Harming Civilians or Prisoners
This chapter uses responses to direct, closed questions about personal involvement to identify 12.8% of veterans as harmers. It examines qualitative information to compare self-identified harmers of civilians or prisoners with other veterans. It investigates the qualitative data to discover the specific circumstances in which this type of harm took place. It suggests that harm to prisoners may usually have occurred following attacks on clearly identifiable enemy forces. In contrast, many incidents of harm to civilians appear to have occurred in attempts by U.S. forces to implement the policy of clearing the population from areas considered to be under enemy control. Other than their much more severe combat exposure, this analysis reveals very few characteristics of the harmers that differentiated them from those not directly involved in inflicting such harm. The harmers themselves tend to suffer from persistent guilt and anger.