Dry Air Cooling and the sCO2 Brayton Cycle

Author(s):  
James J. Sienicki ◽  
Anton Moisseytsev ◽  
Qiuping Lv

Commercially available and cost effective finned tube air coolers are an enabling technology that makes practical dry air cooling for the supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO2) Brayton cycle by which heat is directly rejected from CO2 to the air atmospheric heat sink. With dry air cooling, sCO2 Brayton cycle conditions need to be re-optimized to increase the main compressor inlet temperature and pressure (e.g., 35 °C and 8.2 MPa) relative to water cooling to limit the air cooler size to a practical value, and to increase the compressor outlet pressure (e.g., 25 MPa) to maintain a high efficiency. With reoptimization, the plant efficiency for the AFR-100 Sodium-Cooled Fast Reactor Nuclear Power Plant (NPP) is similar to that with once-through water cooling, while the NPP capital cost per unit output electrical power ($/kWe) is roughly estimated to be only 2 % greater. For the AFR-100 application, no unique benefit is identified for the sCO2 Brayton cycle relative to the superheated steam cycle with respect to the capability to use dry air cooling.

Author(s):  
Anton Moisseytsev ◽  
Qiuping Lv ◽  
James J. Sienicki

The capability to utilize dry air cooling by which heat is directly rejected to the air atmosphere heat sink is one of the benefits of the supercritical carbon dioxide (sCO2) energy conversion cycle. For the selection and analysis of the heat exchanger options for dry air cooling applications for the sCO2 cycle, two leading forced air flow design approaches have been identified and analyzed for this application; an air cooler consisting of modular finned tube air coolers; and an air cooler consisting of modular compact diffusion-bonded heat exchangers. The commercially available modular finned tube air cooler is found to be more cost effective and is selected as the reference for dry air cooling.


Author(s):  
Dominik Thibault ◽  
Patrick K. Dubois ◽  
Benoit Picard ◽  
Alexandre Landry-Blais ◽  
Jean-Sébastien Plante ◽  
...  

Abstract In order to reach 40% efficiency, sub-MW turbines must operate in a recuperated gas Brayton cycle at a turbine inlet temperature (TIT) above 1300°C. Current sub-MW turbines have material-related operating temperature limits. Still to this day, there is no cost-effective rotor design which operates at such high temperatures. This paper introduces a novel, sliding-blade, inside-out ceramic turbine (ICT) wheel configuration, which could enable high-efficiency sub-MW recuperated engines to be achieved with cheap monolithic ceramic blades. The inside-out configuration uses a rotating structural hoop, or shroud, to convert centrifugal forces into compressive blade loading. The sliding-blade architecture uses a hub with angled planes on which ceramic blades slide up and down, allowing to match the radial expansion of the structural shroud. This configuration generates low stress values in both ceramic and metallic components and can achieve high tip speeds. A prototype is designed and its reliability is calculated using CARES software. The result is a design which has a single blade probability of failure (Pf) of 0.1% for 1000 h of steady operation. Analyses also demonstrate that reliability is greatly dependent on friction at ceramic-to-metal interfaces. Low friction could lead to acceptable reliability levels for engine applications. The prototype was successfully tested in a laboratory turbine environment at a tip speed of 350 m/s and a TIT of 1100 °C without any damage.


Author(s):  
D. Thibault ◽  
P. K. Dubois ◽  
B. Picard ◽  
A. Landry-Blais ◽  
J.-S. Plante ◽  
...  

Abstract In order to reach 40% efficiency, sub-MW turbines must operate in a recuperated gas Brayton cycle at a turbine inlet temperature (TIT) above 1300°C. Current sub-MW turbines have material-related operating temperature limits. Still to this day, there is no cost-effective rotor design which operates at such high temperatures. This paper introduces a novel, sliding-blade, inside-out ceramic turbine (ICT) wheel configuration, which could enable high-efficiency sub-MW recuperated engines to be achieved with cheap monolithic ceramic blades. The inside-out configuration uses a rotating structural hoop, or shroud, to convert centrifugal forces into compressive blade loading. The sliding-blade architecture uses a hub with angled planes on which ceramic blades slide up and down, allowing to match the radial expansion of the structural shroud. This configuration generates low stress values in both ceramic and metallic components and can achieve high tip speeds. A prototype is designed and its reliability is calculated using CARES software. The result is a design which has a single blade probability of failure (Pf) of 0.1% for 1000 h of steady operation. Analyses also demonstrate that reliability is greatly dependent on friction at ceramic-to-metal interfaces. Low friction could lead to acceptable reliability levels for engine applications. The prototype was successfully tested in a laboratory turbine environment at a tip speed of 350 m/s and a TIT of 1100 °C without any damage. These achievements demonstrate the robustness of the sliding-blade ICT configuration. Further research and development will focus on increasing tip speed and TIT to higher values.


Author(s):  
T. M. Conboy ◽  
M. D. Carlson ◽  
G. E. Rochau

Currently, waste heat rejection from electrical power systems accounts for the largest fraction of water withdrawals from the US fresh water table. Siting of nuclear power plants is limited to areas with access to a large natural supply of fresh or sea water. Due to a rise in energy needs and increased concern over environmental impact, dry air cooling systems are poised to play a large role in the future energy economy. In practice, the implementation of dry air-cooled condensing systems at steam plants has proven to be capital-intensive and requires the power cycle to take a significant efficiency penalty. These shortcomings are fundamental to dry-air steam condensation, which must occur at a fixed temperature. Closed-cycle gas turbines are an alternative to the conventional steam Rankine plant that allow for much improved dry heat rejection compatibility. Recent research into advanced nuclear energy systems has identified the supercritical CO2 (s-CO2) Brayton cycle in particular as a viable candidate for many proposed reactor types. The s-CO2 Brayton cycle can maintain superior thermal efficiency over a wide range of ambient temperatures, making these power systems ideally suited for dry air cooling, even in warm climates. For an SFR operating at 550°C, thermal efficiency is calculated to be 43% with a 50°C compressor inlet temperature. This is achieved by raising CO2 compressor inlet pressure in response to rising ambient temperatures. Preliminary design studies have shown that s-CO2 power cycle hardware will be compact and therefore well-matched to near-term and advanced integral SMR designs. These advantages also extend to the cooling plant, where it is estimated that dry cooling towers for an SFR-coupled s-CO2 power cycle will be similar in cost and scale to the evaporative cooling tower for an LWR. The projected benefits of the s-CO2 power cycle coupled to dry air heat rejection may enable the long-awaited rise of next-generation nuclear energy systems, while re-drawing the map for siting of small and large nuclear energy systems.


Author(s):  
Dustin W. Demetriou ◽  
Vinod Kamath ◽  
Howard Mahaney

The generation-to-generation IT performance and density demands continue to drive innovation in data center cooling technologies. For many applications, the ability to efficiently deliver cooling via traditional chilled air cooling approaches has become inadequate. Water cooling has been used in data centers for more than 50 years to improve heat dissipation, boost performance and increase efficiency. While water cooling can undoubtedly have a higher initial capital cost, water cooling can be very cost effective when looking at the true lifecycle cost of a water cooled data center. This study aims at addressing how one should evaluate the true total cost of ownership for water cooled data centers by considering the combined capital and operational cost for both the IT systems and the data center facility. It compares several metrics, including return-on-investment for three cooling technologies: traditional air cooling, rack-level cooling using rear door heat exchangers and direct water cooling via cold plates. The results highlight several important variables, namely, IT power, data center location, site electric utility cost, and construction costs and how each of these influence the total cost of ownership of water cooling. The study further looks at implementing water cooling as part of a new data center construction project versus a retrofit or upgrade into an existing data center facility.


Author(s):  
Thomas Conboy ◽  
Steven Wright ◽  
James Pasch ◽  
Darryn Fleming ◽  
Gary Rochau ◽  
...  

Supercritical CO2 (S-CO2) power cycles offer the potential for better overall plant economics due to their high power conversion efficiency over a moderate range of heat source temperatures, compact size, and potential use of standard materials in construction [1,2,3,4]. Sandia National Labs (Albuquerque, NM, US) and the US Department of Energy (DOE-NE) are in the process of constructing and operating a megawatt-scale supercritical CO2 split-flow recompression Brayton cycle with contractor Barber-Nichols Inc. [5] (Arvada, CO, US). This facility can be counted among the first and only S-CO2 power producing Brayton cycles anywhere in the world. The Sandia-DOE test-loop has recently concluded a phase of construction that has substantially upgraded the facility by installing additional heaters, a second recuperating printed circuit heat exchanger (PCHE), more waste heat removal capability, higher capacity load banks, higher temperature piping, and more capable scavenging pumps to reduce windage within the turbomachinery. With these additions, the loop has greatly increased its potential for electrical power generation — according to models, as much as 80 kWe per generator depending on loop configuration — and its ability to reach higher temperatures. To date, the loop has been primarily operated as a simple recuperated Brayton cycle, meaning a single turbine, single compressor, and undivided flow paths. In this configuration, the test facility has begun to realize its upgraded capacity by achieving new records in turbine inlet temperature (650°F/615K), shaft speed (52,000 rpm), pressure ratio (1.65), flow rate (2.7 kg/s), and electrical power generated (20kWe). Operation at higher speeds, flow rates, pressures and temperatures has allowed a more revealing look at the performance of essential power cycle components in a supercritical CO2 working fluid, including recuperation and waste heat rejection heat exchangers (PCHEs), turbines and compressors, bearings and seals, as well as auxiliary equipment. In this report, performance of these components to date will be detailed, including a discussion of expected operational limits as higher speeds and temperatures are approached.


Biomass fuel as carbon neutral, abundant, domestic, cost effective is being reconsidered to fuel-up the power plant to produce electricity in clean way. But utilization of biomass fuel directly in existing conventional power plant causes problem in turbine such as erosion, hot corrosion, clogging and depositions [1]. As such combustion of biomass fuel outside the primary cycle eradicates potential hazards for turbine. In such a case indirectly fired micro gas turbine opens a door to biomass fuel as this technology is free from negative aspects of direct combustion as well as making micro gas turbine feasible to generate electricity in small scale at non-grid areas for individual consumer or group of consumers. In this research, the effect of different types of biomass fuel on operating parameters as well as on output electrical power of externally fired micro gas turbine (EFmGT)has been analyzed. The biomass fuels are categorized on the basis of air to fuel ratio (AFR) using stoichiometry combustion theory. It is found from results that parameters like air mass flow rate, compression ratio, heat exchanger effectiveness, turbine inlet temperature, combustion temperature, and temperature difference in heat exchanger affect the performance of EFmGT. Also types of biomass fuel have substantial impacts on these performance parameters as well as on electrical power output of EFmGT cycle.


Author(s):  
Anton Moisseytsev ◽  
James J. Sienicki

Supercritical carbon dioxide Brayton cycle power converters can benefit advanced nuclear reactors, as well as small modular reactors, by reducing the plant cost and increasing plant electrical output. The sCO2 cycles can also be designed for operation under direct dry air cooling. This paper presents the results of the coupled control analysis of a sCO2 cycle for a 100 MWe sodium-cooled fast reactor. The plant control mechanisms were investigated and optimized for load following operation.


Author(s):  
Jekyoung Lee ◽  
Jeong Ik Lee ◽  
Yoonhan Ahn ◽  
Seong Gu Kim ◽  
Jae Eun Cha

Supercritical carbon dioxide (S-CO2) Brayton cycle has gaining attention due to its compactness and high efficiency at intermediate temperature range of turbine inlet temperature. Thus, many research groups have been trying to develop their own S-CO2 Brayton cycle technology or component design technology. KAIST research team has been trying to develop a S-CO2 turbomachinery design methodology. As a part of this effort, In-House code KAIST_TMD (KAIST Turbomachinery Design) was developed based on open literatures. KAIST_TMD can reflect real gas effect since it uses precise equations and property database rather than ideal gas assumptions. Most special characteristic of KAIST_TMD is that KAIST_TMD can design both of radial type and axial type turbomachineries so it can compare performance of both radial and axial turbomachineries under the same operating conditions. KAIST_TMD provides geometry of turbomachinery and off design performance map also. This research team built a S-CO2 Pump Experiment facility (SCO2PE) to experience the S-CO2 loop operation and to perform validation and verification of KAIST_TMD in near future. Canned motor pump and shell and tube type heat exchanger were installed as the main components of SCO2PE. Main objectives of this paper are to present preliminary experimental data and share the operating experience and troubleshooting of the facility. Data analysis and detailed discussions about an experimental procedure and major issues when pump operates near the critical point will be presented in the paper. As a result, preliminary data were obtained that can be used for improving the facility to increase accuracy of the data for future validation and verification of KAIST_TMD for radial compressor/pump design.


1950 ◽  
Vol 163 (1) ◽  
pp. 221-234 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. G. Smith ◽  
R. D. Pearson

The cooling of turbines offers the alternative advantages of the use of higher cycle-maximum-temperatures than are possible with uncooled turbines, with consequent increase of thermal efficiency and power output for a given size of compressor, or the use of lower quality materials for a given turbine inlet-temperature. Two main methods of cooling the blades, which are the most difficult elements of the turbine to cool, have been investigated in the past. They are internal water-cooling, offering a simpler technical problem in cooling due to the great heat-removing capacity of water as compared with air; and air cooling, offering an inherently simpler “plumbing” system as compared with water cooling. Experimental and theoretical information on both these classes of cooling methods si given, and, in addition, experimental information on a new method of cooling is presented, in which a water spray is injected directly on to rotor-blade exterior surfaces. Work at the National Gas Turbine Establishment (N.G.T.E.) has been concentrated mainly on the application of fundamental heat-transfer information to the design of internally air-cooled blading, and measurements on an internal air-cooled cascade blade showed that the blade could be maintained at temperatures several hundred degrees Fahrenheit below gas temperatures, for small cooling-air quantities. Cooling was non-uniform, and difficulties due to consequent thermal stressing may well appear with blades of the type tested. A great deal of improvement over the performance obtained with this first cascade blade is possible, however, and some information on a type of blade which has theoretically a much better performance is given. All cooling methods so far tested show the feature of non-uniformity of cooling, and the present lack of knowledge on the allowable extent of this non-uniformity is an obstacle to the assessment of the gas temperatures at which the various cooling methods will allow a turbine to be run. Probably the air-injection methods, that is, “effusion” cooling, by effusing air through a permeable blade wall, or “film” cooling, by injecting air through slits pointing backwards along the blade surface, will permit the highest possible gas temperatures, since in both these methods there is an insulating action by the injected air. Results of theoretical work at the N.G.T.E. are presented, showing the need for a higher effusion velocity near the blade edges than elsewhere, for effusion-cooled blades. Information is given from tests on a four-stage turbine whose rotor blades were internally water-cooled by the free thermosiphon method, with steam production. Whilst it is likely that effective cooling was obtained in the sense that metal temperatures were kept low, difficulty was experienced with corrosion of the mild steel rotor, a blade eventually corroding through. Certain difficulties with vibration were experienced, but they are thought not to be inherent in the method of cooling. Another method of liquid cooling, that of spraying a small quantity of water on to the rotor blades (of a Whittle jet-engine) from tubes in the nozzle blades, showed unexpectedly great cooling action. The investigation is as yet, however, in a preliminary stage. A discussion is made of the effect of blade aerodynamic design upon the heat which must be extracted from a stage in order to cool it. It appears from the extrapolation of present blade heat-transfer data, that a high axial-velocity (or, more accurately, a high ratio of axial velocity/peripheral velocity) is advantageous and should lead to low heat-extraction quantities. This high velocity ratio will lead to increased volute losses, and there are other factors tending to cause loss of work and efficiency. Some of these are discussed, but mainly not quantitatively owing to lack of systematic knowledge.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document