When does selection favor learning from the old? Social Learning in age-structured populations
Culture and demography jointly facilitate flexible human adaptation, yet it still remains unclear how social learning operates in populations with age structure. Specifically, how do demographic processes affect the adaptive value of culture, cultural adaptation and population growth and when does selection favor copying the behavior of older vs. younger individuals? Here, we develop and analyze a mathematical model of the evolution of social learning in a population with different age classes. We find that adding age structure alone does not resolve Rogers' paradox, i.e. the finding that social learning can evolve without increasing population fitness. Cultural transmission in combination with demographic filtering, however, can lead to much higher adaptation levels. This is because by increasing proportions of adaptive behavior in older age classes, demographic filtering constitutes an additional adaptive force that social learners can benefit from. Moreover, older age classes tend to have higher proportions of adaptive behavior when the environment is relatively stable and adaptive behavior is hard to acquire but confers large survival advantages. Through individual-based simulations comparing temporal and spatial variability in the environment, we find a ``copy older over younger models''-strategy only evolves readily when social learning is erroneous. The opposite ``copy the younger''-strategy is adaptive when the environment fluctuates frequently but still maintains large proportions of social learners. Our results demonstrate that age structure can substantially alter cultural dynamics and should be addressed in further theoretical and empirical work.