What Picture Would They Use?
This chapter studies the impact of digital culture on a long-standing crime news staple, the mug shot. First, it historicizes the way mug shots have traditionally served the interests of news organizations and the criminal justice system. Then, based on two highly publicized cases, the chapter situates mug shots in a model of decontextualization and recontextualization that accounts for traditional and social media. Former Texas governor Rick Perry’s mug shot was recontextualized by traditional journalists and social media users, and grounded research suggests that he was able to exert embodied gatekeeping to control the narrative about his case. Former Stanford University swimmer Brock Turner was subjected to the anger of many Twitter users, who used his digital mug shot to create counternarratives to criminalize him visually. The two cases illustrate the affordance of images to narrative, the role of power in message construction, and the impact of digitization on a model for recontextualization.