scholarly journals An Examination of the Dependency between Maximum Equilibrium Local Scour Depth and the Grain Size/Structure Size Ratio

Water ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 12 (11) ◽  
pp. 3117
Author(s):  
Raphael Crowley ◽  
William Cottrell ◽  
Alexander Singleton

This paper begins by demonstrating how the Florida Department of Transportation (FDOT) local scour equations take the ratio between grain size and structure size into account when computing equilibrium local scour depth and contrasts this with the well-known Colorado State University (CSU) equation that does not take sediment information into account. Then, a relatively recent empirical formulation from the J-L. Briaud research group for computing local equilibrium scour depth is presented that appears to take the structure size/grain size ratio into account indirectly. Next, a possible explanation for the dependency between local equilibrium scour depth and the structure/grain size ratio is presented that was originally developed by D. Max Sheppard in 2004. This explanation shows that superimposing the pressure gradient around a particle with the pressure gradient around a pile leads to the dependency between equilibrium scour depth and the grain size/structure size ratio. Finally, a new formulation for local equilibrium scour depth based upon turbulent energy spectrum decay is presented. This new formulation reduces the local scour problem to a problem whereby turbulent diffusivity must be better understood. However, this new formulation also appears to show a dependency between equilibrium scour depth and the grain size/structure size ratio. Overall, the analysis presented herein provides several reasons, explanations, and pieces of evidence to suggest that the grain/structure size ratio is an important parameter to consider when computing local equilibrium scour depth.

2018 ◽  
Vol 40 ◽  
pp. 03038 ◽  
Author(s):  
Costantino Manes ◽  
Francesco Coscarella ◽  
Ashley Rogers ◽  
Roberto Gaudio

Local scour represents the erosion process that occurs at the base of hydraulic structures overlying sediment beds. Horseshoe vortices forming at the bed-structure junction are the main responsible for sediment removal and dictate erosion rates as well as the maximum erosion depth resulting from a significant flow event. In steady-flow conditions this is often referred to as the equilibrium scour depth, which, for many hydraulic structures, represents a key parameter for foundation-design and risk-assessment purposes. The equilibrium scour depth has been investigated for decades and many predictive formulae have been developed following the classical empirical approach, whereby numerous experimental datasets are used to isolate and identify the influence of non-dimensional groups emerging from dimensional analysis. Within this context, the influence of obstacle Reynolds numbers, and consequently of viscous forces, has always been neglected because of the large Re values normally encountered in engineering and laboratory conditions. The present paper demonstrates that this assumption is largely incorrect especially for beds made of sand or finer material. The theoretical analysis presented in Manes and Brocchini ([1]) is herein extended to include viscosity effects and investigate their importance on equilibrium scour depths forming around obstacles resembling bridge piers.


Water ◽  
2019 ◽  
Vol 11 (12) ◽  
pp. 2631 ◽  
Author(s):  
Priscilla Williams ◽  
Ram Balachandar ◽  
Tirupati Bolisetti

An evaluation of scour estimation methods has indicated that the effects of blockage ratio are neglected in both scour modelling and development of new predictive methods. The role of channel blockage on the mechanism and progression of local scour is not well understood, and further analysis is required in order to incorporate this effect into scour estimation. In the present investigation, local scour experiments were carried out under varying blockage ratio. The results were compared with data from literature in order to explore the effects of blockage ratio (D/b, where D is the pier diameter, and b is the channel width) on equilibrium scour depth (dse/D, where dse is the depth of scour at equilibrium). It was determined that D/b had a small influence on both dse/D and the progression of scour depth (ds/D) when relative coarseness D/d50 < 100 (where d50 is the median diameter of sediment), and that the influence appeared to be amplified when D/d50 > 100. The efficacy of scour estimation methods used to predict the progression of local scour was also dependent on D/d50. A method of scour estimation used to predict dse/D was evaluated, and it was similarly found to be particularly effective when D/d50 < 100. In future work, further experiments and analysis in the range of D/d50 > 100 are required in order to establish the role of D/b under prototype conditions and to refine existing scour estimation methods.


Author(s):  
Xiaofan Lou ◽  
Kaibing Zhang ◽  
Zhenhong Chen

Abstract The effect of Reynolds number (Re) on the local scour around a monopile encountering steady current was investigated experimentally in a water flume. The experiment was performed using circular cylinders with different diameters under two different freestream velocities, covering both clear-water and live-bed scours and a Reynolds number range of approximately 9,000–60,000. The time-series of the scour depth was recorded during the whole scour process and the scour pit was scanned after the scour process reached equilibrium. Results are presented in terms of the equilibrium scour depth, the time-scale of the scour process and the three-dimensional scour profile at different Reynolds numbers. For both clear-water and live-bed scours, the time history of the scour process indicate that the time-scale becomes larger as Re increases. It is also found that the normalized equilibrium scour depth, as well as the normalized scour radius, decrease with the increasing Re. An empirical equation of the equilibrium scour depth is derived as a function of Reynolds number based on the experimental results so as to better account for Re effect in the scour design.


Author(s):  
Nicholas S. Tavouktsoglou ◽  
John M. Harris ◽  
Richard R. Simons ◽  
Richard J. S. Whitehouse

Offshore Gravity Base Foundations (GBFs) are often designed with non-uniform cylindrical geometries. Such structures interact with the local hydrodynamics which amplify the adverse dynamic pressure gradient, which is responsible for all flow and scour phenomena including the bed shear stress amplification. In this study a method for predicting the effect non-uniform cylindrical structure geometries have on local scour around offshore structures under the forcing of a unidirectional current is presented. The interaction of the flow field with the sediment around these complex structures is described in terms of non-dimensional parameters that characterize the similitude of water-sediment movement. The paper presents insights in the influence a form of the Euler number has on the equilibrium scour around uniform and non-uniform cylindrical structures. Here the Euler number is defined as the depth averaged pressure gradient (calculated using potential flow theory) divided by the product of the square of mean flow velocity and the fluid density. The insights are confirmed through a series of experiments where the equilibrium scour was monitored for different types of structures and flow conditions. The results of this study show that the Euler number is a more appropriate parameter for describing the scour potential of a structure compared to using the equivalent pile diameter. The experimental data show that an increasing Euler number yields an increase in the non-dimensional equilibrium scour. The results of this study also suggest that an increase in the water depth yields a decrease in the equilibrium scour depth for the conical, cylindrical base structures and truncated cylinders and an increase in the equilibrium scour depth for the uniform cylinders which can also be explained in terms of changes in the Euler number. Finally, the Buckingham π theorem in conjunction with the experimental data was used to derive a simple shape correction factor that could be used to determine the scour depth of a non-uniform cylindrical structure based on the equilibrium scour produced for the same flow conditions by a uniform cylinder.


2021 ◽  
Vol 13 (24) ◽  
pp. 13614
Author(s):  
Junhan Li ◽  
Bin Zhang ◽  
Chao Shen ◽  
Xiaoli Fu ◽  
Weichao Li

Local scour is one of the key factors that cause the collapse of structures. To avoid structure failures and economic losses in water, it is usually essential to predict the equilibrium scour depth of the foundation. In this study, several design models which were presented to predict the equilibrium scour depth either under steady clear water conditions and combined waves and current conditions were recommended. These models from China, the United States and Norway were analyzed and compared through experiments. Moreover, flume tests for monopile foundation embedded in sand under different flow conditions were carried out to observe the process and gauge the maximum depth around the pile. Based on this study, for predicting the equilibrium scour depth around bridge piers, the computational results of three design methods are all conservative, as expected. For the foundation of offshore structures in marine environment, most of the predicted scour depths by design methods are different from field data; in particular, the mean relative error with these design methods proposed may reach up to 966.5%, which may lead to underestimation of the problem, overdesign and consequently high construction cost. To further improve the ability of the scour prediction in a marine environment, data from flume tests and some field data from a previous study were used to derive the major factors of scour. Based on the dimensional analysis method, a new model to estimate the equilibrium scour depth induced by either current or waves is proposed. The mean relative error of the new formula is 49.1%, and it gives more accurate scour depth predictions than the existing methods.


1960 ◽  
Vol 82 (4) ◽  
pp. 855-866
Author(s):  
F. Eberle ◽  
J. S. Makris

The effect of cold deformations as encountered in tube and superheater fabrication and of temperature and time of annealing on the grain-size characteristics of 18Cr8Ni-Ti is demonstrated by laboratory experiments with material from six heats of steel. It is shown that cold-drawn tubing retains a relatively uniform small grain size at annealing temperatures up to about 1900 F to 1950 F and that above this temperature individual grains begin to grow at an accelerated rate, leading to a mixed grain-size structure. Annealing times between 5 and 15 minutes caused only insignificant differences in the over all grain size, but extension of exposure to 30 minutes produced a noticeably larger grain structure. Small cold deformations as may be introduced into the material by tube straightening can, when followed by a final anneal, cause excessive localized grain enlargements. Observations pointed to the possibility that materials with high Ti/C ratios may retain a predominantly small grain size at annealing temperatures as high as 2050 F.


2001 ◽  
Vol 28 (3) ◽  
pp. 440-451 ◽  
Author(s):  
J A Kells ◽  
R Balachandar ◽  
K P Hagel

In this study, the effect of grain size on the dynamics of local scour processes is discussed in the context of the erosion that takes place downstream from a submerged sluice gate. Four gradations of non-cohesive bed material were used to study the scour process for various tailwater depth and flow rate conditions. The sand gradations included three sizes of uniformly graded sand and a fourth size, which was obtained by mixing the three uniform sands in equal proportions by weight. A total of 36 tests was carried out, each for a period of 24 h. An equilibrium scour condition was not attained over this time period for any of the tests, although a sense of similarity in the bed profiles is observed in the region close to the sluice gate. The present results indicate that the depth and the area of scour are highly dependent on the bed grain size, both increasing as the grain size is reduced. As well, it was found that the tests with a mixed (i.e., graded) sand bed resulted in less scour relative to those in which a uniformly graded sand of similar grain size was used. Moreover, the maximum scour depth increases with increases in the discharge and the tailwater depth. Finally, it was found that the location of the point of maximum scour depth, as measured from the upstream end of the erodible sand bed, moved downstream with an increase in either the discharge or tailwater depth and upstream with an increase in the grain size.Key words: grain size, grain size distribution, local scour, scour dynamics, sluice gate, tailwater depth, video image data acquisition.


1981 ◽  
Vol 4 ◽  
Author(s):  
T. J. Stultz ◽  
J. F. Gibbons

ABSTRACTStructural and electrical characterization of laser recrystallized LPCVD silicon films on amorphous substrates using a shaped cw laser beam have been performed. In comparing the results to data obtained using a circular beam, it was found that a significant increase in grain size can be achieved and that the surface morphology of the shaped beam recrystallized material was much smoother. It was also found that whereas circular beam recrystallized material has a random grain structure, shaped beam material is highly oriented with a <100> texture. Finally the electrical characteristics of the recrystallized film were very good when measured in directions parallel to the grain boundaries.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document