Experimental Investigation of the Diffuser Vane Clearance Effect in a Centrifugal Compressor Stage With Adjustable Diffuser Geometry: Part II—Detailed Flow Analysis

2014 ◽  
Vol 137 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Stefan Ubben ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis

Adjustable diffuser vanes offer an attractive design option for centrifugal compressors applied in industrial applications. However, the knowledge about the impact on compressor performance of a diffuser vane clearance between vane and diffuser wall is still not satisfying. This two-part paper summarizes results of experimental investigations performed with an industrial-like centrifugal compressor. Particular attention was directed toward the influence of the diffuser clearance on the operating behavior of the entire stage, the pressure recovery in the diffuser, and on the diffuser flow by a systematic variation of the parameters diffuser clearance height, diffuser vane angle, radial gap between impeller exit and diffuser inlet, and rotor speed. In Part I it was shown that an one-sided diffuser clearance is able to contribute to an increase in flow range, stall margin, pressure ratio, and efficiency. In order to reveal the relevant flow phenomena, in Part II the results of detailed measurements of the pressure distribution at diffuser exit and particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements inside the diffuser channel performed at three clearance configurations and three diffuser angles at a fixed radial gap are discussed. It was found that, for defined diffuser configurations, the clearance flow amplifies the diffuser throat vortex capable to reduce the loading of the highly loaded vane pressure side and to support a more homogenous diffuser flow. It turned out that the co-action of the geometry parameter diffuser vane angle and diffuser clearance height is of particular importance. The experimental results are published as an open computational fluid dynamics (CFD) testcase “Radiver 2.”

2014 ◽  
Vol 137 (3) ◽  
Author(s):  
Stefan Ubben ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis

Adjustable diffuser vanes offer an attractive design option for centrifugal compressors applied in industrial applications. However, the knowledge about the impact on compressor performance of a diffuser vane clearance between vane and diffuser wall is still not satisfying. This two-part paper summarizes results of experimental investigations performed with an industrial-like centrifugal compressor. Particular attention was directed toward the influence of the diffuser clearance on the operating behavior of the entire stage, the pressure recovery in the diffuser, and on the diffuser flow by a systematic variation of the parameters diffuser clearance height, diffuser vane angle, radial gap between impeller exit and diffuser inlet, and rotor speed. Compressor map measurements provide a summary of the operating behavior related to diffuser geometry and impeller speed, whereas detailed flow measurements with temperature and pressure probes allow a breakdown of the losses between impeller and diffuser and contribute to a better understanding of relevant flow phenomena. The results presented in Part I show that an one-sided diffuser clearance does not necessarily has a negative impact on the operation and loss behavior of the centrifugal compressor, but instead may contribute to an increased pressure ratio and improved efficiency as long as the diffuser passage is broad enough with respect to the clearance height. The flow phenomena responsible for this detected performance behavior are exposed in Part II, where the results of detailed measurements with pressure probes at diffuser exit and particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements conducted inside the diffuser channel are discussed. The experimental results are published as an open computational fluid dynamics (CFD) testcase “Radiver 2.”


Author(s):  
Stefan Ubben ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis

The combination of variable speed control and adjustable diffuser vanes offers an attractive design option for centrifugal compressors applied in industrial applications where a wide operating range at high efficiency level and a favorable surge line is required. However, the knowledge about the impact on compressor performance of a diffuser vane clearance between vane and diffuser wall which is mandatory since the diffuser geometry adjustment has to take place during operation, is still not satisfying. The results of characteristic line and probe measurements presented in Part I [18] of this two-part paper showed that an one-sided diffuser clearance not necessarily need to lead to a negative impact on compressor operating behavior but is able to contribute to an increase in flow range, stall margin, pressure ratio and efficiency, as long as the diffuser passage is broad enough with respect to the clearance height. In order to reveal the relevant flow phenomena, in Part II the results of detailed measurements of the pressure distribution at diffuser exit and Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) measurements inside the diffuser channel performed at three clearance configurations and three diffuser angles at a fixed radial gap are discussed. It was found, that for defined diffuser configurations the clearance flow amplifies the diffuser throat vortex capable to reduce the loading of the highly loaded vane pressure side and to support a more homogenous diffuser flow. It turned out that the coaction of the geometry parameter diffuser vane angle and diffuser clearance height is of particular importance. The experimental results are published as an open CFD testcase “Radiver 2” [17], extending the experimental data base of the testcase “Radiver” published in 2003 by Ziegler [24].


Author(s):  
Stefan Ubben ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis

The combination of variable speed control and adjustable diffuser vanes offers an attractive design option for centrifugal compressors applied in industrial applications where a wide operating range at high efficiency level and a favorable surge line is required. However, the knowledge about the impact on compressor performance of a diffuser vane clearance between vane and diffuser wall which is mandatory since the diffuser geometry adjustment has to take place during operation, is still not satisfying. This two-part paper summarizes results of investigations performed at the Institute of Jet Propulsion and Turbomachinery at RWTH Aachen with an industrial-like centrifugal compressor, featuring a design pressure ratio of 4 and a design speed of 35200 rpm. Particular attention was directed to the influence of the diffuser clearance on the operating behavior of the entire stage, the pressure recovery in the diffuser and on the diffuser flow by a systematic variation of the parameters diffuser clearance height, diffuser vane angle, radial gap between impeller exit and diffuser inlet, and rotor speed. Compressor map measurements provide a summary of the operating behavior related to diffuser geometry and impeller speed, whereas detailed flow measurements with temperature and pressure probes allow a breakdown of the losses between impeller and diffuser and contribute to a better understanding of relevant flow phenomena. The results presented in Part I show that an one-sided diffuser clearance does not necessarily has a negative impact on the operation and loss behavior of the centrifugal compressor, but instead may contribute to an increased pressure ratio and improved efficiency. The flow phenomena responsible for this detected performance behavior are exposed in Part II [28], where the results of detailed measurements with pressure probes at diffuser exit and Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) measurements conducted inside the diffuser channel, revealing the complex and unsteady flow leaving the impeller and passing the diffuser channel, are discussed. The experimental results are published as an open CFD testcase “Radiver 2” [26], extending the experimental data base of the testcase “Radiver” published in 2003 by Ziegler [31].


Author(s):  
Kai U. Ziegler ◽  
Heinz E. Gallus ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis

The interaction between impeller and diffuser is considered to have strong influence on the flow in highly loaded centrifugal compressors. However, the knowledge about this influence is still not satisfying. This two-part paper presents an experimental investigation of the effect of impeller-diffuser interaction on the unsteady and the time averaged flow configuration in impeller and diffuser and the performance of these components. The flat wedge vaned diffuser of the investigated stage allows an independent adjustment of diffuser vane angle and radial gap between impeller exit and diffuser vane inlet. Attention is mainly directed to the radial gap, as it determines the intensity of the impeller-diffuser interaction. In part I it was shown that smaller radial gaps improve diffuser pressure recovery, whereas impeller efficiency is hardly affected. Part II focuses on the reasons for these effects. Measurements with a laser-2-focus velocimeter in the highly unsteady flow field between the impeller exit region and diffuser throat were performed at three different diffuser geometries allowing a detailed flow analysis. Especially the unsteady results show that for a smaller radial gap more impeller wake fluid is conveyed towards the highly loaded diffuser vane pressure side reducing its loading and leading to a better diffusion in the diffuser channel. Concerning the impeller flow, it was found that a smaller radial gap is leading to a noticeable reduction of the wake region at impeller exit. The experimental results are intended to be published as an open CFD testcase under the name “Radiver”.


Author(s):  
Uwe Zachau ◽  
Reinhard Niehuis ◽  
Herwart Hoenen ◽  
David C. Wisler

On a centrifugal compressor test facility various experimental investigations have been carried out contributing a valuable gain in knowledge on the fundamental flow physics within passage type diffusers. An extensive measurement series using various steady, unsteady and laser optical measurement techniques has been performed to detect the unsteady, highly three dimensional diffuser flow under various realistic operating conditions. Zachau et al. [1] presented the test facility and the results gathered under nominal conditions. As a follow-up the results of investigated parameter variations are now presented, covering bleed variations, impeller tip clearance and impeller-diffuser misalignment studies. The data is compared to the benchmark created from the nominal baseline data sets and evaluated with respect to the compressor stage performance. Zachau et al. [1] found that under nominal conditions the flow in the pipe diffuser separates on the pressure side in the first half of the pipe. In the last 30% of the pipe hardly any deceleration of the flow takes place. From this, special attention is given to the investigated parameter variations regarding a first proposal for a diffuser design change, which consists in shortening the diffuser. The results for each parameter variation are evaluated in detail in direct comparison to the nominal baseline configuration underlining the conclusion made earlier that the diffuser flow always separates on the pressure side with negligible deceleration in the last third of the diffusing pipe.


Author(s):  
Seiichi Ibaraki ◽  
Tetsuya Matsuo ◽  
Hiroshi Kuma ◽  
Kunio Sumida ◽  
Toru Suita

High pressure ratio centrifugal compressors are applied to turbochargers and turboshaft engines because of their small dimensions, high efficiency and wide operating range. Such a high pressure ratio centrifugal compressor has a transonic inlet condition accompanied with a shock wave in the inducer portion. It is generally said that extra losses are generated by interaction of the shock wave and the boundary layers on the blade surface. To improve the performance of high pressure ratio centrifugal compressor it is necessary to understand the flow phenomena. Although some research works on transonic impeller flow have been published, some unknown flow physics are still remaining. The authors designed a transonic impeller, with an inlet Mach number is about 1.3, and conducted detailed flow measurements by using Laser Doppler Velocimetry (LDV). In the result the interaction between the shock wave and tip leakage vortex at the inducer and flow distortion at the downstream of inducer were observed. The interaction of the boundary layer and the shock wave was not observed. Also computational flow analysis were conducted and compared with experimental results.


Author(s):  
A. R. Wadia ◽  
P. N. Szucs ◽  
D. W. Crall

The recent trend in using aerodynamic sweep to improve the performance of transonic blading has been one of the more significant technological evolutions for compression components in turbomachinery. This paper reports on the experimental and analytical assessment of the pay-off derived from both aft and forward sweep technology with respect to aerodynamic performance and stability. The single stage experimental investigation includes two aft-swept rotors with varying degree and type of aerodynamic sweep and one swept forward rotor. On a back-to-back test basis, the results are compared with an unswept rotor with excellent performance and adequate stall margin. Although designed to satisfy identical design speed requirements as the unswept rotor, the experimental results reveal significant variations in efficiency and stall margin with the swept rotors. At design speed, all the swept rotors demonstrated a peak stage efficiency level that was equal to that of the unswept rotor. However, the forward-swept rotor achieved the highest rotor-alone peak efficiency. At the same time, the forward-swept rotor demonstrated a significant improvement in stall margin relative to the already satisfactory level achieved by the unswept rotor. Increasing the level of aft sweep adversely affected the stall margin. A three-dimensional viscous flow analysis was used to assist in the interpretation of the data. The reduced shock/boundary layer interaction, resulting from reduced axial flow diffusion and less accumulation of centrifuged blade surface boundary layer at the up, was identified as the prime contributor to the enhanced performance with forward sweep. The impact of tip clearance on the performance and stability for one of the aft-swept rotors was also assessed.


Author(s):  
Chenxing Hu ◽  
Xue Li ◽  
Siyu Zheng

The increasing demand for compression systems with high pressure ratio and wide safety margin has set new prerequisites for designers to meet the industrial needs without increasing the manufacturing costs excessively. In this work, the turbulent stability of the vaneless diffuser of the centrifugal compressor was analyzed. Unsteady Reynolds-averaged numerical simulations of the isolated diffuser and full annular diffuser with or without circumferential asymmetric boundary conditions downstream were performed. And a continuous adjoint approach was adopted, which is rarely applied in the stability analysis of compressor flow. Then, the origin of instability under different inflow and outflow conditions was sought with a sensitivity analysis. The prediction of the growth rate reveals that the flow near the shroud dominates the global stability of the diffuser. When connected with an impeller in the upstream direction, the most unstable region is localized at the backflow regions near the outlet. The wave number, however, is altered under the impact of the jet-wake flow. When connected to a circumferential asymmetric condition, the structural sensitivity of the vaneless diffuser with a radius ratio of 1.53 indicates that the interaction between the inlet reverse flow and outlet backflow is responsible for the occurrence of stall. The most unstable regions are localized at the region 90°–135° away from the volute tongue. The present work mainly contributes to the instabilities identification with novel sensitivity methods under asymmetric boundary conditions.


Author(s):  
Ming Ni ◽  
Shaojuan Geng ◽  
Zuojun Wei ◽  
Xiaohua Gan

Abstract Inter-stage water injection is currently a common method to reduce the compression work. In this paper, we evaluate the effect of this approach on an opposed-setting-two-stage centrifugal compressor which is designed for a small gas turbine numerically. The Eulerian-Lagrangian method is adopted to calculate the continuous flow field and discrete particle terms with the k-ε turbulence model. 6 water injection conditions are conducted to compare with the dry air condition. The performance curve shift to the right-up side, i.e. higher total pressure ratio, higher efficiency and larger choking mass flow. However, the larger the performance improvement gained by inter-stage injection, the worse the stability will be. Under the micro injection ratio (about 0.1%), the stall margin of the compressor is improved. Additionally, with a proper injection parameter, the loading in the diffuser can be reduced and promise a wider stall margin. Nevertheless, there still exists droplets at the outlet of the high-pressure diffuser because of the insufficient time for evaporation.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document