The Evolution and Function of Third-Party Moral Judgment

Author(s):  
Will Reader ◽  
Sara Hughes
2020 ◽  
Author(s):  
Aisulu Kulbayeva

Abstract This study illustrates how personal narratives of victimized self serve two Kazakh-speaking village neighbors to accomplish self-presentation during a mealtime interaction. Integrating Goffman’s (1959) theorization of self-presentation with narrative positioning (Bamberg, 1997; Schiffrin, 1996) and Muslim cultural practices (e.g., Al Zidjaly, 2006), this study conceptualizes mealtime conversations as frontstage and examines two victimhood narratives after providing the sequential overview of the twelve narratives occurred in the interaction. The analysis illustrates how linguistic construction of agentive and epistemic selves of the narrators position them as victims (whose personal items are stolen) in relation to other neighbors (who do the act of stealing) in the story world. This juxtaposition of “I” vs. “Others” in the story world allows the neighbor-tellers to present an idealized self (morally superior neighbors) and function as a team by getting lower hand and aligning with one another against a third party (morally wrong neighbors) in the interaction.


1987 ◽  
Vol 10 (3) ◽  
pp. 359-375 ◽  
Author(s):  
Michael W. Pratt ◽  
Gail Golding ◽  
Patricia Kerig

Recent work on aging and moral judgment has investigated the claim that older adults may show a regression in their average stage level of moral judgment, compared with younger groups. A second line of work has suggested that at least some elderly adults may be more reflective in their thinking regarding moral and ethical issues (e.g. Kohlberg, 1973). The present research was designed to investigate these issues with respect to hypothetical and real-life moral judgment. Subjects were 60 adults in three age groups: 18-24 years, 30-45 years, and 60-75 years. Each responded to the Kohlberg Moral Judgment Interview and to the personal moral dilemma task of Gilligan. Measures of stage level and of reported use of perspectivetaking processes, as well as analyses of the content of personal dilemmas, were obtained. Results showed no average stage level differences between the age or sex groups. Hypothetical stage scores were significantly higher than real-life scores overall. There were no age differences in reported role-taking processes on hypothetical dilemmas, though there were sex differences, with men more likely to report adopting a third-party, observer role. Finally, older subjects produced significantly more varied reflections on their personal dilemmas.


Blood ◽  
2016 ◽  
Vol 128 (22) ◽  
pp. 5724-5724 ◽  
Author(s):  
Fenlu Zhu ◽  
Nirav N. Shah ◽  
Huiqing Xu ◽  
Dina Schneider ◽  
Rimas Orentas ◽  
...  

Abstract Introduction Chimeric Antigen Receptor T (CAR-T) cells redirected against tumor antigens are an effective therapy for B cell malignancies refractory to standard treatments. The production of patient-derived CAR-T cells is complicated and thus far is limited to institutions with experienced researchers and expensive GMP facilities, or to those invited to participate in industry sponsored clinical trials. The outsourcing of CAR T-cell production to third party vendors where cells are collected locally, shipped to the manufacturing site, and then sent back to the institution for infusion can be both costly and timely. As a result, CAR-T cell therapies are not widely available and only patients with means to travel to participating sites and with disease that is stable enough to wait the 2-3 months needed to collect and produce CAR-T cells are eligible for these treatments. At our instution we have explored the use of the CliniMACS® Prodigy (Miltenyi Biotec, Inc) for the production of CAR-T cells. The CliniMACS® Prodigy is an automated device that can be used for cell processing within a closed GMP-compliant system. Using the CAR-T system that includes software, specialized tubing sets, and optimized reagents we demonstrate the processing of CAR-T cells, with similar characteristics to those produced in a more traditional manner, in a closed system that is suitable for clinical use without the need for a clean room manufacturing facility. Methods In collaboration with Miltenyi Biotec, we obtained pre-release and final versions of the CliniMACS® Prodigy TCT process software and the TS520 tubing set that allows for cell enrichment, transduction, wash steps, and expansion all within a single set. Starting material was MNC cells recovered from a leukoreduction system chamber (LRSC) used during platelet collections by apheresis. Materials and reagents included MACS CD4 & CD8 reagents for cell enrichment, TransAct CD3/CD28 reagent for activation, lentiviral CD8 TM-41BB-CD3 zeta-cfrag vectors with either CD19 or CD20/CD19 Ab chains (Lentigen Technology Inc., A Miltenyi Biotec Company), TexMACS culture medium-3% HS-IL2, and PBS/EDTA buffer for wash steps. For two experiments, cells after CD4/CD8 enrichment were activated and transduced in 6 well plates and expanded after day 5 in G-Rex gas permerable devices. Total time for line preparation was 14±1 days. Transduction was measured by Protein L expression using flow cytometry. Line function was measured in 51Cr Release assays and by intracellular cytokine production. Results Starting cells were washed free of platelets and enriched for CD4+ and CD8+ cells using the Prodigy device. We achieved consistent high levels purity (99±3%) and good recovery (51.0±6%) of CD4+ and CD8+ cells (N=5). The enriched cells were 90±12% CD3+. The approximately 10% non-T cells were CD8+ NK cells, that were largely eliminated after cell activation through CD3/CD28 and expansion. A controlled number of 1 x 10E8 cells enriched for CD4+ plus CD8+ cells were retained in the Prodigy and in 2 experiments a smaller fraction of cells was cultured in 6 well plates for activation and initial transduction. Three preparations were conducted in the Prodigy, one using the CD19 vector and two with the CD19+CD20 vector. Transduction efficiency ranged from 21%-46% of total T cells with a modest preference for CD4+ cells. Expansion ranged from 26-40 fold and all of the lines recognized CD19 and/or CD20 targets based on 51Cr release assays or IFN-gamma production. The paired lines generated on the Prodigy versus manual methods showed similar overall transduction, phenotype, and function as shown in the figure for one representative preparation. Conclusions CAR-T cells generated in the Prodigy were similar to those prepared using manual methods in both phenotype and function. This process is timely, requiring 14 days for generation of the target CAR-T cell dose, and does not require outsourcing to third party vendors. All of the Prodigy CAR-T cell preparations met criteria for clinical use in our upcoming Phase I clinical trial. The ability to produce CAR-T cells suitable for clinical use in an entirely closed system without the need for a clean room should allow more centers and patients access to this novel form of immunotherapy. Disclosures Shah: Oncosec: Equity Ownership; Exelixis: Equity Ownership; Geron: Equity Ownership. Orentas:Lentigen Technology, Inc.: Employment. Dropulic:Lentigen Technology Inc. A Miltenyi Biotec Company: Employment. Hari:Merck: Research Funding; BMS: Honoraria.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Chenhao Hu ◽  
Zhen Wu

There is a growing concern for environmental issues and urgent need to understand interaction between human behavior and nature. Rewarding environmental protection and punishing harm can be the behavioral consequence of the moral judgment to environmental actions. Two studies (N = 211) were designed to understand the early development of such moral behaviors. In Study 1 and the follow-up conceptual replication Study 2, we performed 4- to 6-year-old children with both environmental protection and harm. Three tasks measured children’s behavioral responses toward environmental actions: reward the action that they think is good or punish the action that they think is bad even at a cost. Results demonstrated that children differentiate environmental actions and depicted an age-increase preference to environmental protection. Preschoolers, as a third-party bystander, actively punish environmental harm; with age, they become more consistently and steadily willing to be punitive even with a personal sacrifice. Together, young children are pro-environmental; from early in development children show a behavioral capacity to promote environmental good. The research fills the gap between moral judgment and behavior and contributes to applied implications.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Joanna Korman ◽  
Boyoung Kim

Microaggressions are subtle, offensive comments directed at minority group members that are characteristically ambiguous in meaning. In two studies, we explored how observers interpret such ambiguous statements by comparing microaggressions to faux pas, offenses caused by the speaker having an incidental false belief. In Study 1, we compared third-party observers’ blame and intentionality judgments of microaggressions with those for social faux pas. Despite judging both offenses not to be caused intentionally, participants judged microaggressions as more blameworthy. In Study 2 microaggressions without explicit mental state information exhibited a similar profile of judgments as those accompanied by explicit prejudiced or ignorant beliefs. Although they are, like faux pas, judged not to cause harm intentionally, microaggressive comments appear to be judged as more blameworthy on account of enduring prejudice thought to be lurking behind a speaker’s false or incorrect beliefs. Our studies demonstrate a distinctive profile of moral judgment for microaggressions.


Author(s):  
Nihal Abdurahiman ◽  
Ahmad Qadeib alban ◽  
abdullatif shikfa ◽  
Qutaibah Malluhi

Private Function Evaluation (PFE) is the problem of evaluating one party’s private data using a private function owned by another party. Several techniques were presented to tackle PFE by running universal circuits in secure multi-party computation and more recently by hiding the circuit’s topology and the gate’s functionalities. These solutions however, are not efficient enough for practical use; hence there remains a need for more efficient techniques. This work looks at utilizing the Intel Software Guard Extensions platform (SGX) to provide a more practical solution for PFE while the privacy of the data and the function are both kept protected. Our solution carefully avoids the pitfalls of side channel attacks on SGX. We present solutions for two different scenarios: the first is with the function’s owner having SGX enabled and the other is with a third party (other than data owner and function owner) having SGX. Our results show a clear expected advantage in term of time consumption for the first case over the second. Investigating the slowdown in the second case lead to the garbling time, which constitutes more than 60% of the consumed time. Both solutions clearly outperform Fairplay PF in our tests.


2017 ◽  
Author(s):  
Indrajeet Patil ◽  
Liane Young ◽  
Vladimiro Sinay ◽  
Ezequiel Gleichgerrcht

Recent research has demonstrated impairments in social cognition associated with multiple sclerosis (MS). The present work asks whether these impairments are associated with atypical moral judgment. Specifically, we assessed whether MS patients are able to integrate information about intentions and outcomes for moral judgment (i.e., appropriateness and punishment judg- ments) in the case of third-party acts. We found a complex pattern of moral judgments in MS patients: although their moral judgments were comparable to controls’ for specific types of acts (e.g., accidental or intentional harms), they nevertheless judged behaviors to be less appropriate and endorsed more severe punishment across the board, and they were also more likely to report that others’ responses would be congruent with theirs. Further analyses suggested that elevated levels of externally oriented cognition in MS (due to co-occurring alexithymia) explain these effects. Additionally, we found that the distinction between appropriateness and punishment judgments, whereby harmful outcomes influence punishment judgments to a greater extent than appropriateness judgments, was preserved in MS despite the observed disruptions in the affective and motivational components of empathy. The current results inform the two-process model for intent-based moral judgments as well as possible strategies for improving the quality of life in MS patients.


Author(s):  
Xun Xu

Function blocks are an IEC (International Electro-technical Commission) standard for distributed industrial processes and control systems (IEC 61499, 2005). It is based on an explicit event driven model and provides for data flow and finite state automata-based control. Based on previous research, function blocks can be used as the enabler to encapsulate process plans, integrate with a third-party dynamic scheduling system, monitor process plan during execution, and control machining jobs under normal and abnormal conditions. They are also considered to be suitable for machine-level monitoring, shop-floor execution control, and CNC control. Combination of STEP-NC and Function Blocks can be seen as a “natural marriage”. This is because the former provides an informationally complete data model but with no functionality, whereas the latter can embed intelligence and provide functionality in the data model for a more capable CNC regime. This chapter introduces the function block architecture which has been implemented in two types of integrations. The first brings together CAD, CAPP, and CAM. The key is to embed machining information in a function block system that is based on the concept of machining features. The second integration connects CAM with CNC. This is in fact an open CNC architecture that is function block driven, instead of G-code driven.


2019 ◽  
Author(s):  
Alexander Noyes ◽  
Frank Keil

We investigate ordinary concepts of institutional groups: stable, cooperative, and socially constructed entities like clubs, companies, and academic departments. We use a transformation paradigm to examine participants’ causal beliefs about how groups exist and persist over time. We consider whether participants believe groups are grounded in collective recognition or function. Participants' default views about groups see them as persisting because the members or a relevant third-party collectively recognize the members as belonging to a group (Study 1-4). Social groups are dual-character though (Study 5-8). There is a second sense: the true group. This true judgment is grounded in whether the group realizes its basic function. This sense is more influenced by participants' own ideological commitments. Thus, participants can disagree about whether a group truly exists even if they agree about the bare facts. We discuss implications for theories of conceptual representation.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document