Comparative assessment of genes driving cancer and somatic evolution

ABSTRACTGenetic alterations of somatic cells can drive non-malignant clone formation and promote cancer initiation. However, the link between these processes remains unclear hampering our understanding of tissue homeostasis and cancer development. Here we collect a literature-based repertoire of 3355 well-known or predicted drivers of cancer and noncancer somatic evolution in 122 cancer types and 12 noncancer tissues. Mapping the alterations of these genes in 7953 pancancer samples reveals that, despite the large size, the known compendium of drivers is still incomplete and biased towards frequently occurring coding mutations. High overlap exists between drivers of cancer and noncancer somatic evolution, although significant differences emerge in their recurrence. We confirm and expand the unique properties of drivers and identify a core of evolutionarily conserved and essential genes whose germline variation is strongly counter-selected. Somatic alteration in even one of these genes is sufficient to drive clonal expansion but not malignant transformation. Our study offers a comprehensive overview of our current understanding of the genetic events initiating clone expansion and cancer revealing significant gaps and biases that still need to be addressed. The compendium of cancer and noncancer somatic drivers, their literature support and properties are accessible at http://www.network-cancer-genes.org/.

Clonal architecture in mesothelioma is prognostic and shapes the tumour microenvironment

Malignant Pleural Mesothelioma (MPM) is typically diagnosed 20–50 years after exposure to asbestos and evolves along an unknown evolutionary trajectory. To elucidate this path, we conducted multi-regional exome sequencing of 90 tumour samples from 22 MPMs acquired at surgery. Here we show that exomic intratumour heterogeneity varies widely across the cohort. Phylogenetic tree topology ranges from linear to highly branched, reflecting a steep gradient of genomic instability. Using transfer learning, we detect repeated evolution, resolving 5 clusters that are prognostic, with temporally ordered clonal drivers. BAP1/−3p21 and FBXW7/-chr4 events are always early clonal. In contrast, NF2/−22q events, leading to Hippo pathway inactivation are predominantly late clonal, positively selected, and when subclonal, exhibit parallel evolution indicating an evolutionary constraint. Very late somatic alteration of NF2/22q occurred in one patient 12 years after surgery. Clonal architecture and evolutionary clusters dictate MPM inflammation and immune evasion. These results reveal potentially drugable evolutionary bottlenecking in MPM, and an impact of clonal architecture on shaping the immune landscape, with potential to dictate the clinical response to immune checkpoint inhibition.

Distinct Somatic Alteration Features Identified by Gene Panel Sequencing in Korean Triple-Negative Breast Cancer with High Ki67 Expression

This study aimed to clarify the genetic difference between Korean triple-negative breast cancer (TNBC) and other breast cancer (BC) subtypes. TNBC was defined as the absence of hormonal receptors and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (HER2) amplification. DNA panel of the Ion Torrent Oncomine Comprehensive Assay (OCA) v3 was performed to identify somatic alteration in 48 specimens. In a total of 102 alterations (37 nonsense, 35 missense, 8 frameshift and 22 amplifications), 30 nucleotide alterations (24 nonsense, 1 missense, and 5 frameshift) were newly identified. The eight most commonly altered genes were PIK3CA, TP53, ERBB2, BRCA2, FANCD2, AKT1, BRCA1, and FANCA. TNBC had significantly lower mutation frequency in PIK3CA (TNBC vs. hormone receptor-positive and HER2-negative BC [HRPBC], p = 0.009), but higher mutation frequency in TP53 (TNBC vs. HRPBC, p = 0.036; TNBC vs. hormone receptor-positive and HER2- positive BC [HHPBC], p = 0.004). TNBC showed frequently higher Ki-67 expression than any positive BC (p = 0.004) due to HRPBC (p < 0.001). TNBC with high Ki-67/unmutated PIK3CA/mutated TP53 appears at a younger age (52.2 ± 7.6 years), compared to other subtypes (63.7 ± 11.0 years). TNBC with high Ki-67/unmutated PIK3CA/mutated TP53 may be related to relatively early onset BCThese findings demonstrate the genomic heterogeneity between TNBC and other BC subtypes and could present a new approach for molecular targeted therapy in TNBC patients.

Genetic alteration of ARMC5 in a patient diagnosed with meningioma and primary macronodular adrenal hyperplasia: a case report

A monoallelic germline alteration of ARMC5 causes primary bilateral macronodular adrenal hyperplasia (PBMAH) with Cushing’s syndrome via its subsequent somatic alteration on the other allele as the second hit. PBMAH is sometimes complicated with meningioma. Dependency of such a multi-organ disease on the second hit mechanism was reported before, but this finding has not been confirmed yet. We describe a case of a 65-year-old female with PBMAH, carrying a heterozygous germline alteration of ARMC5, p.R267*, complicated with meningioma associated with somatic loss of heterozygosity (LOH) of the unaffected allele. Pathogenic alterations of ARMC5 may also contribute to the development of meningioma by the two-hit mechanism.

PTPN11 mutation with additional somatic alteration indicates unfavorable outcome in juvenile myelomonocytic leukemia: a retrospective clinical study from a single center

Juvenile myelomonocytic leukemia (JMML) is a heterogeneous childhood leukemia. The management of patients with JMML requires accurate assessment of genetic and clinical features to help in patient risk stratification. This study aimed to investigate the association between genomic alterations and prognosis in children with JMML. Genomic DNA was extracted from a total of 93 patients with JMML for targeted sequencing. Univariable and multivariable analysis were used to evaluate the correlation between gene mutations and prognosis of the patients. Patients with PTPN11 mutation exhibited significantly lower event-free survival (EFS) compared with non-PTPN11 mutations (P = 0.005). Patients without or with one somatic alteration at diagnosis showed significantly better prognosis in comparison with those with more than two alterations (P = 0.009). PTPN11 mutation with additional alterations showed significantly the poorest outcome in comparison with those with only one non-PTPN11 mutation, only one PTPN11 mutation, and combined mutations without PTPN11, respectively (P < 0.0001).Conclusion: Both PTPN11 mutation and the number of somatic alterations detected at diagnosis are likely to be the major determinant of outcome in JMML. The subgroup of patients with PTPN11 mutation showed the shortest survival which was even worsened when a secondary mutation was present.

Analysis of cell-free circulating tumor DNA in 419 patients with glioblastoma and other primary brain tumors

Aim: Genomically matched trials in primary brain tumors (PBTs) require recent tumor sequencing. We evaluated whether circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) could facilitate genomic interrogation in these patients. Methods: Data from 419 PBT patients tested clinically with a ctDNA NGS panel at a CLIA-certified laboratory were analyzed. Results: A total of 211 patients (50%) had ≥1 somatic alteration detected. Detection was highest in meningioma (59%) and gliobastoma (55%). Single nucleotide variants were detected in 61 genes, with amplifications detected in ERBB2, MET, EGFR and others. Conclusion: Contrary to previous studies with very low yields, we found half of PBT patients had detectable ctDNA with genomically targetable off-label or clinical trial options for almost 50%. For those PBT patients with detectable ctDNA, plasma cfDNA genomic analysis is a clinically viable option for identifying genomically driven therapy options.

Pan-Cancer Analysis Reveals Differential Susceptibility of Bidirectional Gene Promoters to DNA Methylation, Somatic Mutations, and Copy Number Alterations

Bidirectional gene promoters affect the transcription of two genes, leading to the hypothesis that they should exhibit protection against genetic or epigenetic changes in cancer. Therefore, they provide an excellent opportunity to learn about promoter susceptibility to somatic alteration in tumors. We tested this hypothesis using data from genome-scale DNA methylation (14 cancer types), simple somatic mutation (10 cancer types), and copy number variation profiling (14 cancer types). For DNA methylation, the difference in rank differential methylation between tumor and tumor-adjacent normal matched samples based on promoter type was tested by the Wilcoxon rank sum test. Logistic regression was used to compare differences in simple somatic mutations. For copy number alteration, a mixed effects logistic regression model was used. The change in methylation between non-diseased tissues and their tumor counterparts was significantly greater in single compared to bidirectional promoters across all 14 cancer types examined. Similarly, the extent of copy number alteration was greater in single gene compared to bidirectional promoters for all 14 cancer types. Furthermore, among 10 cancer types with available simple somatic mutation data, bidirectional promoters were slightly more susceptible. These results suggest that selective pressures related with specific functional impacts during carcinogenesis drive the susceptibility of promoter regions to somatic alteration.

Pan-Cancer Analysis Reveals Differential Susceptibility of Bidirectional Gene Promoters to DNA Methylation, Somatic Mutations, and Copy Number Alterations

Bidirectional gene promoters affect the transcription of two genes, leading to the hypothesis that they should exhibit protection against genetic or epigenetic changes in cancer. Therefore, they provide an excellent opportunity to learn about promoter susceptibility to somatic alteration in tumors. We tested this hypothesis using data from genome-scale DNA methylation (14 cancer types), simple somatic mutation (10 cancer types), and copy number variation profiling (14 cancer types). For DNA methylation, the difference in rank differential methylation between tumor and tumor-adjacent normal matched samples based on promoter type was tested by Wilcoxon rank sum test. Logistic regression was used to compare differences in simple somatic mutations. For copy number alteration, a mixed effects logistic regression model was used. The change in methylation between non-diseased tissues and their tumor counterparts was significantly greater in single compared to bidirectional promoters across all 14 cancer types examined. Similarly, the extent of copy number alteration was greater in single gene compared to bidirectional promoters for all 14 cancer types. Furthermore, among 10 cancer types with available simple somatic mutation data, bidirectional promoters were slightly more susceptible. These results suggest that selective pressures related with specific functional impacts during carcinogenesis drive the susceptibility of promoter regions to somatic alteration.

Evaluating Tumor Evolution via Genomic Profiling of Individual Tumor Spheroids in a Malignant Ascites from a Patient with Ovarian Cancer Using a Laser-aided Cell Isolation Technique

BackgroundEpithelial ovarian cancer (EOC) is a silent but mostly lethal gynecologic malignancy. Most patients present with malignant ascites and peritoneal seeding at diagnosis. In the present study, we used a laser-aided isolation technique to investigate the clonal relationship between the primary tumor and tumor spheroids found in the malignant ascites of an EOC patient. Somatic alteration profiles of ovarian cancer-related genes were determined for eight spatially separated samples from primary ovarian tumor tissues and ten tumor spheroids from the malignant ascites using next-generation sequencing.ResultsWe observed high levels of intra-tumor heterogeneity (ITH) in copy number alterations (CNAs) and single-nucleotide variants (SNVs) in the primary tumor and the tumor spheroids. As a result, we discovered that tumor cells in the primary tissues and the ascites were genetically different lineages. We categorized the CNAs and SNVs into clonal and subclonal alterations according to their distribution among the samples. Also, we identified focal amplifications and deletions in the analyzed samples. For SNVs, a total of 171 somatic mutations were observed, among which 66 were clonal mutations present in both the primary tumor and the ascites, and 61 and 44 of the SNVs were subclonal mutations present in only the primary tumor or the ascites, respectively.ConclusionsBased on the somatic alteration profiles, we constructed phylogenetic trees and inferred the evolutionary history of tumor cells in the patient. The phylogenetic trees constructed using the CNAs and SNVs showed that two branches of the tumor cells diverged early from an ancestral tumor clone during an early metastasis step in the peritoneal cavity. Our data support the monophyletic spread of tumor spheroids in malignant ascites.