Weil rooted her in idealism in the ethics of Classical Reform Judaism although she described her beliefs as personal. A spiritual seeker, she adhered to a prophetic rather than a rabbinic Judaism that emphasized ethics, rationalism, and universalism. Judaism was a live issue, and she was drawn to Ethical Culture Society. At the Oheb Sholom temple in Goldsboro she served for fifty years as Sunday School principal and worshipped there faithfully on the Sabbath. She was also a leader of the North Carolina Association of Jewish Women, founded by her Aunt Sarah. In contrast to Reform ideology, the Weil women were committed Zionists, fostered through their friendship with Henrietta Szold, founder of Hadassah.