Pattern of recurrence after partial and total nephrectomy in non-metastatic renal cell carcinoma (RCC) of low, intermediate and high risk: Implications for follow-up.
601 Background: Guidelines recommend risk-adapted follow-up (FUP) after (partial) nephrectomy in non-metastatic RCC. VEGF-targeted therapy does not cure multiple metastatic RCC. FUP should therefore focus on local recurrences or single-/-oligometastases that may potentially be cured by local therapy. The rate of potentially curable recurrences per risk group is unknown and their pattern and management were analyzed in this study. Methods: From an IRB approved database non-metastatic RCC patients who underwent (partial) nephrectomy from 2004 to 2011 with a minimum FUP of ≥4 years and regular cross-sectional imaging were identified. Risk stratification was assigned to Leibovich- (clear-cell ) or UICC-stage- (non-clear cell) risk groups . Local recurrence, solitary and oligometastases defined as < 3 lesions at a single site were considered potentially curable by local therapy modalities. Recurrences were recorded as was the time to detection of recurrence (TDR) and their management. Results: From 230 patients identified, 191 (clear-cell) and 39 (non-clear cell) were assigned to the Leibovich- or UICC-risk groups respectively. Together, 69 developed recurrences (30 %), of whom 29 (42 %) were potentially curable. Of low-risk patients (32.6 %), only 9 (12 %) had recurrences of which 5 (55.6 %) were potentially curable. In high-risk (19.1 %), of 26 (59.1%) recurrences, the majority were multiple and rapid at a median TDR of 8.4 months (IQR 13.7) with only 6 (23.1 %) potentially curable at a median TDR of 17.6 (IQR 53.8) months. Of 24 recurrences (33.8 %) in intermediate risk, 12 (50 %) potentially curable lesions were detected after a median TDR of 26 (IQR 36.2) months. Together, of 29 potentially curable lesions 15 (51.7 %) were not treated because of comorbidity, poor performance or prognosis and irresectability. Conclusions: High-risk patients predominantly develop multiple metastases early during FUP. A benefit of FUP might derive from identifying potentially curable lesions which develop with latency especially in intermediate and high risk. With only 48 % of potentially curable lesions treated locally the impact of FUP on OS remains controversial.