scholarly journals Comparison between upwind and downwind designs of a 10 MW wind turbine rotor

2019 ◽  
Vol 4 (1) ◽  
pp. 115-125 ◽  
Author(s):  
Pietro Bortolotti ◽  
Abhinav Kapila ◽  
Carlo L. Bottasso

Abstract. The size of wind turbines has been steadily growing in the pursuit of a lower cost of energy by an increased wind capture. Within this trend, the vast majority of wind turbine rotors have been designed based on the conventional three-bladed upwind concept. This paper aims at assessing the optimality of this configuration with respect to a three-bladed downwind design, with and without an actively controlled variable coning used to reduce the cantilever loading of the blades. Results indicate that a conventional design appears difficult to beat even at these turbine sizes, although a downwind nonaligned configuration might be an interesting alternative.

2018 ◽  
Author(s):  
Pietro Bortolotti ◽  
Abinhav Kapila ◽  
Carlo L. Bottasso

Abstract. The size of wind turbines has been steadily growing in the pursuit of a lower cost of energy by an increased wind capture. In this trend, the vast majority of wind turbine rotors has been designed based on the conventional three-bladed upwind concept. This paper aims at assessing the optimality of this configuration with respect to a three-bladed downwind design, with and without an actively controlled variable coning used to reduce the cantilever loading of the blades. A 10 MW wind turbine is used for the comparison of the various design solutions, which are obtained by an automated comprehensive aerostructural design tool. Results show that, for this turbine size, downwind rotors lead to blade mass and cost reductions of 6 % and 2 %, respectively, compared to equivalent upwind configurations. Due to a more favorable rotor attitude, the annual energy production of downwind rotors may also slightly increase in complex terrain conditions characterized by a wind upflow, leading to an overall reduction in the cost of energy. However, in more standard operating conditions, upwind rotors return the lowest cost of energy. Finally, active coning is effective in alleviating loads by reducing both blade mass and cost, but these potential benefits are negated by an increased system complexity and reduced energy production. In summary, a conventional design appears difficult to beat even at these turbine sizes, although a downwind non-aligned configuration might result in an interesting alternative.


Author(s):  
Sayem Zafar ◽  
Mohamed Gadalla

A small horizontal axis wind turbine rotor was designed and tested with aerodynamically efficient, economical and easy to manufacture blades. Basic blade aerodynamic analysis was conducted using commercially available software. The blade span was constrained such that the complete wind turbine can be rooftop mountable with the envisioned wind turbine height of around 8 m. The blade was designed without any taper or twist to comply with the low cost and ease of manufacturing requirements. The aerodynamic analysis suggested laminar flow airfoils to be the most efficient airfoils for such use. Using NACA 63-418 airfoil, a rectangular blade geometry was selected with chord length of 0.27[m] and span of 1.52[m]. Glass reinforced plastic was used as the blade material for low cost and favorable strength to weight ratio with a skin thickness of 1[mm]. Because of the resultant velocity changes with respect to the blade span, while the blade is rotating, an optimal installed angle of attack was to be determined. The installed angle of attack was required to produce the highest possible rotation under usual wind speeds while start at relatively low speed. Tests were conducted at multiple wind speeds with blades mounted on free rotating shaft. The turbine was tested for three different installed angles and rotational speeds were recorded. The result showed increase in rotational speed with the increase in blade angle away from the free-stream velocity direction while the start-up speeds were found to be within close range of each other. At the optimal angle was found to be 22° from the plane of rotation. The results seem very promising for a low cost small wind turbine with no twist and taper in the blade. The tests established that non-twisted wind turbine blades, when used for rooftop small wind turbines, can generate useable electrical power for domestic consumption. It also established that, for small wind turbines, non-twisted, non-tapered blades provide an economical yet productive alternative to the existing complex wind turbine blades.


2021 ◽  
Vol 6 (5) ◽  
pp. 1277-1290
Author(s):  
Pietro Bortolotti ◽  
Nick Johnson ◽  
Nikhar J. Abbas ◽  
Evan Anderson ◽  
Ernesto Camarena ◽  
...  

Abstract. This work investigates the conceptual design and the aeroservoelastic performance of land-based wind turbines whose blades can be transported on rail via controlled bending. The turbines have a nameplate power of 5 MW and a rotor diameter of 206 m, and they aim to represent the next generation of land-based machines. Three upwind designs and two downwind designs are presented, combining different design goals together with conventional glass and pultruded carbon fiber laminates in the spar caps. One of the five blade designs is segmented and serves as a benchmark to the state of the art in industry. The results show that controlled flexing requires a reduction in the flapwise stiffness of the blades, but it represents a promising pathway for increasing the size of land-based wind turbine rotors. Given the required stiffness, the rotor can be designed either downwind with standard rotor preconing and nacelle uptilt angles or upwind with higher-than-usual angles. A downwind-specific controller is also presented, featuring a cut-out wind speed reduced to 19 m s−1 and a pitch-to-stall shutdown strategy to minimize blade tip deflections toward the tower. The flexible upwind and downwind rotor designs equipped with pultruded carbon fiber spar caps are found to generate the lowest levelized cost of energy, 2.9 % and 1.3 %, respectively, less than the segmented design. The paper concludes with several recommendations for future work in the area of large flexible wind turbine rotors.


Author(s):  
Youjin Kim ◽  
Ali Al-Abadi ◽  
Antonio Delgado

This study introduces strategic methods for improving the aerodynamic performance of wind turbines. It was completed by combining different optimization methods for each part of the wind turbine rotor. The chord length and pitch angle are optimized by a torque-matched method (TMASO), whereas the airfoil shape is optimized by the genetic algorithm (GA). The TMASO is implemented to produce an improved design of a reference turbine (NREL UAE Phase V). The GA is operated to generate a novel airfoil design that is evaluated by automatic interfacing for the highest gliding ratio (GR). The adopted method produces an optimized wind turbine with an 11% increase of power coefficient (Cp) with 30% less of the corresponding tip speed ratio (TSR). Furthermore, the optimized wind turbine shows reduced tip loss effect.


Rangifer ◽  
2004 ◽  
Vol 24 (2) ◽  
pp. 55-66 ◽  
Author(s):  
Kjetil Flydal ◽  
Sindre Eftestøl ◽  
Eigil Reimers ◽  
Jonathan E. Colman

In recent decades, industrial developments have expanded into reindeer ranges in the arctic and adjacent higher latitudes in search for energy, minerals, timber and other resources. Several wind turbine parks are under planning in reindeer ranges in Norway, and there is concern about possible negative effects on behaviour and area use of wild and semi-domestic reindeer. We tested whether a wind turbine and its rotor movement had any effect on area use, activity changes, vigilance bouts, and restless behaviour like running, walking, and standing for enclosed semi-domestic reindeer. Five different groups of reindeer in a 450 m long, 8 hectare, enclosure close to a wind turbine were manipulated by turning the wind turbine rotor on and off, and compared with reindeer in a control enclosure without wind turbine exposure. When exposed to rotor movement, two groups used locations farther from the wind turbine, two groups showed no shift, while one group moved closer to the wind turbine. The reindeer showed no systematic differences in the measured behaviour patterns between the two enclosures that could indicate fright or stress as a consequence of the wind turbine or rotor movement. We conclude that semi-domestic reindeer in an enclosure showed no negative behavioural response and little or no aversion towards a wind turbine. The possibility of rapid habituation in a small enclosure with continuous wind turbine exposure suggests that effects on area use should be studied at a larger scale or with free-ranging reindeer.Abstract in Norwegian / Sammendrag:I løpet av de senere tiår har industriell utbygging til utnytting av energi, mineraler, tømmer og andre ressurser ekspandert inn i reinens beiteområder i nordområdene. Flere vindmølleparker er under planlegging i norske reinbeiteområder, og det spekuleres i mulige konsekvenser av disse på atferd og arealbruk hos villrein og tamrein. Vi testet om en vindmølle og dens rotorbevegelse hadde noen effekt på arealbruk, aktivitetsskifter, vaktsomhetsatferd, og rastløshetsatferd i form av løp, gange og ståing for tamrein i innhegning. I en 450 m lang innhegning på 8 hektar som var plassert tett opp til en vindmølle, ble fem forskjellig grupper av reinsdyr manipulert ved å slå vindmøllerotoren av og på. Reinsdyrene i innhegningen ved vindmøllen ble sammenlignet med reinsdyr i en kontrollinnhegning som var uten påvirkning fra vindmøller. Når reinsdyrene ble utsatt for vindmøllerotoren i bevegelse, viste to grupper av dyr et skifte i arealbruk til områder av innhegningen som var lenger unna møllen, to grupper av dyr viste ikke noe skifte i arealbruk, mens en gruppe dyr beveget seg nærmere vindmøllen. Sammenligning av atferden hos reinsdyrene i vindmølleinnhegningen og kontrollinnhegningen viste ingen systematisk forskjell som kunne indikere frykt eller stress som en effekt av vindmøllen eller rotorbevegelsen. Vi konkluderer med at tamrein i innhegning ikke viser negative atferdsresponser og viser lite eller ingen reduksjon i arealbruken tett opp til en vindmølle. Muligheten for at det skjer en rask tilvenning i en liten innhegning der dyrene er i kontinuerlig påvirkning av vindmøllen betyr at effekter på arealbruk bør studeres i et større arealperspektiv eller på frittgående rein.


2019 ◽  
Vol 12 (2) ◽  
pp. 92
Author(s):  
Susilo Susilo ◽  
Bambang Widodo ◽  
Eva Magdalena Silalahi ◽  
Atmadi Priyono

Bentuk sudu taper linier merupakan bentuk sudu yang paling optimal untuk kecepatan angin yang rendah. Jumlah sudu yang baik untuk kecepatan angin rendah berkisar antara 3-7 buah sudu, namun desain sudu dengan menggunakan airfoil dan profil pada sudut pasang sudu yang bagaimana memberikan daya keluaran dan tegangan keluaran yang optimal. Turbin angin didesain dengan 2 bilah dan 4 bilah dengan sudut pasang yang bisa diatur untuk mendapatkan perbedaan daya optimal masing-masing desain. Pengujian dilakukan di 3 area berbeda untuk mendapatkan gambaran geografis kondisi angin yang berbeda khususnya masalah kecepatan angin di ksiaran 2 m/s - 7 m/s. Pengujian dilakukan dengan luas penampang turbin angin (A) sebesar 3m2 Hasil penelitian menunjukkan bahwa nilai terbaik diperoleh pada kecepatan angin maksimal 4 m/s dan jumlah blade 4  sedangkan untuk nilai terkecil diperoleh pada kecepatan angin 3 m/s dan jumlah blade 2 yaitu. Untuk nilai TSR maksimal pada kecepatan maksimal 4 m/s terjadi pada jumlah blade 4, sedangkan untuk nilai terendah pada kecepatan angin 3 m/s dihasilkan pada jumlah blade 2. Melalui pengukuran berbasis teknologi smart monitoring system, dari penelitian diperoleh semakin tinggi kecepatan angin maka tegangan keluaran semakin tinggi. Semakin tinggi tegangan keluaran, semakin tinggi daya keluaran pada generator. Sudut pasang ? dan jumlah sudu mempengaruhi kecepatan putaran rotor turbin angin. Kecepatan putaran rotor turbin angin berelasi dengan tegangan keluaran generator. pada sudut pasang ? dan jumlah sudu 4, diperoleh daya keluaran yang sebesar 150 watt namun pada kecepatan angin 7 m/s daya turbin yang dihasilkan mencapai 600 watt. Dengan kondisi ini cukup memenuhi untuk alternatif cadangan listrik skala rumah tangga khusunya di pedesaan dan daerah terpencil (rural area). The linear taper blade shape is the most optimal blade shape for low wind speeds. The number of blades that are good for low wind speeds ranges from 3-7 blades, but the blade design uses an airfoil and profile on the blade mounting angle which is how to provide optimal output power and output voltage. Wind turbines are designed with 2 blades and 4 blades with adjustable tide angles to get the difference in the optimal power of each design. Tests were carried out in 3 different areas to obtain a geographical description of different wind conditions, especially the problem of wind speed in the range of 2 m / s - 7 m / s. Tests carried out with a cross section area of  wind turbines (A) of 3m2 The results showed that the best value was obtained at a maximum wind speed of 4 m / s and number 4 blade while the smallest value was obtained at wind speeds of 3 m / s and number 2 blades namely. For the maximum TSR value at a maximum speed of 4 m / s occurs in the number of 4 blades, while for the lowest value at 3 m / s wind speed is produced on the number of blades 2. From the research, the higher the wind speed, the higher the output voltage. The higher the output voltage, the higher the output power at the generator. The ? tide angle and number of blades affect the speed of the wind turbine rotor rotation. The rotational speed of the wind turbine rotor is related to the generator output voltage. at the tide angle ? and number of blades 4, the output power of 150 watts is obtained but with wind speed 7 m/s turbine power 600 watt achieved. With this condition, it is sufficient for alternative household electricity reserves, especially in rural and remote areas (rural areas).


Author(s):  
Michael McWillam ◽  
David Johnson

The engineering of wind turbines is not fully mature. There are still phenomena, particularly dynamic stall that cannot be accurately modeled. Dynamic stall contributes to fatigue stress and premature failure in many turbine components. The three dimensionality of dynamic stall make these structures unique for wind turbines. Currently flow visualization of dynamic stall on a wind turbine rotor has not been achieved, but these visualizations can reveal a great deal about the structures that contribute to dynamic stall. Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) is a powerful experimental technique that can take non-intrusive flow measurements of planar flow simultaneously. High-speed cameras enable time resolved PIV can reveal the transient development. This technique is suited to gain a better understanding of dynamic stall. A custom 3.27 m diameter wind turbine has been built to allow such measurements on the blade. The camera is mounted on the hub and will take measurements within the rotating domain. Mirrors are used so that laser illumination rotates with the blade. The wind turbine will operate in controlled conditions provided by a large wind tunnel. High-speed pressure data acquisition will be used in conjunction with PIV to get an understanding of the forces associated with the flow structures. Many experiments will be made possible by this apparatus. First the flow structures responsible for the forces can be identified. Quantitative measurements of the flow field will identify the development of the stall vortex. The quantified flow structures can be used to verify and improve models. The spatial resolution of PIV can map the three dimensional structure in great detail. The experimental apparatus is independent of the blade geometry; as such multiple blades can be used to identify the effect of blade geometry. Finally flow control research in the field of aviation can be applied to control dynamic stall. These experiments will be subject of much of the future work at the University of Waterloo. Potentially this work will unlock the secrets of dynamic stall and improve the integrity of wind turbines.


2018 ◽  
Vol 28 (5) ◽  
pp. 1047-1060 ◽  
Author(s):  
Javier Martinez Suarez ◽  
Pawel Flaszynski ◽  
Piotr Doerffer

Purpose The purpose of this paper is to describe numerical investigations focused on the reduction of separation and the aerodynamic enhancement of wind turbine blades by a rod vortex generator (RVG). Design/methodology/approach A flow modelling approach through the use of a Reynolds-averaged Navier–Stokes solver is used. The numerical tools are validated with experimental data for the NREL Phase VI rotor and the S809 aerofoil. The effect of rod vortex generator’s (RVG) configuration on aerofoil aerodynamic performance, flow structure and separation is analysed. RVGs’ chordwise locations and spanwise distance are considered, and the optimum configuration of the RVG is applied to the wind turbine rotor. Findings Results show that streamwise vortices created by RVGs lead to modification of flow structure in boundary layer. As a result, the implementation of RVGs on aerofoil has proven to decrease the flow separation and enhance the aerodynamic performance of aerofoils. The effect on flow structure and aerodynamic performance has shown to be dependent on dimensions, chordwise location and spanwise distribution of rods. The implementation of devices with the optimum configuration has shown to increase aerodynamic performance and to significantly reduce separation for selected conditions. Application of rods to the wind turbine rotor has proven to avoid the spanwise penetration of flow separation where applied, leading to reduction of flow separation and to aerodynamic enhancement. Originality/value The proposed RVGs have shown potential to enhance the aerodynamic performance of wind turbine rotors and profiles, making devices an alternative solution to the classical vortex generators for wind turbine applications.


2021 ◽  
Author(s):  
Pietro Bortolotti ◽  
Nick Johnson ◽  
Nikhar J. Abbas ◽  
Evan Anderson ◽  
Ernesto Camarena ◽  
...  

Abstract. This work investigates the conceptual design and the aeroservoelastic performance of land-based wind turbines whose blades can be transported on rail via controlled bending. The turbines have a nameplate power of 5 MW and a rotor diameter of 206 m, and they aim to represent the next generation of land-based machines. Three upwind designs and two downwind designs are presented, combining different design goals together with conventional glass and pultruded carbon fiber laminates in the spar caps. The results show that controlled flexing requires a reduction in the flapwise stiffness of the blades, but it represents a promising pathway to increase the size of land-based wind turbine rotors. Given the required stiffness, the rotor can be designed either downwind with standard rotor preconing and nacelle uptilt angles or upwind with higher-than-usual angles. A downwind-specific controller is also presented, featuring a cut-out wind speed reduced to 19 m per second and a pitch-to-stall shutdown strategy to minimize blade-tip deflections toward the tower. The flexible upwind and downwind rotor designs equipped with pultruded carbon fiber spar caps are found to generate the lowest levelized cost of energy, 2.9 % and 1.3 %, respectively, less than the segmented design. The paper concludes with several recommendations for future work in the area of large flexible wind turbine rotors.


Energies ◽  
2020 ◽  
Vol 13 (14) ◽  
pp. 3745 ◽  
Author(s):  
Takanori Uchida

The scope of the present study was to understand the wake characteristics of wind-turbines under various inflow shears. First, in order to verify the prediction accuracy of the in-house large-eddy simulation (LES) solver, called RIAM-COMPACT, based on a Cartesian staggered grid, we conducted a wind-tunnel experiment using a wind-turbine scale model and compared the numerical and experimental results. The total number of grid points in the computational domain was about 235 million. Parallel computation based on a hybrid LES/actuator line (AL) model approach was performed with a new SX-Aurora TSUBASA vector supercomputer. The comparison between wind-tunnel experiment and high-resolution LES results showed that the AL model implemented in the in-house LES solver in this study could accurately reproduce both performances of the wind-turbine scale model and flow characteristics in the wake region. Next, with the LES solver developed in-house, flow past the entire wind-turbine, including the nacelle and the tower, was simulated for a tip-speed ratio (TSR) of 4, the optimal TSR. Three types of inflow shear, N = 4, N = 10, and uniform flow, were set at the inflow boundary. In these calculations, the calculation domain in the streamwise direction was very long, 30.0 D (D being the wind-turbine rotor diameter) from the center of the wind-turbine hub. Long-term integration of t = 0 to 400 R/Uin was performed. Various turbulence statistics were calculated at t = 200 to 400 R/Uin. Here, R is the wind-turbine rotor radius, and Uin is the wind speed at the hub-center height. On the basis of the obtained results, we numerically investigated the effects of inflow shear on the wake characteristics of wind-turbines over a flat terrain. Focusing on the center of the wind-turbine hub, all results showed almost the same behavior regardless of the difference in the three types of inflow shear.


Sign in / Sign up

Export Citation Format

Share Document