Psychiatric conditions, such as Autism Spectrum Condition (ASC) are marked by large heterogeneity, which complicates providing tailored support and prognosis. In this study, we aim to identify homogeneous subgroups in autistic adults using community detection. We included 14 variables related to aging with ASC (i.e., demographic, psychological and lifestyle), measured by questionnaires. Community detection analysis was used for subgroup identification in 133 autistic adults and 62 non-autistic comparisons (age 31-89 years). We replicated our findings in a separate sample (Nautistic = 277; Ncomparisons=384; age 30-92 years). For more insight into heterogeneity within ASC, we performed separate community detection analyses in the ASC subsamples. To test the external validity of the ASC subgroups, we compared them on cognitive failures, quality of life, and psychological difficulties. To test specificity, we repeated the community detection analysis after adding 62 adults with ADHD. The ASC and COMP groups formed distinct subgroups. Within the ASC group, we identified three subgroups, of which two were replicated. We identified a “High social, High Grip” subgroup and a “Low social, low grip” subgroup. The “Low social, low grip” reported the most cognitive failures, lowest quality of life, and most psychological difficulties. Addition of an ADHD group did not alter the subgrouping results. Autistic adults are distinct from comparisons on the considered variables. Within autistic adults, one subgroup seems to have less grip on life and could in the long-term benefit from more support, although this must be confirmed in longitudinal and intervention studies.