Comparison of an intramolecular Michael-type addition with its intermolecular counterpart: an abinitio theoretical study
Abinitio theoretical calculations were carried out on the intramolecular addition of 3-ketopent-4-en-1-olate 1 to form 1-oxacyclohex-3-en-4-olate 2 (reaction I; Scheme 1) and the corresponding intermolecular Michael addition of methanolate to butenone forming 4-methoxybut-2-en-2-olate 4 (reaction II; Scheme 1). The calculations were carried out at the RHF level using an augmented 4-31G basis set; single point energies were then taken using the 6-31 + G* basis set. The overall energy change of the reaction in going from reactants to products is very similar for both reactions, with products being about 8.3 kcal/mol more stable than reactants; the major difference energetically between the two reactions is at the level of the transition state: the transition state energy for reaction I (intramolecular) is 6 kcal/mol higher than that for reaction II (intermolecular). The transition state geometry of reaction II conforms quite closely to the stereoelectronic requirements for a Michael addition, but that of reaction I is very distorted, reflecting significant compromises in the stereoelectronic requirements. Keywords: abinitio theoretical study, Michael-type addition, intramolecular, transition state.