EXTRACTION OF POTASSIUM AND SODIUM FROM ACID AND CALCAREOUS SOILS WITH THE KELOWNA MULTIPLE ELEMENT EXTRACTANT
The objective of this study was to evaluate the Kelowna multiple element extractant and some EDTA and DTPA modifications for simultaneous determination of potassium and sodium in acid and calcareous soils. To that end, the relationships between K and Na concentrations extracted with 1 N NH4OAc and the Kelowna multiple element extractant (0.25 N HOAc + 0.015 N NH4F) were assessed. However, relationships between K and Na concentrations removed by the modified Kelowna multiple element extractants containing either EDTA or DTPA (KEDTA & KDTPA with NH4F; and AAEDTA & AADTPA without NH4F) were evaluated by comparing values against those obtained with the Kelowna extractant. Addition of these complexing agents was of interest because of their potential in enabling simultaneous extraction of available Zn. The procedures were evaluated by contrasting K and Na concentrations extracted from 100 Canadian soils — half which had pH values between 4.1 and 6.9 (H2O) and a second group with values between 7 and 9.6 — by means of graphing, regression and correlation techniques. Potassium and sodium concentrations removed by the Kelowna extractant ranged from 25 to 510 μg and from 10 to 1420 μg mL−1 soil, respectively. The Kelowna and its EDTA and DTPA modifications extracted K and Na as effectively from acid as calcareous soils. This conclusion was supported by the similar regression slopes obtained when relating concentrations of K and Na removed from these soil groups by the multiple element extractants against those removed by 1 N NH4OAc (r-values ≥ 0.97**). However, the new multiple element extractants removed an average of about 20% less K than 1 N NH4OAc from these soils, though similar Na levels. The lower K levels removed from the Kelowna extractant, or by one of its modifications, may require that soil test interpretation norms be adjusted to compensate for the lower values when using one of these to determine K-availability. A significant correlation was found between extracted Na levels and 1:2 vol/vol water-extract conductivities (r ≥ 0.83**) suggesting that "higher" Na levels may be soluble instead of exchangeable. Some Na test interpretations are discussed in the text. Key words: EDTA, DTPA