Know Your Meme (KYM) is a website devoted to compiling histories,
definitions, and examples of internet memes. In the last decade, KYM has become popular
among researchers, educators, and day-to-day Web users to understand memes and their
meanings. As a result, it has become instrumental in establishing dominant histories of
memes on the Web. This paper uses a discursive interface analysis of the KYM website along
with the examples of Pepe the Frog, OK Boomer, and niche Facebook meme groups to demonstrate
how the website constructs itself as a cultural authority to define and classify memes, and
that an overreliance on KYM can have significant stakes. It may overlook entire uses of the
meme, potentially downplay harmful ideologies, and generally imply the possibility for a
meme to have a single primary meaning. I argue that an overreliance on KYM without
acknowledging its limitations tends to overlook the essential plurality of the Web and
instead implies a singular history of memes as an element of internet culture. However, KYM
can still be a useful resource and to that end, ultimately, I conclude that we should move
toward defining KYM as, “a curated collection of user-submitted meme instances and partially
crowdsourced definitions.” While KYM is undeniably a useful resource, it is important that
those of us who study the histories of the Web are mindful about how we lean upon this
particular website and situate it within our work.