Review of A23.3-94 simplified method of shear design and comparison with results using shear friction
A review of the so-called simplified method of shear design described in CSA A23.3-94 "Design of concrete structures" shows that the method is not simple. The designer is required to check numerous equations and limits. The resulting relation between stirrup spacing and shear strength is found to be an extremely complex line resulting from the intersection of seven separate surfaces. A shear friction model has been developed which seems to predict the shear strength of beams rather well. Stirrups and longitudinal reinforcement provide a clamping force thereby increasing the friction force which can be transferred across a crack along a potential failure plane. This model is based on the shear strength after cracking so that no diagonal tension strength is included. The shear friction model has been used as the basis for determining approximate equations for maximum stirrup spacing. A comparison of these approximate shear friction predictions with those using the simplified method indicates a high degree of correlation but many important differences. It seems that shear design can be clarified as well as simplified by adoption of the shear friction approach.Key words: reinforced concrete, shear, shear friction, shear tests, stirrup spacing.