Temporal and Spiritual, Pope and Prince, the Right Way Up
These identifications of the community of interest between the ill-intentioned (that is to say, Jesuits and puritans) in turn provided a platform for cases to be made about the right relationship between political and spiritual authority and, in particular, for an interrogation of what was the proper place in western Christendom of the pope and whatever authority it was that he possessed. The appellants’ claims on this score provoked, not unpredictably, Robert Parsons into an equal-and-opposite defence of papal authority. Here, however, appellant writers were also trying to distance themselves from the more strident analyses of this topic which had been associated, for example, with William Allen and which, with the collapse of the French Holy League and the approach, as seemed likely, of some sort of peace in northern Europe, and the very likely accession of James VI in England, were arguably inappropriate. This also raised the issue of how Catholicism might eventually be restored in England again.