Platelet Suppression Therapy in Arterial Disease: Present Status
Arterial disease is a severe test of clinical trials methodology. Results to date have defined areas for further study, but clinical indications are not established. Dipyridamole reduces emboli from prosthetic heart valves but applicability to less thrombogenic valves is uncertain. Transient cerebral ischemic attacks are physiologically appropriate and there is preliminary evidence of reduced attacks with Sulfinpyrazone, none with Dipyridamole, and favorable case reports with Aspirin. Effects on stroke and death in patients presenting with TIA or stroke are under study. Sulfinpyrazone has failed to prolong patency time after peripheral vascular surgery. Administration of aspirin and of Sulfinpyrazone to elderly populations has shown no detectable benefit from Aspirin, and has suggested that Sulfinpyrazone should be further studied in patients recovered from thrombotic stroke. The greatest potential benefit may be secondary prevention of myocardial infarct, but to date efficacy has neither been demonstrated nor excluded. Studies in progress include: ASA and/or Sulfinpyrazone and TIA, stroke and death in patients with TIA; ASA with and without Dipyridamole in patients with TIA: Sulfinpyrazone and survival after recovery from thrombotic stroke; Secondary prevention of myocardial infarct with ASA, ASA or ASA + Dipyridamole, Sulfinpyrazone, and Clofibrate; Sulfinpyrazone, ASA, and ASA with anticoagulants and emboli from prosthetic valves. Platelet survival studies may permit selection of populations likely to benefit and assessment of adequacy of therapy.Hypotheses tested by clinical trial must be distinguished from hypotheses formulated from retrospective analysis, and methods must permit effects of treatment to be distinguished from differences in risk.