by 52% of respondents. Only 26% considered that withdrawal was a negative symptom, the percentage data for lack of motivation and blunting of affect being 37% and 15% respectively.


1994 ◽  
Vol 165 (S24) ◽  
pp. 70-79 ◽  
Author(s):  
Mingyuan Zhang ◽  
Heqin Yan ◽  
Michael R. Phillips

This paper describes the community mental health services in Shanghai, analyses the effectiveness of these services, and discusses their culture-specific characteristics. It reports on a prospective, matched-control study of the three most important types of service: a community follow-up programme in psychiatric out-patient clinics at primary-level general hospitals, ‘guardianship networks’ operated by non-professional volunteers, and work therapy stations. In total 308 pairs of subjects completed the study. Using Chinese versions of the Disability Assessment Schedule to assess impairment in psychosocial functioning and the Present State Examination to assess the levels of positive and negative symptoms, ten blind evaluators who had excellent inter-rater reliability assessed the functioning of subjects at enrolment and every six months for the next two years. Over the two years, symptoms and social functioning improved in the treatment groups and deteriorated in the control groups. Thus these community psychiatric services have the dual benefit of promoting rehabilitation and preventing psychosocial deterioration.


1997 ◽  
Vol 3 (6) ◽  
pp. 339-346 ◽  
Author(s):  
Ann Mortimer

At most, 15% of patients in Western countries remain free of relapse after their first episode of schizophrenia (Crow et al, 1986). Like many chronic illnesses, schizophrenia can be controlled by appropriate treatment, but there may be a gradual deterioration over time. This encompasses problems such as loss of self-care, communication and community skills; negative symptoms of poverty of affect and ideation; cognitive impairment; behaviour problems such as aggression; and poorly controlled positive symptoms.


2020 ◽  
Vol 46 (Supplement_1) ◽  
pp. S78-S78
Author(s):  
Ege Bor ◽  
Diego Quattrone ◽  
Victoria Rodriguez ◽  
Luis Alameda ◽  
Sinan Guloksuz ◽  
...  

Abstract Background Current clinical utility of diagnostic categories in patients with psychosis is in debate. Alternatively, symptom-based dimensional approaches are suggested, but research on their utility and longitudinal stability is at its early phases, showing lack of consistencies. The aims of this prospective study are: 1) to test the stability of structure of symptom dimensions in first episode psychosis patients; 2) to explore the utility of symptom dimensions in predicting clinical and functional outcomes. Methods This study included a total of 208 with first episode of psychosis-spectrum disorders aged 18–65 years who presented to psychiatric services in South London, recruited as part of the Genetics and Psychosis Outcome (GAP) case-control study and EU-GEI multicentre case-control study. A subsample of 114 patients were traced after a mean of 6.5 years. Psychopathology was assessed at baseline and at follow-up using OPCRIT and tested with bifactor model, encompassing one general psychosis dimension and five specific symptom dimensions (positive, negative, disorganisation, mania, and depression). Follow up measures on functional outcome (assessed with GAF scale) and clinical outcomes (number and total length of hospitalisations) were derived from clinical records. Predictor role of baseline symptom dimensions was tested by multiple linear regression to predict global functioning; and by negative binomial regression for length of hospitalisation and number of hospital admissions. Results Factor loadings of disorganisation dimension were most likely to change longitudinally while loadings of positive dimension were most stable. Regarding dimension stability over time, all positive, disorganised and depressive symptoms significantly improved over time while manic and negative symptoms did not significantly differ. In terms of prediction of outcome, baseline manic symptoms were associated with reduced risk of hospitalisation (adj OR 1.56; 95% CI 1.01–2.38), reduced length of hospitalisation (adj IRR= 0.73; 95% CI 0.56–0.95) and better global functioning (β=5.21; 95% CI 2.46–7.95) at follow up. Similarly, depressive symptoms were associated with reduced length of hospitalisation (adj IRR= 0.77; CI 0.61–0.97). On the other hand, baseline positive symptoms were associated with increased risk of hospitalisation (adj OR 1.93; 95% CI 1.25–2.96). No other significant associations were found between the rest of symptom dimensions and outcomes. Discussion This study provides new evidence on the longitudinal stability of bifactor model of psychosis and, shows that all except manic and negative symptoms significantly improved over time. Whereas affective symptoms (including mania and depression) were associated with good prognosis, positive symptoms seem to predict poor clinical outcomes. The particular and different influence of affective and psychotic symptoms on long-term functional and clinical outcomes may have therapeutic implications and support the potential clinical utility of incorporating symptom-based approach in further outcome research.


Psychiatry ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 18 (2) ◽  
pp. 21-31
Author(s):  
S. A. Stolyarov

Background: the comparative aspect of the clinical-diagnostic and prognostic evaluation of long-term remissions treated with antipsychotics of various generations in patients with shift-like schizophrenia remains poorly studied and retains scientific and practical actuality. The purpose of the study: a comparative study of the therapeutic effect of antipsychotics of different generations on clinical-psychopathological peculiarities and the dynamics of 2-year remissions after acute paranoid states in patients with shift-like schizophrenia. Patients and methods: 34 female patients (average age made up 26.9 years old) were diagnosed in shift-like schizophrenia with a clinical picture of the attack as acute paranoid syndrome (F20.02 according to ICD-10). 16 patients received treatment with typical neuroleptics (TN), other 18 patients received atypical neuroleptics (ATN). The study was conducted as an open prospective, using clinical-psychopathological, clinical-catamnestic and clinical-psychometric methods. The mental state of patients was assessed four times: upon admission to the hospital in acute psychosis (1 point), when entering remission (2 points), after 1 and 2 years of remission (3 and 4 points). In psychometric assessment was used calculated for 1 patient indices of the main total score of all signs (MTS) and main score of 1 sign (MS) of the PANSS scale and its subscales of positive (P), negative (N) and general psychopathological (G) syndromes. Results: at the end of the active treatment with both types of antipsychotics at the 2 point of assessment, was reduced MS of positive symptoms P+G subscales from 3.3 to 1.7 scores on TN and from 3.8 to 2.2 scores on ATN, with a remission and stabilization of the achieved improvement with reduction of MS at 4 points up to 1.5. MS of negative symptoms by the 2 nd  year of remission on ATN decreased from 2.7 to 2.0 in parallel with the reduction of positive signs by P + G; on TN there was an increase in MS indices of subscale N from 2.3 to 2.7 scores. The assessment of negative disorders is discussed as “secondary” negative due to the phenomenologically is assumed with the symptoms of the positive syndrome and the effects of neurolepsy. Conclusion: TN and ATN exhibit a similar “antipsychotic” effect in the treatment of acute paranoid psychoses in shift-like schizophrenia patients with the formation of long-term high quality remissions, stabilization of degrees of reducted productive psychopathological symptoms and with the absence of the progredience disease. To optimize the therapeutic effect of both types of antipsychotics, it is recommended correction of the regime and the term in transition from active to maintenance therapy and prescription of neurolepsy correctors to reduce severity in the picture of “secondary” negative symptoms.


Author(s):  
Anatoly Smulevich ◽  
Dmitry Romanov

The chapter focuses on the relationship of negative and positive symptoms in schizophrenia. Negative symptoms should be evaluated in a relation to positive symptoms both cross-sectionally and long term (prospectively/retrospectively). Two types of long-term interaction between negative and positive symptoms could be distinguished: (1) relatively synchronized, and (2) relatively desynchronized. Synchronization of negative and positive symptoms is characterized by their unidirectional long-term course. Desynchronization is characterized by their bidirectional long-term relations: (1) negative schizophrenia with minimal positive symptoms at the beginning of the disease and further progression of negative symptoms; or (2) schizophrenia with negative symptoms ‘that stopped at the very beginning’, and the later course is characterized by positive symptoms. Considering every single time point of the long-term relationship between negative and positive symptoms (cross-sectionally), the chapter describes the concept of ‘mutual/common syndromes’ (consisting of both positive and negative symptoms) at different stages of schizophrenia, including residual deficit states.


2014 ◽  
Vol 48 (1) ◽  
pp. 47-55 ◽  
Author(s):  
Barbara Remberk ◽  
Anna Katarzyna Bażyńska ◽  
Zofia Bronowska ◽  
Paweł Potocki ◽  
Anna Krempa-Kowalewska ◽  
...  

Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document