Generation and timing of graded responses to morphogen gradients

ABSTRACT Morphogen gradients are known to subdivide a naive cell field into distinct zones of gene expression. Here, we examine whether morphogens can also induce a graded response within such domains. To this end, we explore the role of the Dorsal protein nuclear gradient along the dorsoventral axis in defining the graded pattern of actomyosin constriction that initiates gastrulation in early Drosophila embryos. Two complementary mechanisms for graded accumulation of mRNAs of crucial zygotic Dorsal target genes were identified. First, activation of target-gene expression expands over time from the ventral-most region of high nuclear Dorsal to lateral regions, where the levels are lower, as a result of a Dorsal-dependent activation probability of transcription sites. Thus, sites that are activated earlier will exhibit more mRNA accumulation. Second, once the sites are activated, the rate of RNA Polymerase II loading is also dependent on Dorsal levels. Morphological restrictions require that translation of the graded mRNA be delayed until completion of embryonic cell formation. Such timing is achieved by large introns, which provide a delay in production of the mature mRNAs. Spatio-temporal regulation of key zygotic genes therefore shapes the pattern of gastrulation.

Asymmetric requirement of Dpp/BMP morphogen dispersal in the Drosophila wing disc

How morphogen gradients control patterning and growth in developing tissues remains largely unknown due to lack of tools manipulating morphogen gradients. Here, we generate two membrane-tethered protein binders that manipulate different aspects of Decapentaplegic (Dpp), a morphogen required for overall patterning and growth of the Drosophila wing. One is “HA trap” based on a single-chain variable fragment (scFv) against the HA tag that traps HA-Dpp to mainly block its dispersal, the other is “Dpp trap” based on a Designed Ankyrin Repeat Protein (DARPin) against Dpp that traps Dpp to block both its dispersal and signaling. Using these tools, we found that, while posterior patterning and growth require Dpp dispersal, anterior patterning and growth largely proceed without Dpp dispersal. We show that dpp transcriptional refinement from an initially uniform to a localized expression and persistent signaling in transient dpp source cells render the anterior compartment robust against the absence of Dpp dispersal. Furthermore, despite a critical requirement of dpp for the overall wing growth, neither Dpp dispersal nor direct signaling is critical for lateral wing growth after wing pouch specification. These results challenge the long-standing dogma that Dpp dispersal is strictly required to control and coordinate overall wing patterning and growth.

Ediacara growing pains: modular addition and development in Dickinsonia costata

Constraining patterns of growth using directly observable and quantifiable characteristics can reveal a wealth of information regarding the biology of the Ediacara biota—the oldest macroscopic, complex community-forming organisms in the fossil record. However, these rely on individuals captured at an instant in time at various growth stages, and so different interpretations can be derived from the same material. Here we leverage newly discovered and well-preserved Dickinsonia costata Sprigg, 1947 from South Australia, combined with hundreds of previously described specimens, to test competing hypotheses for the location of module addition. We find considerable variation in the relationship between the total number of modules and body size that cannot be explained solely by expansion and contraction of individuals. Patterns derived assuming new modules differentiated at the anterior result in numerous examples in which the oldest module(s) must decrease in size with overall growth, potentially falsifying this hypothesis. Observed polarity as well as the consistent posterior location of defects and indentations support module formation at this end in D. costata. Regardless, changes in repeated units with growth share similarities with those regulated by morphogen gradients in metazoans today, suggesting that these genetic pathways were operating in Ediacaran animals.

MorphoGraphX 2.0: Providing context for biological image analysis with positional information

Positional information is a central concept in developmental biology. In developing organs, positional information can be idealized as a local coordinate system that arises from morphogen gradients controlled by organizers at key locations. This offers a plausible mechanism for the integration of the molecular networks operating in individual cells into the spatially-coordinated multicellular responses necessary for the organization of emergent forms. Understanding how positional cues guide morphogenesis requires the quantification of gene expression and growth dynamics in the context of their underlying coordinate systems. Here we present recent advances in the MorphoGraphX software (Barbier de Reuille et al. eLife 2015;4:e05864) that implement a generalized framework to annotate developing organs with local coordinate systems. These coordinate systems introduce an organ-centric spatial context to microscopy data, allowing gene expression and growth to be quantified and compared in the context of the positional information thought to control them.

Improving the understanding of cytoneme-mediated morphogen gradients by in silico modeling

Morphogen gradients are crucial for the development of organisms. The biochemical properties of many morphogens prevent their extracellular free diffusion, indicating the need of an active mechanism for transport. The involvement of filopodial structures (cytonemes) has been proposed for morphogen signaling. Here, we describe an in silico model based on the main general features of cytoneme-meditated gradient formation and its implementation into Cytomorph, an open software tool. We have tested the spatial and temporal adaptability of our model quantifying Hedgehog (Hh) gradient formation in two Drosophila tissues. Cytomorph is able to reproduce the gradient and explain the different scaling between the two epithelia. After experimental validation, we studied the predicted impact of a range of features such as length, size, density, dynamics and contact behavior of cytonemes on Hh morphogen distribution. Our results illustrate Cytomorph as an adaptive tool to test different morphogens gradients and to generate hypotheses that are difficult to study experimentally.

Minimal synthetic enhancers reveal control of the probability of transcriptional engagement and its timing by a morphogen gradient

How enhancers interpret morphogen gradients to generate spatial patterns of gene expression is a central question in developmental biology. Although recent studies have begun to elucidate that enhancers can dictate whether, when, and at what rate a promoter will engage in transcription, the complexity of endogenous enhancers calls for theoretical models with too many free parameters to quantitatively dissect these regulatory strategies. To overcome this limitation, we established a minimal synthetic enhancer system in embryos of the fruit fly Drosophila melanogaster. Here, a gradient of the Dorsal activator is read by a single Dorsal binding site. By quantifying transcriptional activity using live imaging, our experiments revealed that this single Dorsal binding site is capable of regulating whether promoters engage in transcription in a Dorsal concentration-specific manner. By modulating binding-site affinity, we determined that a gene's decision to engage in transcription and its transcriptional onset time can be explained by a simple theoretical model where the promoter has to traverse multiple kinetic barriers before transcription can ensue. The experimental platform developed here pushes the boundaries of live-imaging in studying gene regulation in the early embryo by enabling the quantification of the transcriptional activity driven by a single transcription factor binding site, and making it possible to build more complex enhancers from the ground up in the context of a dialogue between theory and experiment.

Implications of diffusion and time-varying morphogen gradients for the dynamic positioning and precision of bistable gene expression boundaries

The earliest models for how morphogen gradients guide embryonic patterning failed to account for experimental observations of temporal refinement in gene expression domains. Following theoretical and experimental work in this area, dynamic positional information has emerged as a conceptual framework to discuss how cells process spatiotemporal inputs into downstream patterns. Here, we show that diffusion determines the mathematical means by which bistable gene expression boundaries shift over time, and therefore how cells interpret positional information conferred from morphogen concentration. First, we introduce a metric for assessing reproducibility in boundary placement or precision in systems where gene products do not diffuse, but where morphogen concentrations are permitted to change in time. We show that the dynamics of the gradient affect the sensitivity of the final pattern to variation in initial conditions, with slower gradients reducing the sensitivity. Second, we allow gene products to diffuse and consider gene expression boundaries as propagating wavefronts with velocity modulated by local morphogen concentration. We harness this perspective to approximate a PDE model as an ODE that captures the position of the boundary in time, and demonstrate the approach with a preexisting model for Hunchback patterning in fruit fly embryos. We then propose a design that employs antiparallel morphogen gradients to achieve accurate boundary placement that is robust to scaling. Throughout our work we draw attention to tradeoffs among initial conditions, boundary positioning, and the relative timescales of network and gradient evolution. We conclude by suggesting that mathematical theory should serve to clarify not just our quantitative, but also our intuitive understanding of patterning processes.

Generation and timing of graded responses to morphogen gradients

Morphogen gradients are known to subdivide a naïve cell field into distinct zones of gene expression. Here we examine whether morphogens can also induce a graded response within such domains. To this end we explore the role of the Dorsal protein nuclear gradient along the dorso-ventral axis in defining the graded pattern of actomyosin constriction that initiates gastrulation in early Drosophila embryos. Two complementary mechanisms for graded accumulation of mRNAs of critical zygotic target genes were identified. First, activation of target-gene expression expands over time from the ventral-most region of high nuclear Dorsal to lateral regions where the levels are lower, due to a Dorsal-dependent priming probability of transcription sites. Thus, sites that are activated earlier will lead to more mRNA accumulation. Second, once the sites are primed, the rate of Pol II loading is also dependent on Dorsal levels. Morphological restrictions require that translation of the graded mRNA be delayed until completion of embryonic cell formation. Such timing is achieved by large introns, that provide a delay in production of the mature mRNAs.

Improving the understanding of cytoneme-mediated morphogen gradients by in silico modeling

Morphogen gradients are crucial for the development of organisms, but there is still no agreement on the mechanisms involved in their establishment. The biochemical properties of many morphogens prevent their extracellular free diffusion, indicating the need for an active mechanism for transport. The involvement of filopodial structures (cytonemes) has been proposed for morphogen signaling, although a detailed description of the mechanism is pending. Here, we describe the development of an in silico model based on the main general features of cytoneme-meditated gradient formation and its implementation into an open software tool we named Cytomorph. We have tested the spatial and temporal adaptability of our model experimentally quantifying Hedgehog (Hh) gradient formation in Drosophila and found that Cytomorph is able to reproduce the gradient and explain its scaling between different epithelia. After experimental validation, we studied the predicted impact of a range of features such as length, size, density, dynamics and contact behavior of cytonemes on morphogen distribution. Our results illustrate Cytomorph as an adaptive tool to test and generate hypotheses that are difficult to study experimentally.

Synthetic cell-based materials extract positional information from morphogen gradients

Dynamic biomaterials composed of synthetic cellular structures have the potential to adapt and functionally differentiate guided by physical and chemical cues from their environment. Inspired by developing biological systems, which efficiently extract positional information from chemical morphogen gradients in the presence of environmental uncertainties, we here investigate the analogous question: how well can a synthetic cell determine its position within a synthetic multicellular structure? In order to calculate positional information in such systems, we created and analyzed a large number of replicas of synthetic cellular assemblies, which were composed of emulsion droplets connected via lipid bilayer membranes. The droplets contained cell-free two-node feedback gene circuits that responded to gradients of a genetic inducer acting as a morphogen. We found that in our system, simple anterior-posterior differentiation is possible, but positional information is limited by gene expression noise, and is also critically affected by the temporal evolution of the morphogen gradient and the life-time of the cell-free expression system contained in the synthetic cells. Using a 3D printing approach, we demonstrate morphogen-based differentiation also in larger tissue-like assemblies.