Introduction: Physical activity and sport have been found to have a beneficial effect on executive function, while concussion history may have a detrimental effect. Previous research has yet to investigate the combined effects of leisure-time physical activity, sports participation and concussion history utilizing a comprehensive, remote assessment of executive function. In this study, we aimed to examine the effects of physical activity, athletic status and concussion history on subjective (e.g., questionnaire) and objective measures (e.g., latent variables) of executive functioning in young adults. Method: 247 Canadian university students (ages 18–25; 83% female) completed a remote assessment of executive function (nine computerized tasks and behavioural self-report) in addition to answering items assessing physical activity, athletic status, and concussion history. Structural equation modelling and linear regression were used to predict executive function performance. The structural equation model was a three-factor model of executive function with shifting, updating and inhibition. Results: The three-factor structural equation model of executive function fit the data adequately: χ2=66.38, df=51, p=0.07, CFI=0.95, TLI=0.93, RMSEA=0.04 [90% CI:0.00–0.06], SRMR=0.05. No direct relationship was found between the factors of executive function and the predictor variables (i.e., age, physical activity, concussion history, and athletic status). Sex was significantly related to inhibition, b=0.52, p=0.02, such that males had greater inhibition. For the regression, physical activity (b=0.09, p<.01), concussion history (b=3.29, p<.05) and athletic status (b=-4.01, p<.05) were found to be significant predictors for the behavioural self-report measure of executive function (i.e., Executive Function Index). Conclusions: Concussion history, physical activity, and athletic status were all predictive of subjective executive function but not objective executive function. These findings offer support for the differentiation between subjective and objective measures of executive function when investigating their relationship with physical activity, sports participation, concussion history, age and sex.