AbstractA critical shortage of respirators, masks and other personal protective equipment (PPE) exists due to the COVID-19 pandemic. Of particular need are N95 respirators, which use meltblown microfibers of charged polypropylene. An intensive search is underway to find reliable methods to lengthen the useful life of these normally disposable units.Recent experiments on respirators cleaned with ethanol solutions found drastic post-treatment drops infiltration efficiency (>40%). This has been attributed to a mechanism whereby ethanol disrupts the charges in the microfibers, reducing their ability to trap particles. The CDC/NIOSH has issued guidance directing clinicians and researchers to pursue other methods of decontamination.In our experiments, we replicated the drop in efficiency after 70% ethanol treatment, but we found that the efficiency rose again after more effective drying, which we achieved with a vacuum chamber. After drying at pressures of < ∼6 mbar (0.6 kPa), the measured filtering efficiency rose to within 2% of the pre-washing value, and we found that this was sustained for 5 cleaning-drying cycles in three models of N95 masks. We stress that our tests are not meant to certify that the respirators are safe for use, which would require further, standardized, testing under NIOSH protocols. The tests presented here are used to understand basic mechanisms by which treatments can decrease or increase filtration efficiency.The main mechanism underlying the loss and recovery of filter efficiency seems to be the deposition and removal of water molecules adsorbed on the fiber surfaces, a hypothesis which is supported by several observations: (A) the filtering efficiency increases non-linearly with the weight loss during drying. (B) filtration efficiency shows an abrupt recovery as the vacuum pressure drops from 13 to 6 mbar, the range physically attributable to the removal of adsorbed water. (C) Optical microscopy of the microfiber layer reveals surface wetting of the fibers, which is most resistant to drying in dense regions of the fiber network. These observations indicate that losses in filter efficiency may be caused by the wicking of water into the dense fiber networks, reducing the available surface area for filtration.Such a degradation mechanism has two implications: (A) Ethanol and other aqueous decontamination methods may be more viable than previously assumed. Investigations of such methods should specify drying methods in their protocols. We employ vacuum chambers in this study, but other methods of removing adsorbed water could be equivalent. (B) This mechanism presents the possibility that mask filtration performance may be subject to degradation by other sources of moisture, and that the mask would continue to be compromised even if it appears dry. Further research is needed to determine the conditions under which such risks apply, and whether drying should be a routine practice for respirators undergoing extended use.This study introduces a number of methods which could be developed and validated for use in resource-limited settings. As the pandemic continues to spread in rural areas and developing nations, these would allow for local efforts to decontaminate, restore, and test medical masks.
Can N95 respirators be reused after disinfection? And for how many times?
