Grid Plate Flame Stabilizer for High Intensity Gas Turbine Combustion: The Influence of the Method of Fuel Injection on Mixing, Flame Development and NOx Emissions

2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
José Ramón Quiñonez Arce ◽  
Gordon E. Andrews ◽  
Alan D. Burns ◽  
Naman Al-Dabbagh

Abstract Grid plate flame stabilizers for low NOx emissions have renewed interest in recent years due to their use in low NOx hydrogen gas turbine combustors. For non-premixed grid plate combustion, the difference in flame stabilizer design is in how the grid plate air flow is fueled. In the present work a simple four hole grid plate is investigated using CFD with three methods of fueling the air holes: radially inward fuel injection using 8 fuel nozzles per air hole (Grid Mix, GM 1 and Micromix); central fuel injection (FLOX method); and through a fuel annulus around each air hole (GM2). ANSYS FLUENT CFD predictions for GM2 are compared with axial gas composition traverses inside the combustor and with the mean combustor exit plane emissions. The three methods of fuel injection are also compared using isothermal CFD to determine which of the three methods offer the best mixing quality, which controls the relative NOx emissions. The predictions were for an equivalence ratio of 0.624 for the combustion stage and 0.5 for the isothermal study, using industrial propane. CFD modelling used RANS simulation with Realizable k-epsilon turbulence model, non-premixed combustion with the Steady Laminar Flamelet model. The temperature and mixing profiles obtained for GM2 were in reasonable agreement with the experiments and the other two fuel injection methods were then compared with GM2.

Author(s):  
Mansour Al Qubeissi ◽  
Nawar Al-Esawi ◽  
Hakan Serhad Soyhan

The previously developed models for fuel droplet heating and evaporation processes, mainly the Discrete Multi Component Model (DMCM), and Multi-Dimensional Quasi-Discrete Model (MDQDM) are investigated for the aerodynamic combustion simulation. The models have been recently improved, and generalised for a broad range of bio-fossil fuel blends so that the application areas are broadened with increased accuracy. The main distinctive features of these models are that they consider the impacts of species thermal conductivities and diffusivities within the droplets to account for the temperature gradient, transient diffusion of species and recirculation. A formulation of fuel surrogates is made, using the recently introduced model, referred to as ‘’Complex Fuel Surrogate Model (CFSM)’’ and analysing their heating, evaporation, and combustion characteristics. The CFSM is aimed to reduce the full composition of fuel to a much smaller number of components based on their mass fractions, and to formulate fuel surrogates. Such approach has provided a proof of concept with the implementation of the developed model into a commercial CFD code ANSYS-Fluent. A case study is made for the CFD modelling of gas-turbine engine using kerosene fuel surrogate. The surrogate is proposed using the CFSM. The model is implemented into ANSYS-Fluent via a user-defined function to provide the first full simulation of the combustion process. Detailed chemical mechanism is also implemented into ANSYS Chemkin for the combustion study.


Author(s):  
Alessandro Innocenti ◽  
Antonio Andreini ◽  
Andrea Giusti ◽  
Bruno Facchini ◽  
Matteo Cerutti ◽  
...  

In the present paper a numerical analysis of a low NOx partially premixed burner for industrial gas turbine applications is presented. The first part of the work is focused on the study of the premixing process inside the burner. Standard RANS CFD approach was used: k–ε turbulence model was modified and calibrated in order to find a configuration able to fit available experimental profiles of fuel/air concentration at the exit of the burner. The resulting profiles at different test points have been used to perform reactive simulations of an experimental test rig, where exhaust NOx emissions were measured. An assessment of the turbulent combustion model was carried out with a critical investigation of the expected turbulent combustion regimes in the system and taking into account the partially premixed nature of the flame due to the presence of diffusion type pilot flames. A reliable numerical setup was discovered by comparing predicted and measured NOx emissions at different operating conditions and at different split ratio between main and pilot fuel. In the investigated range, the influence of the premixer in the NOx formation rate was found to be marginal if compared with the pilot flame one. The calibrated numerical setup was then employed to explore possible modifications to fuel injection criteria and fuel split, with the aim of minimizing exhaust NOx emissions. This preliminary numerical screening of alternative fuel injection strategies allowed to define a set of advanced configurations to be investigated in future experimental tests.


Author(s):  
Y. Wang ◽  
L. Reh ◽  
D. Pennell ◽  
D. Winkler ◽  
K. Döbbeling

Stationary gas turbines for power generation are increasingly being equipped with low emission burners. By applying lean premixed combustion techniques for gaseous fuels both NOx and CO emissions can be reduced to extremely low levels (NOx emissions <25vppm, CO emissions <10vppm). Likewise, if analogous premix techniques can be applied to liquid fuels (diesel oil, Oil No.2, etc.) in gas-fired burners, similar low level emissions when burning oils are possible. For gas turbines which operate with liquid fuel or in dual fuel operation, VPL (Vaporised Premixed Lean)-combustion is essential for obtaining minimal NOx-emissions. An option is to vaporise the liquid fuel in a separate fuel vaporiser and subsequently supply the fuel vapour to the natural gas fuel injection system; this has not been investigated for gas turbine combustion in the past. This paper presents experimental results of atmospheric and high-pressure combustion tests using research premix burners running on vaporised liquid fuel. The following processes were investigated: • evaporation and partial decomposition of the liquid fuel (Oil No.2); • utilisation of low pressure exhaust gases to externally heat the high pressure fuel vaporiser; • operation of ABB premix-burners (EV burners) with vaporised Oil No.2; • combustion characteristics at pressures up to 25bar. Atmospheric VPL-combustion tests using Oil No.2 in ABB EV-burners under simulated gas turbine conditions have successfully produced emissions of NOx below 20vppm and of CO below 10vppm (corrected to 15% O2). 5vppm of these NOx values result from fuel bound nitrogen. Little dependence of these emissions on combustion pressure bas been observed. The techniques employed also ensured combustion with a stable non luminous (blue) flame during transition from gaseous to vaporised fuel. Additionally, no soot accumulation was detectable during combustion.


Author(s):  
Gordon E. Andrews ◽  
S. A. R. Ahmed

The scale up of jet shear layer low NOx concepts for compact gas turbine applications is considered using natural gas as the fuel with all experiments at one atmosphere pressure and 600K air inlet temperature. A 76mm diameter cylindrical combustor with 4 round jet shear layers was compared with a near double scale combustor with 140mm diameter and 4 round jet shear layers with the same total blockage as for the smaller combustor. This is compared with 16 round jet shear layers of the same diameter as for the smaller combustor. The shear layer air holes were fuelled by eight radial inward fuel injection holes in each shear layer jet. All three designs had acceptable combustion efficiencies, but the NOx emissions were considerably higher for the 4 shear layer design in the larger combustion. When the same shear layer hole size was used and the number increased in the larger combustor the NOx emissions were identical. Changing the shape of the hole from circulat to slot for the same area, considerably reduced the NOx in the four hole 76mm combustor, but had little effect on the 16 hole 140mm combustor. Fuel staging within the array of shear layers was successfully demonstrated for four levels of fuel staging. There was some intermixing of air from the unfuelled jets, but this had only a small effect on the combustion efficiency and flame stability. A practical range of simulated power turndown was demonstrated with little NOx penalty. This was achieved with no wall between the staged shear layer regions and hence leads to very compact combustor designs.


Author(s):  
H. H.-W. Funke ◽  
S. Boerner ◽  
J. Keinz ◽  
K. Kusterer ◽  
A. Haj Ayed ◽  
...  

In the future low pollution power generation can be achieved by application of hydrogen as a possible alternative gas turbine fuel if the hydrogen is produced by renewable energy sources such as wind energy or biomass. The utilization of existing IGCC power plant technology with the combination of low cost coal as a bridge to renewable energy sources such as biomass can support the international effort to reduce the environmental impact of electricity generation. Against this background the dry low NOx Micromix combustion principle for hydrogen is developed for years to significantly reduce NOx emissions. This combustion principle is based on cross-flow mixing of air and gaseous hydrogen and burns in multiple miniaturized diffusion-type flames. The two advantages of this principle are the inherent safety against flash-back and the low NOx concentrations due to a very short residence time of reactants in the flame region of the micro-flames. The paper presents experimental results showing the significant reduction of NOx emissions at high equivalence ratios and at simultaneously increased energy density under preheated atmospheric conditions. Furthermore the paper presents the feasibility of enlarged Micromix hydrogen injectors reducing the number of required injectors of a full-scale Micromix combustion chamber while maintaining the thermal energy output with significantly low NOx formation. The experimental investigations are accompanied by 3D numerical reacting flow simulations based on a simplified hydrogen combustion model. Comparison with experimental results shows good agreement with respect to flame structure, shape and anchoring position. Thus, the experimental and numerical results highlight further potential of the Micromix combustion principle for low NOx combustion of hydrogen in industrial gas turbine applications.


Author(s):  
N. T. Ahmad ◽  
G. E. Andrews

The premixed combustion efficiency and emissions characteristics of four axial vane swirlers are compared with a simple grid plate stabilised premixed flame. The four swirlers are designed to investigate the influence of Swirl Number, pressure loss and swirler design. The results show that efficient combustion of weak mixtures at simulated gas turbine combustion conditions is difficult with swirl systems, but relatively easily achieved with grid plate systems. High swirl numbers are shown to have the worst combustion efficiency with a major unburned hydrocarbon problem. NOx emissions are similar for all the stabilisers and they all exhibit a very high proportion of NO2 and NOx emissions for weak mixtures.


1992 ◽  
Vol 114 (1) ◽  
pp. 55-62 ◽  
Author(s):  
A. F. Ali Al-Shaikhly ◽  
G. E. Andrews ◽  
C. O. Aniagolu

Direct fueling of each shear layer generated by an array of holes in a grid plate was shown to have ultralow NOx emissions combined with a good flame stability, compared with a premixed system. Two methods of fuel injection were investigated that had opposite NOx/stability characteristics. Four shear layers in a 76-mm combustor were used at gas turbine primary zone operating conditions with 60 percent simulated primary zone air at one bar pressure. The fuels used were propane and natural gas and a minimum NOx emission of 2.5 ppm at 15 percent oxygen, compatible with a 0.1 percent inefficiency, was demonstrated for natural gas with a reasonable stability margin. These designs have the potential for a dry NOx solution to any current or proposed gas turbine NOx regulation for natural gas.


Energies ◽  
2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (20) ◽  
pp. 6545
Author(s):  
Mansour Al Qubeissi ◽  
Nawar Al-Esawi ◽  
Hakan Serhad Soyhan

The previously developed approaches for fuel droplet heating and evaporation processes, mainly using the Discrete Multi Component Model (DMCM), are investigated for the aerodynamic combustion simulation. The models have been recently improved and generalised for a broad range of bio-fossil fuel blends so that the application areas are broadened with an increased accuracy. The main distinctive features of these models are that they consider the impacts of species’ thermal conductivities and diffusivities within the droplets in order to account for the temperature gradient, transient diffusion of species and recirculation. A formulation of fuel surrogates is made using the recently introduced model, referred to as “Complex Fuel Surrogate Model (CFSM)”, and analysing their heating, evaporation and combustion characteristics. The CFSM is aimed to reduce the full composition of fuel to a much smaller number of components based on their mass fractions, and to formulate fuel surrogates. Such an approach has provided a proof of concept with the implementation of the developed model into a commercial CFD code ANSYS Fluent. A case study is made for the CFD modelling of a gas turbine engine using a kerosene fuel surrogate, which is the first of its kind. The surrogate is proposed using the CFSM, with the aim to reduce the computational time and improve the simulation accuracy of the CFD model.


Author(s):  
Roberto Meloni ◽  
Matteo Cerutti ◽  
Alessandro Zucca ◽  
Maurizio Mazzoni

Abstract Main objective of this paper is to assess the capability of numerical models in predicting NOx emissions and flame stabilization mechanisms of a heavy-duty gas turbine burner when operated with hydrogen and hydrogen-methane blends. Effort focused on the selection of the proper input to pre-tabulated Flamelet Generation Manifold combustion model. A dedicated sensitivity to laminar flame speed formulation has been performed as well, since it primarily affects flame stabilization through the closure term of the progress variable transport equation. Available NOx emissions data from full scale annular combustor rig test with hydrogen-air mixtures are presented first in this paper: test results have been used to validate the numerical setup for the reference geometry. Then, the model has been used to predict NOx emissions of alternative geometries in case of pure hydrogen, allowing screening of viable options to reduce the scope of a dedicated test campaign. Concerning flame stabilization mechanisms, simulations have been carried out for a reference geometry first: data from dedicated tests have been used to specialize the tool. Results of modified geometries are shown, to explore the effect of different fuel injection patterns or internal channel modifications. Based on the analysis outcomes, a discussion is provided regarding advantages and drawbacks of each proposed solution, as well as the ability of modelling setup in catching varied flame stabilization mechanisms.


Author(s):  
Adamos Adamou ◽  
Ian Kennedy ◽  
Ben Farmer ◽  
Ahmed Hussein ◽  
Colin Copeland

Abstract Vaporization injectors have been in existence for decades and are a well-proven method of preparing liquid fuels for combustion by heating them above the boiling point of their heaviest hydrocarbon ingredient. By doing so, it converts the fuels into a vapour prior to combustion. When attempting to apply this method of fuel vaporization to micro gas turbines, manufacturing difficulties arise, due to the small complex passages that are required to direct the fuel closer to the high-temperature zone in the combustion chamber and then back to a favourable injection location. This is where the use of additive manufacturing (AM) can prove advantageous due to the complex designs that can be achieved at much smaller scales and potentially at cheaper costs when compared to traditional subtractive manufacturing. The motivation behind the research is to improve the overall efficiency of micro-gas turbines, so they can be applied as range extenders in electric vehicles. Due to the increasing adoption of vehicle electrification. This paper covers the comparison of experimental results for two traditionally manufactured injectors and a third selective laser melted injector (SLM), which were tested in a swirl stabilised micro gas turbine can type combustor on the University of Baths gas stand. The operating range of the tests was 1–4 Bar and 30 to 630 °C inlet air. To the authors knowledge, this is the first such comparison to be made for a gas turbine in open literature, despite wide reports of AM being used in large gas turbines. From the tests, it was found that the 3 and 8 hole machined injectors could not produce stable combustion at the desired operating condition of 4 Bar and 630 °C. The SLM 8 hole injector, however, was able to sustain a stable and constant burn at this design point with low NOx, CO and THC emissions. It was also noticed that the flame colour changed from a yellow flame when testing the first two injectors, to a blue flame when testing the SLM injector suggesting more complete combustion was being achieved due to the lack of soot in burned products, this was assumed to be due to the fuel reaching its saturation conditions within the injector. A number of measurements were taken at various points around the combustor, which included temperatures, pressures and emissions readings. These results were then used to create and validate a non-premixed steady diffusion flamelet model in ANSYS Fluent for the AM injector case. The CFD results were found to overpredict the temperature by approximately 10% when compared to the thermocouple values. This was found to be similar to other studies with similar experimental and computational setups, so it was deemed acceptable. From the validated CFD model, the heat flux at the front surface of the injector was extracted, to be used in a simple heat balance model. Based on a conservative estimate of fuel temperature, the model found that the SLM injectors should have created very near saturation conditions in the nozzle. As this was a conservative analysis, it confirms the experimental findings that partially vaporized fuel was exciting the injector. The model also showed that the fuel in the traditionally machined, 8 hole injector would most likely exit as a liquid.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document