A room with a view in English nuisance law: exploring modernisation hidden within the ‘textbook tradition’
AbstractThe paper critically examines the consensus among tort scholars that an injured view can never be actionable in nuisance. The consensus, it is argued, is based on a problematic understanding of the permanence of early modern nuisance authority, and a neglect of modernisation in the definition of actionable injury in the nineteenth century, in response to industrialisation, urbanisation and, crucially, suburbanisation. David Sugarman's ‘textbook tradition’ provides a valuable disciplinary explanation for the mismatch between scholarly portrayals of doctrine and authoritative judicial formulations in decided cases.
Keyword(s):
2018 ◽
Vol 23
(1-2)
◽
pp. 135-158
◽
Keyword(s):
2019 ◽