Cloning of domestic animals by somatic cell nuclear transfer (SCNT) has permitted the rescue of valuable genetics and has the potential to allow rapid dissemination of desirable traits in production animals through the use of cloned sires. Whilst cloned animals may show developmental deviations and aberrant DNA methylation suggestive of incomplete nuclear reprogramming, it is widely accepted that their offspring are normal, as any aberrant epigenetic marks are believed to be corrected on passage of the genome through the germline. We assessed the extent of reprogramming by comparing DNA methylation patterns in sperm of SCNT bulls (n = 4) with sperm from bulls generated by AI (n = 5) and with the nuclear donor somatic cells (adult skin fibroblasts). The genomic regions examined were 3 repetitive sequences (satellites 1, 2, and alpha) and CpG islands in 5 genes [HAND1, LIT1, MASH2, IGF2, Dickkopf-1(DKK-1)]. Semen was collected from 16-month-old bulls and assessed for volume, sperm number, morphology, and motility. DNA was extracted from washed sperm and somatic donor cells, bisulfite-treated and processed for quantification of CpG methylation using the Sequenom MassArray system. Methylation levels at individual CpG sites/groups of CpGs were compared between sample groups using the t-test with pooled variances. No apparent difference was detected in semen characteristics between SCNT and AI bulls. Sperm DNA methylation levels were very low in single copy genes with the exception of the CpG island in IGF2, which has previously been shown to be completely methylated in sperm. At all genomic regions examined, each CpG site or CpG groups were methylated to different levels, and each region had a distinctive profile, which was almost invariant between individual sperm samples from either the SCNT or AI bulls. In all sites examined, there were no significant differences in methylation profiles between sperm from SCNT and AI bulls. In contrast, DNA methylation profiles were significantly different between SCNT bull sperm and the donor cells. The exception was the CpG island in MASH2, which was essentially unmethylated in both. For the 3 satellite sequences along with LIT1, HAND1, and to a lesser extent, the DKK-1 region, DNA was significantly less methylated in sperm than in the donor cells. Only IGF2 was significantly more methylated in SCNT and AI sperm than in the donor cells at 10/25 CpG sites (P < 0.02). The results indicate that gametes from SCNT bulls had different epigenotypes from the donor somatic cells. This is the first molecular evidence that donor cell genomes have been reprogrammed in these SCNT bulls and that after going through the germline had acquired DNA methylation profiles that were similar to AI-derived bulls. It also suggests that any epigenetic aberrations that SCNT bulls may harbor are unlikely to be passed on to their offspring through their gametes.
Supported by FRST contract C10X0311.
Statistical inference of transmission fidelity of DNA methylation patterns over somatic cell divisions in mammals
