Comparison of Methods Used to Estimate Age and Length of Fishes at Sexual Maturity Using Populations of White Sucker (Catostomus commersoni)
We compared six methods of estimating age and length at sexual maturity of iteroparous fishes: probit analysis, maximum likelihood methodology, linear regression on arcsine - square root transformed data, Lysack's formula, visual observation of distributions for the first occurrence of [Formula: see text] maturity, and computation of lt of the von Bertalanffy equation using age at maturity for t. To aid comparisons, we subdivided 32 white sucker (Catostomus commersoni) maturity distributions into four types: abrupt transition to maturity (type I), successive increases in proportion mature with increase in age or length (type II), nonsuccessive increases in proportion mature with increase in age or length (type III), and absence of 100% maturity at any age (type IV). Type I distributions were best represented by reporting the first occurrence of [Formula: see text] maturity, types II and III by probit analysis and the maximum likelihood method, and type IV distributions were not adequately represented by any method. Lysack's formula tended to produce high estimates for types II and III and negative values for some type IV distributions. Both the number and position of missing year classes influenced estimates of age at maturity. We recommend documenting maturity distributions with all estimates of age and size at maturity.