Explaining the microbial diversity conundrum: can microbiome composition be crucial for host fitness, while highly divergent among healthy individuals?

Recent empirical studies offer conflicting findings regarding the relation between host fitness and the composition of its microbiome, a conflict which we term the microbial β-diversity conundrum: it has been shown that the microbiome is crucial for host wellbeing and survival. At the same time, different healthy individuals' microbiome compositions, even in the same population, often differ dramatically, contrary to the notion that a vital trait should be highly conserved. Moreover, gnotobiotic individuals exhibit highly deleterious phenotypes, supporting the notion that the microbiome is paramount to host fitness. However, the introduction of almost arbitrarily selected microbiota into the system often achieves a significant rescue effect of the deleterious phenotypes, even microbiota from soil or phylogenetically distant host species, highlighting an apparent paradox. Here we suggest several solutions to the paradox using a computational framework, simulating the population dynamics of hosts and their microbiomes over multiple generations. The answers, relating to factors such as host population size, the specific mode of contribution of the microbes to host fitness, and the typical microbiome richness, offer solutions to the conundrum by creating scenarios where even when a host's fitness is determined in full by its microbiome composition, this composition has little or no effect on the natural selection dynamics of the population.

A wMel Wolbachia variant in Aedes aegypti from field-collected Drosophila melanogaster with increased phenotypic stability under heat stress

Mosquito-borne diseases such as dengue, Zika and chikungunya remain a major cause of morbidity and mortality across tropical regions. Population replacement strategies involving the wMel strain of Wolbachia are being used widely to control mosquito-borne diseases transmitted by Aedes aegypti. However, these strategies may be influenced by environmental temperature because wMel is vulnerable to heat stress. wMel infections in their native host Drosophila melanogaster are genetically diverse, but few transinfections of wMel variants have been generated in Ae. aegypti mosquitoes. Here we successfully transferred a wMel variant (termed wMelM) originating from a field-collected D. melanogaster population from Victoria, Australia into Ae. aegypti. The new wMelM variant (clade I) is genetically distinct from the original wMel transinfection (clade III) generated over ten years ago, and there are no genomic differences between wMelM in its original and transinfected host. We compared wMelM with wMel in its effects on host fitness, temperature tolerance, Wolbachia density, vector competence, cytoplasmic incompatibility and maternal transmission under heat stress in a controlled background. wMelM showed a higher heat tolerance than wMel, with stronger cytoplasmic incompatibility and maternal transmission when eggs were exposed to heat stress, likely due to higher overall densities within the mosquito. Both wMel variants had minimal host fitness costs, complete cytoplasmic incompatibility and maternal transmission, and dengue virus blocking under standard laboratory conditions. Our results highlight phenotypic differences between closely related Wolbachia variants. wMelM shows potential as an alternative strain to wMel in dengue control programs in areas with strong seasonal temperature fluctuations.

Gut microbiome composition, not alpha diversity, is associated with survival in a natural vertebrate population

Background The vertebrate gut microbiome (GM) can vary substantially across individuals within the same natural population. Although there is evidence linking the GM to health in captive animals, very little is known about the consequences of GM variation for host fitness in the wild. Here, we explore the relationship between faecal microbiome diversity, body condition, and survival using data from the long-term study of a discrete natural population of the Seychelles warbler (Acrocephalus sechellensis) on Cousin Island. To our knowledge, this is the first time that GM differences associated with survival have been fully characterised for a natural vertebrate species, across multiple age groups and breeding seasons. Results We identified substantial variation in GM community structure among sampled individuals, which was partially explained by breeding season (5% of the variance), and host age class (up to 1% of the variance). We also identified significant differences in GM community membership between adult birds that survived, versus those that had died by the following breeding season. Individuals that died carried increased abundances of taxa that are known to be opportunistic pathogens, including several ASVs in the genus Mycobacterium. However, there was no association between GM alpha diversity (the diversity of bacterial taxa within a sample) and survival to the next breeding season, or with individual body condition. Additionally, we found no association between GM community membership and individual body condition. Conclusions These results demonstrate that components of the vertebrate GM can be associated with host fitness in the wild. However, further research is needed to establish whether changes in bacterial abundance contribute to, or are only correlated with, differential survival; this will add to our understanding of the importance of the GM in the evolution of host species living in natural populations.

Molecular Rationale of Insect-Microbes Symbiosis—From Insect Behaviour to Mechanism

Insects nurture a panoply of microbial populations that are often obligatory and exist mutually with their hosts. Symbionts not only impact their host fitness but also shape the trajectory of their phenotype. This co-constructed niche successfully evolved long in the past to mark advanced ecological specialization. The resident microbes regulate insect nutrition by controlling their host plant specialization and immunity. It enhances the host fitness and performance by detoxifying toxins secreted by the predators and abstains them. The profound effect of a microbial population on insect physiology and behaviour is exploited to understand the host–microbial system in diverse taxa. Emergent research of insect-associated microbes has revealed their potential to modulate insect brain functions and, ultimately, control their behaviours, including social interactions. The revelation of the gut microbiota–brain axis has now unravelled insects as a cost-effective potential model to study neurodegenerative disorders and behavioural dysfunctions in humans. This article reviewed our knowledge about the insect–microbial system, an exquisite network of interactions operating between insects and microbes, its mechanistic insight that holds intricate multi-organismal systems in harmony, and its future perspectives. The demystification of molecular networks governing insect–microbial symbiosis will reveal the perplexing behaviours of insects that could be utilized in managing insect pests.

Horizontal gene transfer-mediated bacterial strain variation affects host fitness in Drosophila

Background How microbes affect host fitness and environmental adaptation has become a fundamental research question in evolutionary biology. To better understand the role of microbial genomic variation for host fitness, we tested for associations of bacterial genomic variation and Drosophila melanogaster offspring number in a microbial Genome Wide Association Study (GWAS). Results We performed a microbial GWAS, leveraging strain variation in the genus Gluconobacter, a genus of bacteria that are commonly associated with Drosophila under natural conditions. We pinpoint the thiamine biosynthesis pathway (TBP) as contributing to differences in fitness conferred to the fly host. While an effect of thiamine on fly development has been described, we show that strain variation in TBP between bacterial isolates from wild-caught D. melanogaster contributes to variation in offspring production by the host. By tracing the evolutionary history of TBP genes in Gluconobacter, we find that TBP genes were most likely lost and reacquired by horizontal gene transfer (HGT). Conclusion Our study emphasizes the importance of strain variation and highlights that HGT can add to microbiome flexibility and potentially to host adaptation.

Gut microbiome composition, not alpha diversity, is associated with survival in a natural vertebrate population

Background: The vertebrate gut microbiome (GM) can vary substantially across individuals within the same natural population. Although there is evidence linking the GM to health in captive animals, very little is known about the consequences of GM variation for host fitness in the wild. Here, we explore the relationship between faecal microbiome diversity, body condition and survival using data from the long-term study of a discrete natural population of the Seychelles warbler ( Acrocephalus sechellensis ) on Cousin Island. To our knowledge, this is the first time that GM differences associated with survival have been fully characterised for a natural vertebrate species, across multiple age groups and breeding seasons. Results: We identified substantial variation in GM community structure among sampled individuals, which was partially explained by breeding season (7% of the variance), and host age class (up to 1% of the variance). We also identified significant differences in GM community membership between individuals that survived, versus those that had died by the following breeding season. Individuals that died carried reduced abundances of beneficial taxa in the bacterial order Clostridiales , but increased abundances of taxa that are known to be opportunistic pathogens (e.g. members of the Chloroflexi and Propionibacteriales ). However, there was no association between GM alpha diversity (the diversity of bacterial taxa within a sample) and survival to the next breeding season, or with individual body condition. Additionally, we found no association between GM community membership and individual body condition. Conclusions: These results demonstrate that components of the vertebrate GM can be associated with host fitness in the wild, although whether changes in bacterial abundance contribute to, or are only correlated with, the differential survival observed remains unclear. Importantly, it suggests that components of the GM may be under selection, and, thus, could have the potential to influence the evolution of host species living in natural populations.

The symbiotic relationship between Caenorhabditis elegans and members of its microbiome contributes to worm fitness and lifespan extension

Background A healthy microbiome influences host physiology through a mutualistic relationship, which can be important for the host to cope with cellular stress by promoting fitness and survival. The mammalian microbiome is highly complex and attributing host phenotypes to a specific member of the microbiome can be difficult. The model organism Caenorhabditis elegans and its native microbiome, discovered recently, can serve as a more tractable, experimental model system to study host-microbiome interactions. In this study, we investigated whether certain members of C. elegans native microbiome would offer a benefit to their host and putative molecular mechanisms using a combination of phenotype screening, omics profiling and functional validation. Results A total of 16 members of C. elegans microbiome were screened under chemically-induced toxicity. Worms grown with Chryseobacterium sp. CHNTR56 MYb120 or Comamonas sp. 12022 MYb131, were most resistant to oxidative chemical stress (SiO2 nanoparticles and juglone), as measured by progeny output. Further investigation showed that Chryseobacterium sp. CHNTR56 positively influenced the worm’s lifespan, whereas the combination of both isolates had a synergistic effect. RNAseq analysis of young adult worms, grown with either isolate, revealed the enrichment of cellular detoxification mechanisms (glutathione metabolism, drug metabolism and metabolism of xenobiotics) and signaling pathways (TGF-beta and Wnt signaling pathways). Upregulation of cysteine synthases (cysl genes) in the worms, associated with glutathione metabolism, was also observed. Nanopore sequencing uncovered that the genomes of the two isolates have evolved to favor the specific route of the de novo synthesis pathway of vitamin B6 (cofactor of cysl enzymes) through serC or pdxA2 homologs. Finally, co-culture with vitamin B6 extended worm lifespan. Conclusions In summary, our study indicates that certain colonizing members of C. elegans have genomic diversity in vitamin B6 synthesis and promote host fitness and lifespan extension. The regulation of host cellular detoxification genes (i.e. gst) along with cysl genes at the transcriptome level and the bacterium-specific vitamin B6 synthesis mechanism at the genome level are in an agreement with enhanced host glutathione-based cellular detoxification due to this interspecies relationship. C. elegans is therefore a promising alternative model to study host-microbiome interactions in host fitness and lifespan.

Multiple generations of antibiotic exposure and isolation influence host fitness and the microbiome in a model zooplankton species

BackgroundChronic antibiotic exposure impacts host health through changes to the microbiome, increasing disease risk and reducing the functional repertoire of community members. The detrimental effects of antibiotic perturbation on microbiome structure and function after one host generation of exposure have been well-studied. However, much less is understood about the multigenerational effects of antibiotic exposure and how the microbiome may recover across host generations.ResultsIn this study, we examined microbiome composition and host fitness across five generations of exposure to a suite of three antibiotics in the model zooplankton host Daphnia magna. By utilizing a split-brood design where half of the offspring from antibiotic-exposed parents were allowed to recover and half were maintained in antibiotics, we aimed to examine recovery and resilience of the microbiome. Unexpectedly, we discovered that experimental isolation of single host individuals across generations also exerted a strong effect on microbiome composition, with composition becoming less diverse over generations regardless of treatment. Simultaneously, Daphnia magna body size and cumulative reproduction increased across generations while survival decreased. Though antibiotics did cause substantial changes to microbiome composition, the microbiome generally became similar to the no antibiotic control treatment within one generation of recovery no matter how many prior generations were spent in antibiotics.ConclusionsContrary to results found in vertebrate systems, Daphnia magna microbiome composition recovers quickly after antibiotic exposure. However, our results suggest that the isolation of individual hosts leads to the stochastic extinction of rare taxa in the microbiome, indicating that these taxa are likely maintained via transmission in host populations rather than intrinsic mechanisms. This may explain the intriguing result that microbiome diversity loss increased host fitness.