Provider Conflicts of Interest in US Healthcare
This chapter focuses on provider conflicts of interest (COIs) in US healthcare. Physicians practice within a turbulent US healthcare system featuring expanding complexity and commercialization. Potential COIs abound, including financial arrangements with drug companies and third-party payers that threaten to undermine clinical judgment and steadfast devotion to the patient. The chapter explores how the obligation to avoid or manage COIs is not always clear and uniform under US law; instead, it arises from a confusing patchwork of overlapping legal sources, including common law doctrines and regulatory provisions that are often limited in application or impose difficult procedural and proof burdens. The typical legal response to COIs has been required disclosure, but disclosure proves a necessary yet insufficient response with potentially unintended results. The chapter then explains why regulation of provider COIs remains particularly challenging for US health law, including limited empirical evidence about the effect of COIs on healthcare, difficulties in developing proportionate responses, and uncertainty in how to address secondary interests that advance important societal goals beyond the immediate patient's welfare.