Fitbit data show poor correlation with measures of activity and sleep among hospitalized general medicine patients
Abstract BackgroundWearable devices such as Fitbits may provide important insights about hospitalized patients that include data on low activity and poor sleep. Monitoring this information could spur interventions to improve mobility and sleep which may reduce the adverse effects associated with hospitalization. However, there is a lack of studies assessing the accuracy of wearables in hospitalized medical patients. The purpose of our study was to determine the accuracy of Fitbit heart rate, sleep and physical activity in hospitalized medical patients.MethodsWe conducted a prospective cohort feasibility study enrolling 50 medical inpatients at two hospitals providing them with a Fitbit Charge. Our main measures were Fitbit heart rate, sleep and activity data as well as nurse recorded heart rates, patient reported sleep, and nurse assessments of activity.ResultsOf the 50 patients who consented to the study, 47 patients wore the devices. Comparing pairs of heart rate data from Fitbit and nurse recorded vital signs for the same minute, there were 261 pairs available for comparison. The mean difference was 0.45 bpm (SD: 13.0, Pearson correlation: 0.68 P<0.001) and the 95% limits of agreement were -25 to 26 bpm. The association between the patient-reported sleep score and Fitbit total sleep duration was 0.19 (P=0.24) and between the self-reported hours of sleep and Fitbit total sleep duration was 0.21 (P=0.21). The correlation between nurse-recorded activity and Fitbit daily steps was 0.06 (P=0.52). ConclusionsFitbit heart rates correlated well with nurse-recorded heart rate but did not correlate well with nurse assessments of activity nor with patient self-assessment of sleep. This study highlights limitations of the accuracy of current wearable wrist-worn device algorithms in activity and sleep detection in patients in hospital. The findings call into question the validity of Fitbits for assessment of patient activity and sleep in the hospital setting and suggest that they should not be routinely used without further validation.Trial RegistrationClinicalTrials.gov NCT03646435