scholarly journals The Examination of Argumentation Based Problem Solving Processes of 10th Grade Students

2021 ◽  
Vol 14 (1) ◽  
pp. 46-63
Author(s):  
Sare ŞENGÜL ◽  
Çiğdem ŞATIR ALTINEL

"Abstract: The aim of this study is to examine the argumentation-based problem solving processes of 10th grade students in the context of quadratic equations. The study was carried out in a public high school in Istanbul. The study group consists of three male students selected by the method of “homogeneous sampling”. In the research, special case study, one of the qualitative research models, was used. The data in the application process were collected with two problem-solving activities related to quadratic equations. The students tried to solve the problems together by doing group work with one week interval for both problems. The problem solving processes of the students were recorded with the video recorder and the discussions between the students were analyzed according to Toulmin's argumentation model. According to the findings of the research, it was determined that the students used the argument (65), least rebuttal (3) and qualitative (3) components among the argumentation components. Students produced less arguments in the first problem solutions than the second problem. For this reason, differences were observed in students' ability to produce arguments according to the qualifications of the questions. In addition, after the argumentation study, the students stated that the problem solving process contributed in the context of understanding the problem for themselves, expressing their thoughts, persuading their opinions by defending their ideas, and communicating together and they want to be found again in similar working environments."

2013 ◽  
Vol 284-287 ◽  
pp. 3702-3706
Author(s):  
Chih Kun Ke

In manufacturing industries, various problems may occur during the production process. A problem is a complex status which involves relevant context in working environments. A problem-solving process is often initiated to create a solution for achieving the desired status; in this process, determining how to obtain a solution from the various candidate solutions is an important issue. In such uncertain working environments, context information provides rich clues for problem-solving decision making. Therefore, this work uses a selection approach for an optimized problem-solving process to assist workers in choosing a reasonable solution. A context-based utility model explores the problem context information to obtain the candidate solutions’ actual utility values; a multi-criteria decision analysis uses the actual utility values to determine the optimal selection order of candidate solutions. The selection order is presented to the worker as an adaptive knowledge recommendation. The worker chooses a reasonable problem-solving solution based on the selection order. This paper uses a high-tech company’s knowledge base log as the analysis data. The experimental results show that the chosen approach to an optimized problem-solving solution selection is effective. The contribution of this research is in demonstrating a method which is easy to implement in a problem-solving knowledge recommendation system for selecting a reasonable solution.


2021 ◽  
Vol 5 (1) ◽  
pp. 26
Author(s):  
Rizky Dian Pertiwi ◽  
Tatag Yuli Eko Siswono

Abstrak — Kemampuan komunikasi matematis adalah kecakapan seseorang dalam menggunakan istilah matematika untuk menyalurkan pemikirannya secara sistematis baik secara lisan maupun tulis. Kemampuan komunikasi matematis dapat diketahui dari kemampuan siswa dalam menyelesaikan soal matematika dan kemampuan dalam mengkomunikasikan hasilnya kepada orang lain. Pengetahuan mengenai transformasi geometri berperan penting dalam perkembangan matematika siswa di sekolah karena dapat membangun kemampuan spasial, kemampuan penalaran serta membantu siswa dalam menganalisis situasi matematis. Penelitian ini bertujuan untuk mendeskripsikan kemampuan komunikasi matematis dalam menyelesaikan soal transformasi geometri yang ditinjau dari gender. Jenis penelitian ini adalah penelitian kualitatif dengan pendekatan deskriptif. Subjek penelitian ini adalah dua orang siswa laki laki dan dua orang siswa perempuan di salah satu sekolah menengah Kota Mojokerto dikarenakan penelitian ini mendeskripsikan bagaimana kemampuan komunikasi matematis yang ditunjukkan oleh siswa laki-laki dan perempuan. Berdasarkan analisis data dalam penelitian dapat disimpulkan bahwa (1) Kemampuan komunikasi matematis siswa lakilaki lebih unggul dibandingkan siswa perempuan dalam kemampuan menyajikan informasi serta dalam kemampuan menggunakan bahasa matematika yang logis dan sistematis dalam proses penyelesaian soal. Sedangkan pada kemampuan menggunakan representasi matematis dalam menyatakan gagasan matematis untuk menyelesaikan soal transformasi geometri, siswa laki-laki dan perempuan memiliki kemampuan yang sama. (2) Siswa laki-laki lebih mampu menyelesaikan soal transformasi geometri dengan lebih tepat dibandingkan siswa perempuan. (3) Siswa laki-laki lebih unggul dalam menjawab soal secara tertulis, sedangkan siswa perempuan memiliki kemampuan yang baik dalam menyajikan jawaban secara lisan atauverbal.Kata kunci: kemampuan komunikasi matematis, transformasi geometri, gender.Abstract — Mathematical communication skills are a person's ability to use mathematical terms to express their thoughts systematically both spoken and written. Mathematical communication skills can be seen from the ability of students to solve mathematic problems and the ability to communicate the results to others. Knowledge of geometric transformations plays an important role in the development of student’s mathematics in school because it can build spatial abilities, reasoning abilities and help students analyze mathematical situations. This study aims to describe written mathematical communication skills in solvinggeometric transformation problems in terms of gender. This type of research is a qualitative research with a descriptive approach. The subjects of this study are two male students and two female students in one of senior high school in Mojokerto because this study describes how mathematical communication skills are showed by male and female students. The results showed that (1) Male students' mathematical communication skills are superior to female students in the ability to present information and in the ability to use logical and systematic mathematical language in the problem solving process. Meanwhile, the abilityto use mathematical representations in expressing mathematical ideas to solve geometric transformation problems, male and female students have the same abilities. (2) Male students are more able to solve geometric transformation problems more precisely than female students. (3) Male students are superior inanswering questions in writing, while female students have good abilities in present the answer orally or verbally.Keywords: mathematical communication skills, problem solving, gender.


Author(s):  
K. Werner ◽  
M. Raab

Embodied cognition theories suggest a link between bodily movements and cognitive functions. Given such a link, it is assumed that movement influences the two main stages of problem solving: creating a problem space and creating solutions. This study explores how specific the link between bodily movements and the problem-solving process is. Seventy-two participants were tested with variations of the two-string problem (Experiment 1) and the water-jar problem (Experiment 2), allowing for two possible solutions. In Experiment 1 participants were primed with arm-swing movements (swing group) and step movements on a chair (step group). In Experiment 2 participants sat in front of three jars with glass marbles and had to sort these marbles from the outer jars to the middle one (plus group) or vice versa (minus group). Results showed more swing-like solutions in the swing group and more step-like solutions in the step group, and more addition solutions in the plus group and more subtraction solutions in the minus group. This specificity of the connection between movement and problem-solving task will allow further experiments to investigate how bodily movements influence the stages of problem solving.


Author(s):  
Liska Yanti Pane ◽  
Kamid Kamid ◽  
Asrial Asrial

This research aims to describe logical thinking process of a logical-mathematical intelligence student. We employ qualitative method to disclose the subject’s learning process. Data are collected by interview and modified think aloud methods. The results show that subject has capability to find and organize problems and data correctly. Subject describes conditions that are needed to do the steps of problem solving strategy. The steps are done systematically until the end of problem solving process.


Author(s):  
Imelda Aisah Sarip ◽  
Kamid Kamid ◽  
Bambang Hariyadi

The aim of this research is to describe creative thinking process of linguistic type student in biology problem solving. This research is conducted to linguistic intelligence type of subject at SMPN 6 Kota Jambi. SL the subject was selected based on the aim of the research. Data collection is conducted by interview and a modified think aloud method. Data is analyzed based on creative thinking process purposed by Polya.The result of this research shows that SL could find and arrange the given problems and collect data correctly and appropriately. The problem solving steps is done systematically to the end of problem solving process. The last steps problem solving, SL does checking while doing scratching to make sure that the written answers meet her need.


Author(s):  
Ronnie W. Smith ◽  
D. Richard Hipp

As spoken natural language dialog systems technology continues to make great strides, numerous issues regarding dialog processing still need to be resolved. This book presents an exciting new dialog processing architecture that allows for a number of behaviors required for effective human-machine interactions, including: problem-solving to help the user carry out a task, coherent subdialog movement during the problem-solving process, user model usage, expectation usage for contextual interpretation and error correction, and variable initiative behavior for interacting with users of differing expertise. The book also details how different dialog problems in processing can be handled simultaneously, and provides instructions and in-depth result from pertinent experiments. Researchers and professionals in natural language systems will find this important new book an invaluable addition to their libraries.


2005 ◽  
Vol 24 (4) ◽  
pp. 259-274
Author(s):  
Sameer Kumar ◽  
Thomas Ressler ◽  
Mark Ahrens

This article is an appeal to incorporate qualitative reasoning into quantitative topics and courses, especially those devoted to decision-making offered in colleges and universities. Students, many of whom join professional workforce, must become more systems thinkers and decision-makers than merely problem-solvers. This will entail discussion of systems thinking, not just reaching “the answer”. Managers will need to formally and forcefully discuss objectives and values at each stage of the problem-solving process – at the start, during the problem-solving stage, and at the interpretation of the results stage – in order to move from problem solving to decision-making. The authors suggest some methods for doing this, and provide examples of why doing so is so important for decision-makers in the modern world.


2020 ◽  
Vol 2 (1) ◽  
pp. 112-125
Author(s):  
Marcela Pozas ◽  
Patrick Löffler ◽  
Wolfgang Schnotz ◽  
Alexander Kauertz

AbstractPrior knowledge, motivational factors, and metacognition have been long considered basic elements for successful problem-solving process. However, the interplay of these variables with context-based task characteristics has rarely been explored in research. The present study aimed at investigating how context-based task characteristics influence these three elements, and further expands to explore potential differentiated effects across physics’ topics. A multivariate analysis of covariance was conducted with 232 participants from high-track schools in Germany to investigate the effects of task characteristics and task topic with regard to their motivational and metacognitive variables. Overall results indicated that students’ situational interest and estimate of solution correctness decrease through time as a result from their interaction with the tasks characteristics. Furthermore, between-subject factor analyses revealed important differences across the task topics of mechanics and thermodynamics. Finally, the covariate of prior knowledge was positively significant across all analyses. The findings demonstrate the importance of appropriate design of context-based tasks to positively influence students’ motivation and metacognitive processing. Implications of the results, as well as further lines of research are discussed.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document