scholarly journals A Comparison between Simple Shear and Triaxial Tests for Evaluating the Variations of G and D with Matric Suction

2019 ◽  
Vol 92 ◽  
pp. 07010
Author(s):  
Kazem Fakharian ◽  
Danial Shirkavand ◽  
Manouchehr Hejazi

Shear modulus (G) and damping ratio (D) are both well known as principal soil dynamic parameters. In the present study, cyclic triaxial and simple shear tests are performed on Firuzkuh silica sand at various shear strain amplitudes using the developed testing devices and peripherals. It is well-understood that degrading curvature of G with shear strain appears in both triaxial and simple shear results. Nevertheless, mean confining stress has dissimilar effects in each of the two tests that does not provide comparable empirical correlations. It is noticed that the variations of G and D with suction stress in triaxial differs from those in simple shear. On the basis of cyclic simple shear results, the increase in suction pressure from zero to the end of transition zone in SWCC leads to increase in G values. In triaxial method, on the other hand, similar increase occurs only up to the inflection point in SWCC, starts reducing afterwards down to a limit value at residual water content. The damping ratio variations with shear strain are generally ascending despite local drops at the strain order of 0.1%, which has appeared in both triaxial and simple shear results.

1993 ◽  
Vol 30 (5) ◽  
pp. 747-757 ◽  
Author(s):  
Nario Yasuda ◽  
Norihisa Matsumoto

Cyclic torsional simple shear (CTSS) tests and cyclic triaxial (CTX) tests were carried out to investigate the dynamic deformation characteristics of sands and rockfill materials. It was found that the shear modulus and damping ratio can be expressed as a function of shear strain, void ratio, and confining stress. Also the shear modulus in CTSS tests is larger than in CTX tests because of the influence of the intermediate principal stress. When the shear strain is increased, the shear modulus (G) and damping ratio (h) of the rockfill materials were altered at smaller strains than in sands. Key words : sands, rockfill materials, torsional simple shear, shear modulus, damping ratio.


Buildings ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 11 (5) ◽  
pp. 186
Author(s):  
Ahmed Moussa ◽  
Hany El Naggar ◽  
Abouzar Sadrekarimi

Due to the socio-environmental hazards arising from the stockpiling of disposed scrap tires, the necessity to utilize such material in civil construction and other applications is deemed mandatory. The lightweight of rubber and its high damping capacity are excellent properties of a geomaterial that could be used successfully in seismic isolation and vibration damping applications in civil construction. Scrap tires could be shredded into specific sizes, and their category and application depend on their particle size range. Thus, understanding the dynamic properties and behavior of shredded scrap tires under cyclic loading is of paramount importance. In this study, the dynamic characteristics of granulated rubbers (<12 mm) are investigated using cyclic triaxial and cyclic direct simple shear tests. The effect of using different testing techniques, i.e., cyclic triaxial test (CTT) and cyclic simple shear test (CSST), on the dynamic properties of granulated rubber material is further addressed. Undrained cyclic triaxial and constant-volume direct simple shear tests are conducted on granulated rubber samples under vertical consolidation stresses of 25, 50, 100 and 200 kPa at a frequency of 0.5 Hz. The shear strain amplitude is varied from 0.01% to 10%. Furthermore, the variations of shear modulus and damping ratio with shear strain amplitude are presented. In addition, the obtained dynamic properties from this study are compared with existing experimental data from the literature. It was found that the ranges of shear moduli of granulated rubber from the CTT and CSST are 278 to 2647 kPa and 85 to 2270 kPa, respectively. Moreover, the damping ratios obtained from CTT were higher than those from CSST at shear strains of less than 1%. The damping ratio of granulated rubber was also found to be independent of the vertical consolidation stress.


Author(s):  
Heather J. Miller ◽  
Pedro de Alba ◽  
Kenneth C. Baldwin

A testing system has been developed to study the behavior of saturated sand under low-level cyclic shearing strains. The system has been used to determine threshold shear strain levels for fabric destruction in sand aged for different time periods. The system includes a special soil chamber and a direct simple shear (DSS) machine. To impose very small shearing strains, the DSS machine was designed to apply and measure horizontal deformations as small as 0.0005 mm (2 × 10−5 inches). Data obtained to date support the results of previous investigators who performed triaxial tests on freshly deposited samples, indicating a threshold cyclic shear strain level of approximately 0.01 percent. At strains in excess of those levels, destruction of the sand fabric occurred, as evidenced by a reduction in shear modulus at low strain levels. Subsequent modest increases in shear modulus were observed after the specimens were allowed to recover for 24 hours and then tested again. During the recovery period, drainage valves were left open to allow for dissipation of excess pore pressures and for potential consolidation during the short aging period. The DSS system was found to work well for low strain measurements. Furthermore, since shear strains are measured directly under DSS conditions (as opposed to triaxial conditions), the DSS system shows much promise as a device for studying parameters that may influence threshold shear strain levels and fabric evolution and destruction in sands.


1988 ◽  
Vol 25 (2) ◽  
pp. 401-407
Author(s):  
Guy Lefebvre ◽  
Serge Malenfant

The liquefaction potential of a loose glacial till is assessed by laboratory cyclic tests and by comparison with test results obtained on a clean sand, using the same testing procedures. The laboratory testing program of both soils included cyclic triaxial tests on saturated specimens and constant volume cyclic simple shear tests on dry specimens. The till and the sand exhibited very similar behaviour during cycling and mobilized nearly identical cyclic shear strengths in the triaxial as well as in the simple shear tests. The 28% fines content in the till did not make it more resistant to liquefaction than a clean sand. Key words: liquefaction, sand, silty sand, cyclic simple shear test, cyclic triaxial test.


1991 ◽  
Vol 28 (2) ◽  
pp. 255-262 ◽  
Author(s):  
J. H. Atkinson ◽  
W. H. W. Lau ◽  
J. J. M. Powell

During a simple shear test the axes of stress rotate and, in a conventional apparatus in which the only stresses measured are the normal and shear stresses on horizontal planes, it is not possible to define the stress state completely. As a result, the measured failure stresses may not represent the true strength of the soil. Examination of possible Mohr's circles for soils at failure in simple shear tests demonstrates that the measured strength for a given soil depends on, among other things, the ratio of the horizontal and vertical effective stresses at failure. Results of laboratory tests on Cowden Till and on blue London Clay show the differences between strengths measured in simple shear and triaxial tests. A consequence of the conventional interpretation of the simple shear test is that effective stress failure envelopes have a false cohesion intercept with friction angles smaller than those measured in triaxial tests. Key words: clays, laboratory equipment, shear strength, shear tests, triaxial tests.


Author(s):  
Meysam Bayat

Understanding the factors that influence the dynamic behavior of granular soils during cyclic loading is critical to infrastructure design. Previous research has lacked quantitative study of the effects of fouling index (FI), mean effective confining pressure, relative density, shear strain level and anisotropic consolidation, especially when the effective vertical stress is lower than the effective horizontal stress on the dynamic behavior of gravelly soils. The objective of the present study was to evaluate the dynamic behavior and volume change of both clean and fouled specimens for practical applications. To this end, cyclic triaxial tests with local strain measurements under both isotropic and anisotropic confining conditions were conducted. It is found that the fouled specimen with 50 % sand (i.e. the specimen which contains 50 % gravel and 50 % sand) has the highest shear modulus at low shear strain levels and the largest volume reduction and damping ratio at large shear strain levels. The results of tests indicate that the effect of fouling index on the shear modulus is reduced at large shear strain levels. Volumetric contraction due to the increase in mean effective confining pressure is more significant at large shear strain levels. The results also indicate that the stiffness of the specimens under anisotropic compression mode are larger than those in extension or isotropic mode.


1988 ◽  
Vol 25 (2) ◽  
pp. 395-400 ◽  
Author(s):  
Muniram Budhu

The stress state in many practical geotechnical problems is analogous to simple shear strain. However, the devices available to test soil samples in simple shear strain impose nonuniform stress and strain fields. Consequently, the interpretation of results from simple shear tests is often questioned. In this article, results of tests on loose and dense Leighton Buzzard sand from two specially instrumented simple shear devices–Cambridge University's device and a Norwegian Geotechnical Institute type–are used to interpret the failure mode and the failure stress state. The data were obtained from the centre of the samples, a region removed from stress concentrations. Failure was observed to be initiated on vertical planes and occurred very soon after shear displacement was applied. However, neither these vertical planes nor the horizontal planes were the planes of maximum stress obliquity mobilized during the tests. Key words: deformation, failure, loads, sand, shear tests, simple shear, stresses.


Author(s):  
Nathalie Boukpeti ◽  
Barry Lehane ◽  
J. Antonio H. Carraro

Design of offshore foundation systems requires assessment of the effects of cyclic loading on the soil strength. This paper investigates the applicability of the strain accumulation procedure, which is used to assess the effects of wave loading on the soil strength. Staged undrained cyclic simple shear tests were conducted on a carbonate sediment from the North West shelf of Australia, with varying shear stress amplitude in each stage. The shear strain mobilised at the end of the staged tests is compared with the value predicted by the strain accumulation procedure, using shear strain contours constructed from the results of single amplitude undrained cyclic simple shear tests. It was found that the strain accumulation procedure gives adequate prediction for normalised cyclic shear stress less or equal to 0.3, but largely underestimates the cyclic shear strain for normalised cyclic shear stress greater than 0.3 (the cyclic shear stress being normalised by the effective vertical stress at the end of consolidation).


2019 ◽  
Vol 9 (18) ◽  
pp. 3863
Author(s):  
Pan ◽  
Li ◽  
Lu ◽  
Chen

Soil mixtures with various materials such as scraps of rubber tire, iron powder, and synthetic fibers have been widely used in civil engineering for experimental research or infrastructure construction and maintenance. However, these materials are not only expensive, but may also result in environmental concerns. In recent years, sawdust, because of its light-weight, inexpensive, and environmental friendly characteristics, has frequently been used in the shaking table test to adjust the dynamic properties of experimental soil. However, the dynamic properties of a sand-sawdust mixture for the shaking table test are still unclear. In this paper, the dynamic properties and the hysteresis curve characteristics of the sand-sawdust mixture as well as the influence of the sawdust content and confining pressure on the dynamic properties were studied using a series of consolidated drained dynamic triaxial tests. The test results show that, with the increase of the shear strain, the shape of the hysteresis loops changes from symmetrical willow-leaf to asymmetry sharp-leaf. For a given confining pressure, both the shear modulus and damping ratio decreases as the sawdust percentage increases. It was observed that, with an increase in confining pressure, the shear modulus increased while the damping ratio decreased slightly in the shear strain range of 10−3 to 7×10−3. It was also observed that the maximum shear modulus increased as the confining pressure increased, while the maximum damping ratio remained nearly constant. In addition, both the maximum shear modulus and the maximum damping ratio decreased as the sawdust content increased. Finally, the normalized shear modulus and damping ratio were established, which can be used in simulations using the shaking table test.


2019 ◽  
Vol 92 ◽  
pp. 08007
Author(s):  
Alper Sezer ◽  
Eyyub Karakan ◽  
Nazar Tanrinian

Site response analyses and solution of dynamic soil-structure interaction problems need determination of variation of shear modulus and damping ratio with shear strain. Since many studies in literature concern evaluation of behavior of sands and silty sands, a series of cyclic triaxial tests were performed to determine the variation of shear modulus and damping ratio of a nonplastic silt with shear strain. Stress controlled cyclic triaxial tests on silt specimens of initial relative densities ranging among 30%, 50% and 70% were performed. Tests were carried out on identical samples under different CSR levels, and the confining pressure was selected as 100 kPa. Variation of shear modulus and damping ratio of silts with cyclic stress ratio amplitude, relative density and number of cycles were investigated. It was understood that soil relative density and cyclic stress ratio amplitude has a significant influence on shear modulus and damping ratio of silts. It was also observed that, as the cyclic stress ratio amplitude is increased, greater shear modulus and lower damping ratio values were obtained.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document