SAF-A mutants disrupt chromatin structure through dominant negative effects on RNAs associated with chromatin

Here we provide a brief review of relevant background before presenting results of our investigation into the interplay between scaffold attachment factor A (SAF-A), chromatin-associated RNAs, and DNA condensation. SAF-A, also termed heterogenous nuclear protein U (hnRNP U), is a ubiquitous nuclear scaffold protein that was implicated in XIST RNA localization to the inactive X-chromosome (Xi) but also reported to maintain open DNA packaging in euchromatin. Here we use several means to perturb SAF-A and examine potential impacts on the broad association of RNAs on euchromatin, and on chromatin compaction. SAF-A has an N-terminal DNA binding domain and C-terminal RNA binding domain, and a prominent model has been that the protein provides a single-molecule bridge between XIST RNA and chromatin. Here analysis of the impact of SAF-A on broad RNA-chromatin interactions indicate greater biological complexity. We focus on SAF-A’s role with repeat-rich C0T-1 hnRNA (repeat-rich heterogeneous nuclear RNA), shown recently to comprise mostly intronic sequences of pre-mRNAs and diverse long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs). Our results show that SAF-A mutants cause dramatic changes to cytological chromatin condensation through dominant negative effects on C0T-1 RNA’s association with euchromatin, and likely other nuclear scaffold factors. In contrast, depletion of SAF-A by RNA interference (RNAi) had no discernible impact on C0T-1 RNA, nor did it cause similarly marked chromatin changes as did three different SAF-A mutations. Overall results support the concept that repeat-rich, chromatin-associated RNAs interact with multiple RNA binding proteins (RBPs) in a complex dynamic meshwork that is integral to larger-scale chromatin architecture and collectively influences cytological-scale DNA condensation.

Xist spatially amplifies SHARP recruitment to balance chromosome-wide silencing and specificity to the X chromosome

Although thousands of lncRNAs are encoded in mammalian genomes, their mechanisms of action are largely uncharacterized because they are often expressed at significantly lower levels than their proposed targets. One such lncRNA is Xist, which mediates chromosome-wide gene silencing on one of the two X chromosomes to achieve gene expression balance between males and females. How a limited number of Xist molecules can mediate robust silencing of a significantly larger number of target genes (~1 Xist RNA: 10 gene targets) while maintaining specificity to genes on the X within each cell is unknown. Here, we show that Xist drives non-stoichiometric recruitment of the essential silencing protein SHARP (also called Spen) to amplify its abundance across the inactive X, including at regions not directly occupied by Xist. This amplification is achieved through concentration dependent homotypic assemblies of SHARP on the X and is required for chromosome-wide silencing. We find that expressing Xist at higher levels leads to increased localization at autosomal regions, demonstrating that low levels of Xist are critical for ensuring its specificity to the X chromosome. We show that Xist (through SHARP) acts to suppress production of its own RNA which may act to constrain overall RNA levels and restrict its ability to spread beyond the X. Together, our results demonstrate a spatial amplification mechanism that allows Xist to achieve two essential but countervailing regulatory objectives: chromosome-wide gene silencing and specificity to the X. Our results suggest that this spatial amplification mechanism may be a more general mechanism by which other low abundance lncRNAs can balance specificity to, and robust control of, their regulatory targets.

Ectopic Splicing Disturbs the Function of Xist RNA to Establish the Stable Heterochromatin State

Non-coding Xist RNA plays an essential role in X chromosome inactivation (XCI) in female mammals. It coats the X chromosome in cis and mediates the recruitment of many proteins involved in gene silencing and heterochromatinization. The molecular basis of how Xist RNA initiates chromosomal silencing and what proteins participate in this process has been extensively studied and elucidated. Its involvement in the establishment and maintenance of the X-inactivated state is, however, less understood. The XistIVS allele we previously reported is peculiar in that it can initiate XCI but fails to establish the inactive state that is stably maintained and, therefore, may provide an opportunity to explore how Xist RNA contributes to establish a robust heterochromatin state. Here we demonstrate that ectopic splicing taking place to produce XistIVS RNA disturbs its function to properly establish stable XCI state. This finding warrants the potential of XistIVS RNA to provide further insight into our understanding of how Xist RNA contributes to establish sustainable heterochromatin.

A dose-sensitive OGT-TET3 complex is necessary for normal Xist RNA distribution and function

Female (XX) mouse embryonic stem cells (mESCs) differ from their male (XY) counterparts because they have lower levels of 5-methylcytosine (5mC) and 5-hydroxymethylcytosine (5hmC). This difference in DNA modifications is a result of having two X chromosomes (Xs), both of which are active at this developmental stage. We identified an X-linked gene, Ogt, that controls levels of 5mC and 5hmC in mESCs. OGT is a post-translational modification enzyme and we identified the 5-methylcytosine dioxygenase TET3 as an OGT target that is differentially modified in XX and XY mESCs. In addition to influencing 5mC and 5hmC abundance, OGT dose also controls TET3 and OGT distribution. OGT and TET3 are predominantly nuclear in XX mESCs and cytoplasmic in XY mESCs. Furthermore, these proteins are present in different complexes in XX and XY mESCs. Mutational analysis revealed that TET3 determines the XX-specific abundance of 5mC and 5hmC in mESCs. While TET3 null XX mESCs exhibited modest changes in gene expression, there were substantial alterations upon differentiation into epiblast-like cells (mEpiLCs). In addition, these TET3 null XX mESCs did not undergo X-chromosome inactivation (XCI) when differentiated. These data suggest that an X-dose sensitive complex containing OGT and TET3 regulates cytosine modifications and XCI.

Time-resolved structured illumination microscopy reveals key principles of Xist RNA spreading

X-inactive specific transcript (Xist) RNA directs the process of X chromosome inactivation in mammals by spreading in cis along the chromosome from which it is transcribed and recruiting chromatin modifiers to silence gene transcription. To elucidate mechanisms of Xist RNA cis-confinement, we established a sequential dual-color labeling, super-resolution imaging approach to trace individual Xist RNA molecules over time, which enabled us to define fundamental parameters of spreading. We demonstrate a feedback mechanism linking Xist RNA synthesis and degradation and an unexpected physical coupling between preceding and newly synthesized Xist RNA molecules. Additionally, we find that the protein SPEN, a key factor for Xist-mediated gene silencing, has a distinct function in Xist RNA localization, stability, and coupling behaviors. Our results provide insights toward understanding the distinct dynamic properties of Xist RNA.

The dynamic epigenetic regulation of the inactive X chromosome in healthy human B cells is dysregulated in lupus patients

Systemic lupus erythematous (SLE) is a female-predominant disease characterized by autoimmune B cells and pathogenic autoantibody production. Individuals with two or more X chromosomes are at increased risk for SLE, suggesting that X-linked genes contribute to the observed sex bias of this disease. To normalize X-linked gene expression between sexes, one X in female cells is randomly selected for transcriptional silencing through X-chromosome inactivation (XCI), resulting in allele-specific enrichment of epigenetic modifications, including histone methylation and the long noncoding RNA XIST/Xist on the inactive X (Xi). As we have previously shown that epigenetic regulation of the Xi in female lymphocytes from mice is unexpectedly dynamic, we used RNA fluorescence in situ hybridization and immunofluorescence to profile epigenetic features of the Xi at the single-cell level in human B cell subsets from pediatric and adult SLE patients and healthy controls. Our data reveal that abnormal XCI maintenance in B cells is a feature of SLE. Using single-cell and bulk-cell RNA sequencing datasets, we found that X-linked immunity genes escape XCI in specific healthy human B cell subsets and that human SLE B cells exhibit aberrant expression of X-linked genes and XIST RNA interactome genes. Our data reveal that mislocalized XIST RNA, coupled with a dramatic reduction in heterochromatic modifications at the Xi in SLE, predispose for aberrant X-linked gene expression from the Xi, thus defining a genetic and epigenetic pathway that affects X-linked gene expression in human SLE B cells and likely contributes to the female bias in SLE.

4D chromosome reconstruction elucidates the spatial reorganization of the mammalian X-chromosome

Chromosomes are segmented into domains and compartments; yet, how these structures are spatially related in 3D is unclear. Here, by directly integrating Hi-C capture experiments and 3D modeling, we use X-inactivation as a model to examine the time evolution of 3D chromosome architecture during substantial changes in gene expression. First, we show that gene expression A/B compartments are consistent with phase separation in 3D space. Second, we show that residuals of smaller scale structures persist through transitions, despite further large-scale reorganization into the final inactive configuration, comprising two “megadomains”. Interestingly, these previously hidden residual structures were not detectable in 2D Hi-C maps or principal component analyses. Third, time-dependent reaction-diffusion simulations reveal how Xist RNA particles diffuse across the 3D X-superstructure as it reorganizes. Our 4DHiC pipeline helps satisfy the growing demand for methodologies that produce 3D chromosome reconstructions directly from 2D datasets, which are consistent with the empirical data.

Effects of forced cohesin eviction and retention on X-inactivation and autosomes

SUMMARYDepletion of architectural factors globally alters chromatin structure, but only modestly affects gene expression. We revisit the structure-function relationship using the inactive X chromosome (Xi) as a model. We investigate cohesin imbalances by forcing its depletion or retention using degron-tagged RAD21 (cohesin subunit) or WAPL (cohesin release factor). Interestingly, cohesin loss disrupts Xi superstructure, unveiling superloops between escapee genes, with minimal effect on gene repression. By contrast, forced cohesin retention markedly affects Xi superstructure and compromises spreading of Xist RNA-Polycomb complexes, attenuating Xi silencing. Effects are greatest at distal chromosomal ends, where looping contacts with the Xist locus are weakened. Surprisingly, cohesin loss created an “Xi superloop” and cohesin retention created “Xi megadomains” on the active X. Across the genome, a proper cohesin balance protects against aberrant inter-chromosomal interactions and tempers Polycomb-mediated repression. We conclude that a balance of cohesin eviction and retention regulates X-inactivation and inter-chromosomal interactions across the genome.