A human stem cell resource to decipher the biochemical and cellular basis of neurodevelopmental defects in Lowe Syndrome

Human brain development is a complex process where multiple cellular and developmental events are co-ordinated to generate normal structure and function. Alteration in any of these events can impact brain development, manifesting clinically as neurodevelopmental disorders. Human genetic disorders of lipid metabolism often present with features of altered brain function. Lowe syndrome (LS), is a X-linked recessive disease with features of altered brain function. LS results from mutations in OCRL1 that encodes a phosphoinositide 5-phosphatase enzyme. However, the cellular mechanisms by which loss of OCRL1 leads to brain defects remain unknown. Human brain development involves several cellular and developmental features not conserved in other species and understanding such mechanisms remains a challenge. Rodent models of LS have been generated, but failed to recapitulate features of the human disease. Here we describe the generation of human stem cell lines from LS patients. Further, we present biochemical characterization of lipid metabolism in patient cell lines and demonstrate their use as a “disease-in-a-dish” model for understanding the mechanism by which loss of OCRL1 leads to altered cellular and physiological brain development.

Genotype Phenotype Correlation in Dent Disease 2 and Review of the Literature: OCRL Gene Pleiotropism or Extreme Phenotypic Variability of Lowe Syndrome?

Dent disease is a rare X-linked renal tubulopathy due to CLCN5 and OCRL (DD2) mutations. OCRL mutations also cause Lowe syndrome (LS) involving the eyes, brain and kidney. DD2 is frequently described as a mild form of LS because some patients may present with extra-renal symptoms (ESs). Since DD2 is a rare disease and there are a low number of reported cases, it is still unclear whether it has a clinical picture distinct from LS. We retrospectively analyzed the phenotype and genotype of our cohort of 35 DD2 males and reviewed all published DD2 cases. We analyzed the distribution of mutations along the OCRL gene and evaluated the type and frequency of ES according to the type of mutation and localization in OCRL protein domains. The frequency of patients with at least one ES was 39%. Muscle findings are the most common ES (52%), while ocular findings are less common (11%). Analysis of the distribution of mutations revealed (1) truncating mutations map in the PH and linker domain, while missense mutations map in the 5-phosphatase domain, and only occasionally in the ASH-RhoGAP module; (2) five OCRL mutations cause both DD2 and LS phenotypes; (3) codon 318 is a DD2 mutational hot spot; (4) a correlation was found between the presence of ES and the position of the mutations along OCRL domains. DD2 is distinct from LS. The mutation site and the mutation type largely determine the DD2 phenotype.

Novel pathogenic OCRL mutations and genotype–phenotype analysis of Chinese children affected by oculocerebrorenal syndrome: two cases and a literature review

Background Oculocerebrorenal syndrome of Lowe is a rare X-linked disorder characterized by congenital cataracts, mental retardation, and proximal tubulopathy. This condition is caused by a mutation of OCRL gene (located at chromosome Xq26.1), which encodes an inositol polyphosphate 5-phosphatase. Case presentation We identified two novel OCRL mutations in two unrelated Chinese boys, each with a severe phenotype of Lowe syndrome. A novel de novo deletion (hemizygous c.659_662delAGGG, p.E220Vfs*29) was present in patient 1 and a novel splicing mutation (hemizygous c.2257-2A > T) that was maternally inherited was present in patient 2. A renal biopsy in patient 2 indicated mild mesangial proliferative glomerulonephritis, mild focal mononuclear cells infiltration, and interstitial focal fibrosis. Moreover, renal expression of OCRL-1 protein in patient 2 was significantly reduced compared to a control patient with thin basement membrane disease. Conclusions This study reports two novel OCRL variants associated with severe ocular and neurologic deficiency, despite only mild renal dysfunction. Based on our two patients and a literature review, the genotype–phenotype correlation of OCRL mutations with this severe phenotype of Lowe syndrome suggest a possible clustering of missense, deletion, and nonsense mutations in the 5-phosphatase domain and Rho-GAP domain in the Chinese population.

A human stem cell resource to decipher the biochemical and cellular basis of neurodevelopmental defects in Lowe Syndrome

Human brain development is a complex process where multiple cellular and developmental events are co-ordinated to generate normal structure and function. Alteration in any of these events can impact brain development, manifesting clinically as neurodevelopmental disorders. Human genetic disorders of lipid metabolism often present with features of altered brain function. Lowe syndrome (LS), is a X-linked recessive disease with features of altered brain function. LS results from mutations in OCRL1 that encodes a phosphoinositide 5-phosphatase enzyme. However, the cellular mechanisms by which loss of OCRL1 leads to brain defects remain unknown. Human brain development involves several cellular and developmental features not conserved in other species and understanding such mechanisms remains a challenge. Rodent models of LS have been generated, but failed to recapitulate features of the human disease. Here we describe the generation of human stem cell lines from LS patients. Further, we present biochemical characterization of lipid metabolism in patient cell lines and demonstrate their use as a disease-in-a-dish model for understanding the mechanism by which loss of OCRL1 leads to altered cellular and physiological brain development.

Genomic sequencing of Lowe syndrome trios reveal a mechanism for the heterogeneity of neurodevelopmental phenotypes

Lowe syndrome is an X-linked recessive monogenic disorder resulting from mutations in the OCRL gene that encodes a phosphatidylinositol 4,5 bisphosphate 5-phosphatase. The disease affects three organs-the kidney, brain and eye and clinically manifests as proximal renal tubule dysfunction, neurodevelopmental delay and congenital cataract. Although Lowe syndrome is a monogenic disorder, there is considerable heterogeneity in clinical presentation; some individuals show primarily renal symptoms with minimal neurodevelopmental impact whereas others show neurodevelopmental defect with minimal renal symptoms. However, the molecular and cellular mechanisms underlying this clinical heterogeneity remain unknown. Here we analyze a Lowe syndrome family in whom affected members show clinical heterogeneity with respect to the neurodevelopmental phenotype despite carrying an identical mutation in the OCRL gene. Genome sequencing and variant analysis in this family identified a large number of damaging variants in each patient. Using novel analytical pipelines and segregation analysis we prioritize variants uniquely present in the patient with the severe neurodevelopmental phenotype compared to those with milder clinical features. The identity of genes carrying such variants underscore the role of additional gene products enriched in the brain or highly expressed during brain development that may be determinants of the neurodevelopmental phenotype in Lowe syndrome. We also identify a heterozygous variant in CEP290, previously implicated in ciliopathies that underscores the potential role of OCRL in regulating ciliary function that may impact brain development. More generally, our findings demonstrate analytic approaches to identify high-confidence genetic variants that could underpin the phenotypic heterogeneity observed in monogenic disorders.

A 3D Renal Proximal Tubule on Chip Model Phenocopies Lowe Syndrome and Dent II Disease Tubulopathy

Lowe syndrome and Dent II disease are X-linked monogenetic diseases characterised by a renal reabsorption defect in the proximal tubules and caused by mutations in the OCRL gene, which codes for an inositol-5-phosphatase. The life expectancy of patients suffering from Lowe syndrome is largely reduced because of the development of chronic kidney disease and related complications. There is a need for physiological human in vitro models for Lowe syndrome/Dent II disease to study the underpinning disease mechanisms and to identify and characterise potential drugs and drug targets. Here, we describe a proximal tubule organ on chip model combining a 3D tubule architecture with fluid flow shear stress that phenocopies hallmarks of Lowe syndrome/Dent II disease. We demonstrate the high suitability of our in vitro model for drug target validation. Furthermore, using this model, we demonstrate that proximal tubule cells lacking OCRL expression upregulate markers typical for epithelial–mesenchymal transition (EMT), including the transcription factor SNAI2/Slug, and show increased collagen expression and deposition, which potentially contributes to interstitial fibrosis and disease progression as observed in Lowe syndrome and Dent II disease.