Comparative carbon dioxide exchange for two Populus clones grown in growth room, greenhouse, and field environments

Light-saturated net photosynthetic rates per unit leaf area were 1.6–2.1 times greater for the photosynthetically mature leaves of plants of two hybrid Populus clones (NC-5260, 'Tristis No.1' (Populustristis Fisch. × P. balsamifera L.); NC-5326, 'eugenei' (P. deltoides Bartr. ex Marsh. × P. nigra L.)) grown in pots in the field than in comparable plants from a controlled environment growth room and a winter greenhouse. Stomatal resistances to CO2 in the field trees were only 0.4–0.6 of those in growth room and greenhouse trees. Mesophyll (residual) resistances to CO2 in field trees were 0.4–0.8 of those in growth room and greenhouse trees. Field plants had specific leaf weights 1.5–1.8 times higher than growth room and greenhouse plants, likely primarily owing to the greater average photosynthetic photon flux density in the field (835, 225, and 142 μE m−2 s−1 for field, growth room, and greenhouse conditions, respectively). When net photosynthetic rates (Ps) were corrected for the differences in specific leaf weights to derive net photosynthetic rate per unit leaf dry weight, the values were similar for plants from the three environments (Ps in field trees was 0.9–1.2 times Ps in growth room and greenhouse trees); gross photosynthetic rates per unit leaf weight were even more similar. Internal leaf CO2 concentrations, and photorespiration and dark respiration rates per unit leaf area were not related to growth environment. However, photorespiration rate as a percentage of net photosynthetic rate was lower in the field trees (12–16% in field trees, 19–24% in growth room trees, and 23–39% in greenhouse trees). Net photosynthetic rate was shown to be under strong genetic control in these clones. The effects of growth environment on variables of carbon exchange are sensitive to the basis of expression of those variables.