A Comparison of BTA stat and NMP 22 as Non-Invasive Screening Methods for Bladder Cancer. A Systematic Review.
Abstract BackgroundThe purpose of this study was to systematically review the effects of bladder tumor antigen (BTA) stat and nuclear matrix protein (NMP) 22 as a screening method in an asymptomatic population. Methods We evaluated 381 international studies by selecting randomized controlled trials (RCTs). We descriptively evaluated and summarized all of the 381 studies to identify their strengths and weaknesses in terms of the use of BTA stat and NMP 22. ResultsWe did not identify any RCTs that used BTA stat or NMP 22 as a pure screening tools. We also did not identify any studies that used an asymptomatic population. Different cut-off values and individualized methods were discussed for NMP 22 based on age, sex, risk factors, and history of bladder cancer, introducing significant heterogeneity and bias. Interestingly, the use of NMP 22 demonstrated only in men younger than 65 years positive results. ConclusionsRCTs are needed to show a reliable sensitivity and specificity of using BTA stat or NMP 22 as a screening test. It may be worth investigating in future studies whether it would be useful to offer NMP 22 to only a certain profile of patients. Based on our findings and in consent with national and international guidelines, a screening recommendation using NMP 22 and/or BTA stat can not be given for bladder cancer in an asymptomatic population.